Uchiha massacre defenders.

[Exaar]

There was room for more negotiation imo, so the massacre could've been prevented. What Konoha's mistake was that they went on with the massacre before giving diplomacy a chance to resolve matters including addressing the reasons for the uchiha clan's discontent.

Well hiruzen was more than willing to talk and attempted to delay any action against them as long as he could, All it would've taken is Fugaku to reach out to him, even in secret.

Uchiha also share some of the blame for the lack of communication between them.

 

[Mori Jin]

Maggot food is all they are

 

[Avani]

When I said "I expected and argument, I received salt instead" I was talking about my example with Hyuuga vs Uchiha thing, not you.

I wasn't going off topic with my original post, nor did I start this argument in the first place, but I will leave it at that.

Oh ok. I just glanced, didn't read it.

Well if you don't wish to start arguments a good way is not to quote people or insinuate stuff about them for it was instantly picked up by other members too. Yea no problem.

 

[sayian]

Genocides and rebellions were common then even during ww1. Didn't really become pure taboo till hitler regime.

 

[Darth AniCetuS]

Well hiruzen was more than willing to talk and attempted to delay any action against them as long as he could, All it would've taken is Fugaku to reach out to him, even in secret.

Uchiha also share some of the blame for the lack of communication between them.

Indeed the uchihas too were at fault but Hiruzen was willing to wait some more and the other's should've respected that. Maybe seeing Hiruzen's sincerity the uchiha would've come to the talking table eventually.

 

[BenjerminGaye]

Indeed the uchihas too were at fault but Hiruzen was willing to wait some more and the other's should've respected that. Maybe seeing Hiruzen's sincerity the uchiha would've come to the talking table eventually.

by that time even shisui realized that it couldn't be prevented.

 

[Exaar]

Maybe seeing Hiruzen's sincerity the uchiha would've come to the talking table eventually.

maybe but it's doubtful.
Even shisui was going to resort to KA and in his final moments fugaku made it clear that himself and itachi walk different paths and had no hesitation in the path he chose for himself and the clan.

It was also apparent that fugaku had respect for hiruzen, as he named his son after hiruzen's father, Sasuke Sarutobi.

 

[Darth AniCetuS]

by that time even shisui realized that it couldn't be prevented.

maybe but it's doubtful.
Even shisui was going to resort to KA and in his final moments fugaku made it clear that himself and itachi walk different paths and had no hesitation in the path he chose for himself and the clan.

It was also apparent that fugaku had respect for hiruzen, as he named his son after hiruzen's father, Sasuke Sarutobi.

Still if Hiruzen wanted some more time to negotiate then he should've got that. I doubt he'd ask without having some hope that the uchihas would come around and he wouldn't risk giving more time to the uchiha to prepare for the coup if he didn't believe that there's some chance that the uchiha's could be convinced.
And I guess Shisui realized Danzo wanted nothing but the massacre to happen.

 

[Sagebee]

...........

Uchiha attacked because they thought they had no other choice but if shisui and itachi worked together they could force them to come up with a truce.

 

[AllKnowingShinobi]

>Philosophy
>Rick and morty

Honestly go read or listen to real philosophers, not nihilism hedonistic promoting shows that degrade what it means to be human.

ive read alot of philosophers and its really depressing, for the reason that they are always down played and under appreciated in their time and even now any philosophers can tell you the world we live in is for the capitalist morons and tools like your self who cant appreciate art/writing/cultures because of your our stupid idealistic view on the world, it is as bleak as child in sitting in front of a show of tom and jerry for hours.

so before you know what real news is and fake bullshit go **** yourself

 

[Avani]

Uchiha attacked because they thought they had no other choice but if shisui and itachi worked together they could force them to come up with a truce.

Izanami was introduced much later. So I'm not sure when Itachi learned to use it but he still awakened MS after Shisui's death only. If Shisui wanted to use his MS to make them change their mind or to force them to do what he wished controlling their actions (as suggest in the manga) it meant Uchihas had already rejected the talks by then. Yea, Danzou was a jealous and ambitious cruel schemer who forced Itachi's hand. But since he indirectly killed Shisui/stole his eye and Uchiha were not going to change their mind now that they couldn't be forced, that option is moot. Also Shisui couldn't use it for next 10 years once he was done. It was a temporary truce at best though I would agree that extra time could have both sides to rethink their choices.

