[Discussion] We have the right to criticise Kishi

[Lana Del Taka]

It's shit right now. That is all.

 

[ninjarasengan]

you can criticize kishi, yes, and call him out on his inconsistent writing. What you can't do, however, is label anything as an asspull because it's kishi's manga and he can do whatever he wants with it--even making it so Sakura can harm Kaguya (even though she was so frightened by a measly Madara she forgot to breathe).

So yeah, nothing in the manga is an asspull, but there can be inconsistensies with the writing.

are we labeling character growth as inconsistency...you know maybe she developed after being called useless by Sasuke.

remember naruto in p1? he froze facing the demon bros, got dissed by sasuke and went on to face the killing intent beast zabuza.

calling inconsistency is just disgruntled fan bull because the person really has nothing to complain about. grasping at straws.

 

[Jimihendrix]

are we labeling character growth as inconsistency...you know maybe she developed after being called useless by Sasuke.

remember naruto in p1? he froze facing the demon bros, got dissed by sasuke and went on to face the killing intent beast zabuza.

calling inconsistency is just disgruntled fan bull because the person really has nothing to complain about. grasping at straws.

Because she was called useless? She went from being frozen from a not fully powered up Madara to being able to confidently sttack the proginetor of chakra? riiiiight... Kishi didn't establish any resolve from her, just that she's also a woman.

Does this make woman in Kishi's eye nonfactor? Madara, who's weaker than Kaguya, warrants more fear? Don't try to justify inconsistency, you just look really petty

 

[ninjarasengan]

Because she was called useless? She went from being frozen from a not fully powered up Madara to being able to confidently sttack the proginetor of chakra? riiiiight... Kishi didn't establish any resolve from her, just that she's also a woman.

Does this make woman in Kishi's eye nonfactor? Madara, who's weaker than Kaguya, warrants more fear? Don't try to justify inconsistency, you just look really petty

Nah bro you seem petty...almost like you're letting hatred for a fictional character cloud your mind.

Sakura was not with her team while facing down madara was she? Why could Naruto face down Zabuza who was stronger than the demon brothers?

Read chapter 676 again. Sakura already re-established her resolve. Ironically against Madara himself, after he powered up by gaining double Rennegan...and this right here is why complainers are tiresome.

people who go on about Kishi's so called sexism are usually just projecting their own onto him, so whatever...

 

[ultraChalk]

Ok, You can criticize but just dont shove it down people's throats who actually enjoy the manga.

There are plenty people who voice their negative opinions without shoving it, and people will still leave those retarded 'Kishi dun care' responses.

It annoys me.

Everybody does, if one person says (s)he enjoyed the recent chapters 10 people will jump on him/her telling to f*ck off and stop acting like an idiot.

Please link me to the thread that happened last, because at the moment I don't believe you.

Tons of people do.
They act like they're being forced to read the manga.
Even if there's a good chapter, They'll still find a way to complain.

Good is subjective, so what gives you the right to determine whether or not their reactions are warranted?

 

[Nakagami]

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, you with your critiquing, and others telling you to drop the manga. No one is pointing a gun to your head.

Fanfiction was created for this reason. Just because you read the original, doesn't mean you will agree with everything written, and tbh I have read fanfiction that had better plot ideas then some of the original work in books/anime/manga, however we must not forget that these characters/universes would not exist if not for the creator, so you may not like what they are doing, but they are the reason you have these amazing characters to like and talk about.

 

[Cael]

you can criticise when your a paying customer

 

[Reboryushon]

"..If we feel he isn't doing a good job"..

Actually no one can say that he is doing a bad or good job. You can simply say that you don't like his work or what he is doing to the series and that is it.

 

[Mugiwara kun]

Thanks guys, for all your opinions. I actually believe bashing is bad but whether we read the manga for free or not,we all have expectations week in, week out and when they are not met,we can act as critics but bashing does no one any good