[Discussion] What if obito had his both eyes ?

[Sidpat]

Guys would obito would have become greater uchiha than madara and itachi ? , if had both his original sharingan eyes.

As we know obitio had ideology similar to naruto uptill rins death after that he changed , that why he had images in his mind i this issue if the past would be different .

Obito's sharingan is very unique , and there is no counter measure against kamui expect the one of kakashi .

If had both his sharingan , i THINK HIS KAMUI WOULD HAVE LEFT MINOTO THUNDER FLASH IN DUST , AND ALSO ADD TO THAT HE WOULD HAVE SASUNO AND Amaterasu

 

[Cfighter]

1. Theres no evidence to support he would have Amaterasu.
2. He wouldn't be in the same LEAGUE as Madara of Itachi, eyes or no eyes
3. His ideology is more like Pain than Naruto (which is why he fails as a villain, because we've already seen how this ends)
4. Kamui is haxed. If Obito had both his eyes, he wouldn't need ANYTHING else. He could solo everyone with a kunai, because there wouldn't be a thing anyone could do to stop him from just hiding out in his dimension for as long as he wanted.

 

[Anonn]

Obito would be way to OP.

 

[UchihaMifune]

1. Theres no evidence to support he would have Amaterasu.
2. He wouldn't be in the same LEAGUE as Madara of Itachi, eyes or no eyes
3. His ideology is more like Pain than Naruto (which is why he fails as a villain, because we've already seen how this ends)
4. Kamui is haxed. If Obito had both his eyes, he wouldn't need ANYTHING else. He could solo everyone with a kunai, because there wouldn't be a thing anyone could do to stop him from just hiding out in his dimension for as long as he wanted.

Hahaha u really believe that? I'm not saying obito would mop the the floor with them, but one one one against either of them would be an even fight the way I see it (even without both eyes)

 

[kunde]

gg (10 chars)

 

[Cfighter]

Hahaha u really believe that? I'm not saying obito would mop the the floor with them, but one one one against either of them would be an even fight the way I see it (even without both eyes)

Are we assuming that he has the Rinnegan in this match up? I wrote that under the impression that he only had MS, in which case yeah, he wouldn't be as strong as Madara or Itachi. Madara should be obvious as to why he would kill Obito low-mid difficulty. Itachi and Obito are probably even, strength wise, but theres no way at all Obito trumps Itachi's battle smarts. So Itachi defeats Obito by intelligence.

 

[Underdog ninja]

So does this confirm sharingan > rinnegan?

 

[Uchiha Samater]

I have thought about this for a while and come to the following conclusion

His Kamui is just extremely difficult to beat, and that's with one eye, with both eyes he could attack with one eye from distance and defend with the other

You can argue some shinobi may formulate a way around it, [e.g. Minato when he managed to land a blow on Obito], however if it wasn't a death blow, he would just retreat and now know of another way he can be hit and just prepare a solution against it

It is an extremely convenient ability and way too haxx

HOWEVER.......

You can argue if he never was hurt and had both eyes, would he still be powerful enough, [without hashi dna], to spam it as much

 

[silmarill]

Kishi split those eyes for a reason, its just to much cheat 2 kamui for 1 person

 

[Avinash012]

Obito would be the strongest Uchiha even without Juubi that's for sure...

Guys would obito would have become greater uchiha than madara and itachi ? , if had both his original sharingan eyes.

As we know obitio had ideology similar to naruto uptill rins death after that he changed , that why he had images in his mind i this issue if the past would be different .

Obito's sharingan is very unique , and there is no counter measure against kamui expect the one of kakashi .

If had both his sharingan , i THINK HIS KAMUI WOULD HAVE LEFT MINOTO THUNDER FLASH IN DUST , AND ALSO ADD TO THAT HE WOULD HAVE SASUNO AND Amaterasu

I don't think he would have amaterasu also Minato can counter Obito's(close Range) as well as Kakashi's Kumui (Long range)..

Obito is already > Itachi ..even without his other Eye

 

[Sidpat]

I dont think u r right ,
1. About his ideology before rin died is almost similar to that of young narutu , he is the one who gave statement to kakashi that those who abondon their friends are worse that shit .

