[Discussion] We have the right to criticise Kishi

[Mugiwara kun]

We the readers have the right to criticise Kishi If we feel he isn't doing a good job So I don't understand why some hot-heads on this base will say "If you don't like the manga, drop it " ...I mean wtf!!! How do you expect us to drop it when It's coming to a close. Just because we criticise doesn't mean we don't like it. I take exceptions to anyone tells another person to "drop the manga" just because of a little critisicim. *drops mic!*

 

[Seventh Sama]

Ok, You can criticize but just dont shove it down people's throats who actually enjoy the manga.

 

[reizon]

those who say, "if you dont like the manga then just drop it" just for criticising the manga, they are biggest bunch of idiots...!!

 

[Mugiwara kun]

those who say, "if you dont like the manga then just drop it" just for criticising the manga, they are biggest bunch of idiots...!!

the biggest of the biggest

 

[Mugiwara kun]

Ok, You can criticize but just dont shove it down people's throats who actually enjoy the manga.

no one actually does that.

 

[Titania Erza]

no one actually does that.

Everybody does, if one person says (s)he enjoyed the recent chapters 10 people will jump on him/her telling to f*ck off and stop acting like an idiot.

Besides you can give critics, but some people have the impression that they are allowed to force Kishi to rewrite the latest arc...

 

[Jack Spicer]

Yeah, we do.

The manga has become shit.

 

[Naruto X Hunter]

Ok, You can criticize but just dont shove it down people's throats who actually enjoy the manga.

Indeed,i see the same people in multiple threads insulting Kishimoto and bashing the manga.If they don't like it.Don't come to a Naruto site,going in multiple Naruto threads,complaining amongst people who like the manga and don't want to see someone whining all the time.

Yeah, we do.

The manga has become shit.

What really makes you have the right? Cause you used to like the manga? How many volumes have you bought? How many years(?) have you been reading online for free without ever buying a single volume yet your so quick to bash the manga in a place where people who enjoy the manga go,just cause you don't like it currently.

 

[Recable]

Also when people say "You can't say a part of the manga is bad when you can't even make a manga" is stupid since that's like saying "You can't say a part of a manga is good since you can't make one".

 

[Zakler2k9]

You can criticize IF, you buy original shonenjump ,viz translation or Naruto Comics not reading online for free

and yeah recent chapter piss me off

 

[Seventh Sama]

no one actually does that.

Tons of people do.
They act like they're being forced to read the manga.
Even if there's a good chapter, They'll still find a way to complain.

 

[Sage Moonblood]

There is a difference between criticize and bash. I respect criticism because I believe no manga is perfect but most people here just get upset because the story isn't going their way or something happens to their fav.

 

[The Invincible Ninja God]

Most of the criticism is saturated in ignorance.

They don't like something. They spam with @sspull,plot-hole or some other nonsense even though the explanation is right there in the manga. They may not like the explanation and feel it's too convenient. but why Lie about it by calling it something it's not. Someone who actually pays attention points out where the explanation is in the manga and they are immediately bashed as fanboys. Simply because they understood something those bashers couldn't process. It's hella annoying to see the same people complain about things that have been explained to them who knows how many times.

Take the reveal that the Uchiha tablet was tampered with for example, Black Zetsu was manipulating the Uchiha, so why do people still refer back to things Itachi said about awakening mangekyou as basis to say such and such is an asspull?

It's like they are five year old's with short attention spans.

They come off as spoon-fed whining Idiots.

 

[Cooh]

What really makes you have the right? Cause you used to like the manga? How many volumes have you bought? How many years(?) have you been reading online for free without ever buying a single volume yet your so quick to bash the manga in a place where people who enjoy the manga go,just cause you don't like it currently.

The right of free speech makes you have the right. People may have a different opinion on the current state of the manga then you do. You'll have to accept that.

 

[kageking]

Yes we have a right. I have a right to constantly criticize any and everything around me. I don't, because I wouldn't want to be an overbearing scumbag armchair critic that does nothing but berate the efforts of others and assume that I could do it so much better than they can. That's me exercising my right to not be a vicious ****ty plague of a human being.

 

[Florio]

Yes we have a right. I have a right to constantly criticize any and everything around me. I don't, because I wouldn't want to be an overbearing scumbag armchair critic that does nothing but berate the efforts of others and assume that I could do it so much better than they can. That's me exercising my right to not be a vicious ****ty plague of a human being.

Your logic is failure. How does criticizing something make you a shitty plague on humanity? Many creative minds actually greatly appreciate good criticism. There is nothing wrong with being a critic, unless of course your being a critic towards people themselves. But we are only critiquing a manga, so no harm done.

 

[B00m]

No you don't, we don't even know him.

You do have a right to evaluate his manga as you see fit. Like crying about a shitty, free, chapter but your complaints will do nothing. So why make them? About a free read nonetheless.

 

[Madara mhm]

Who's saying you don't have the right? Ofcourse we have the right, is it likely he gives a sht cause it's his manga? Highly doubtful, We have a right to give a thorough opinion of the manga as his fans and readers, but on the guy himself? No that's just outrageous, don't have the right to criticise him as a person if we don't know the fella.

 

[Jimihendrix]

you can criticize kishi, yes, and call him out on his inconsistent writing. What you can't do, however, is label anything as an asspull because it's kishi's manga and he can do whatever he wants with it--even making it so Sakura can harm Kaguya (even though she was so frightened by a measly Madara she forgot to breathe).

So yeah, nothing in the manga is an asspull, but there can be inconsistensies with the writing.

 

[Jimihendrix]

but then again, you are reading his manga for free...