It's like discussing if Titanic could be saved while sitting in a classroom, decades after it drowned. That was then. People did what they thought they had to, to minimize the damage. Some people on both sides made wrong choices.

PS: Sorry I accidentally edited out my post.

 

[Clown World]

ive read alot of philosophers and its really depressing, for the reason that they are always down played and under appreciated in their time and even now any philosophers can tell you the world we live in is for the capitalist morons and tools like your self who cant appreciate art/writing/cultures because of your our stupid idealistic view on the world, it is as bleak as child in sitting in front of a show of tom and jerry for hours.

so before you know what real news is and fake bullshit go **** yourself

Think im a capitalist and a materialist? dont assume shit u have no idea about, you realise most good philosophers are the opposite of what you perceive them as, makes me think you have read barely any of them, barely any promote existential nihilism, and most try and convey a deeper meaning to life. The all knowing shinobi knows jack shit.

 

[AllKnowingShinobi]

Think im a capitalist and a materialist? dont assume shit u have no idea about, you realise most good philosophers are the opposite of what you perceive them as, makes me think you have read barely any of them, barely any promote existential nihilism, and most try and convey a deeper meaning to life. The all knowing shinobi knows jack shit.

How about you do me a favor take your users name advice. Sucking on the tits of philosophers is quiet sad. Its one thing to knowledge an idea than to follow it,sheep.

 

[Brady]

Well hiruzen was more than willing to talk and attempted to delay any action against them as long as he could, All it would've taken is Fugaku to reach out to him, even in secret.

Uchiha also share some of the blame for the lack of communication between them.

I think you forgot the Uchiha weren't allowed to "clear" their name. The elders simply saw fit to segregate them and keep an eye on them rather than just talk. They seemed more interested in catching the Uchiha in an act, or forcing the hand of the Uchiha than actually finding out whether they were really guilty.

 

[unknownvillain1254]

Itachi wasn't that smart.

He later regrets his actions. He knew later on, probably moments after the massacre that it was the dumbest move he had ever made. He saw that his move was so flawed that he even thought of telling Sasuke the whole truth if he could go back in time.

Can you please show the manga scan

 

[unknownvillain1254]

Notice the people here who say "There's no such thing as justified or unjustified killing in the this feudal system" most of them shit on Sasuke for wanting to do the same to Konoha.:lol

Then again, hypocrisy is a common trait among Sasuke haters so I'm not surprised.:bdpf:

Apples and oranges

 

[whiteboy2345]

Can you please show the manga scan

Don't even act like you didn't read the scan where he regrets his actions saying that Sasuke could have changed the Uchiha if he knew the truth.

 

[unknownvillain1254]

Don't even act like you didn't read the scan where he regrets his actions saying that Sasuke could have changed the Uchiha if he knew the truth.

Okay mr. white supremacist Now I understand for your people understanding details and information is hard but show me the scan where he said I regret killing my clan

 

[whiteboy2345]

Okay mr. white supremacist Now I understand for your people understanding details and information is hard but show me the scan where he said I regret killing my clan

If Itachi didn't regret his actions, he wouldn't have considered telling Sasuke who was an eight year old at the time, the truth about the Uchiha's tensions with Konoha.

My username means I'm a white supremacist? Okay, so because you're black you're a criminal right? Great to know where we both stand in life.

 

[unknownvillain1254]

If Itachi didn't regret his actions, he wouldn't have considered telling Sasuke who was an eight year old at the time, the truth about the Uchiha's tensions with Konoha.

My username means I'm a white supremacist? Okay, so because you're black you're a criminal right? Great to know where we both stand in life.

LOL let's be serious I know white supremacist when I see one I'll read your theories let's not play stupid you call a demon by its name .

And just like I said you have no scan of him saying anything