2. If he had both his eyes he would have made fodder of itachi , itachi says every jutsu has a week point but teel me one week point of kamui

3. with both eyes he can take a kunai in one hand dissaper from his original eye and make if appear in heart of opposite ninja even without touching or going near him as kakashi did with 8 tails

4. kakashi is not a uchiha so he cannot unlock full potential of his kamui

5. As for now obito biggest problem is he has to touch a person in order to attack him with kamui but if he had other one he can remain hidden and project his kamui

6. remember even Amaterasu cannot reack him due to his kamui as it occured when itachi had planted it in sauke eyes and it did not reach him at close range

 

[thunderthehybrid]

If Obito had both his eyes, he'd have both kamuis, and have susano'o

 

[Naruto KM V2]

he would be OP

 

[-ahhimane-]

If Obito had both eyes, he would have been blind before he engages into a fight during the Kyuubi attack or somewhere in the future since he relied on his MS too much.

 

[SixPathsOfTobi]

2. If he had both his eyes he would have made fodder of itachi , itachi says every jutsu has a week point but teel me one week point of kamui

You forgot about Konan beating obito if he didn't sacrifice a eye.. if konan would've known about izanaghi obito would've been dead.

he can remain intangible for about 5 minutes.. to suck himself up he needs to be materealized.. to attack he needs to be materialized.

 

[Harry Balzac]

He'd been exactly the same. He was one of the unlucky uchiha who couldn't possess more than 1 ability. Kakashi's kamui differ's from obito because of plot, simple that as that. It was not to give kakashi the same ability as obito otherwise his identity would have been spoiled. Note that their eyes became more and more similar to eachother as his identity was being revealed. Stop genjutsu'ing yourselves into believing he'd become the strongest uchiha, that's what naruto is trying to prevent.

 

[SixPathsOfTobi]

He'd been exactly the same. He was one of the unlucky uchiha who couldn't possess more than 1 ability. Kakashi's kamui differ's from obito because of plot, simple that as that. It was not to give kakashi the same ability as obito otherwise his identity would have been spoiled. Note that their eyes became more and more similar to eachother as his identity was being revealed.

Kakashi's eye aims away in the distance, while obito's eye sucks things inward inside the eye..
Obito always needs to get close and even contact someone that he wants to suck up.
The only thing that changed is that kakashi is able to get himself out of the dimension.

 

[Harry Balzac]

And Obito managed to stop kakashi from rolling gedo mazou's head off with kamui from a distance. And kakashi warped out 8 tails from his eye.

 

[Takos]

Guys would obito would have become greater uchiha than madara and itachi ? , if had both his original sharingan eyes.

As we know obitio had ideology similar to naruto uptill rins death after that he changed , that why he had images in his mind i this issue if the past would be different .

Obito's sharingan is very unique , and there is no counter measure against kamui expect the one of kakashi .

If had both his sharingan , i THINK HIS KAMUI WOULD HAVE LEFT MINOTO THUNDER FLASH IN DUST , AND ALSO ADD TO THAT HE WOULD HAVE SASUNO AND Amaterasu

What is "as Itachi" supposed to mean?
Obito has surpassed Itachi long ago, even before obtaining the Rinnegan.

Seriously, Itachi has absolutely no way to touch Obito (Tsukyomi was broken by a non-MS Uchiha mediocre in genjutsu, so imagine an MS Uchiha with genjutsu mastery falling to it), while all Obito needs is to touch Itachi. Game over.

Also, Obito with both MS would be a beast PROVIDED he can keep his Senju DNA. It's thanks to it that he can spam Kamui as he does, so without it, even with both MS eyes, he'd be around his current level, that is, Kakashi's level (because Obito and Kakashi are pretty much equal, with Kakashi having the edge). (Aka - he could take out anyone with 1-hit-KO-Kamui, but if he couldn't for some reason, he'd lose shortly after from overusing Kamui's defensive version)

 

[Jcub]

I will keep my thoughts short.

Not sure if he would be any better with both.

Both Kakashi and Obito have had their "eyes" for a long time, I think the moment they were not together they start becoming different uses. Kakashi hid his and only used it when nessarly, essentially reserving it, might be why he is better at long range. Where as Obito used his a lot, might be why he has to be so close. (think near sighted/far sighted)

Kamui is effective, but not unbeatable, Kakashi had problems with people or objects moving to fast or irradically (sp?). He was going to Kamui the beast bombs but they were going to be on a set path with a common focus point, it was a matter of timing not speed.

Just so we are clear, he would be a beast, just not completely unstoppable. Remember both eyes and you have Naruto with crazier abilities.

Kakashi and Obito sharing eyes (as a team) is more effective than just Obito with both, just saying.