[VS] Tournament bracket to determine pirate king

[straightup]

I propose we do a contest. Everyone submits their top 16 strongest characters and from that pull we pick the 12 most chosen. With those 12 we set up a bracket and every week we will vote on the winner. Each winner will progress until we have the absolute strongest character. (Excluding roger ofcourse)

My 16

Akainu
Whitebeard
Big mom
Shanks
Luffy
Kaidu
Dolflamingo
Aokiji
Garp
Sengoku
Zoro
Mihawk
Weeble
Rob lucci
Marco
Blackbeard


That is my 16.

I will give up to the first 20 responses or 2 days and then I will tally it up and restructure the thread to a bracket. Once in bracket I will start going down the list. Each character vs will have one day to gather votes.

Any questions or thoughts let me know. Let’s do this and have fun!

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Top 16 to contend for Pirate King?

Shanks
Blackbeard
Whitebeard
Kaido
Linlin
Rayleigh
Mihawk
Garp
Sengoku
Akainu
Aokiji
Kizaru
Dragon
Shiki
Luffy (main character)
Marco/Dogtooth

Those are the people I think are strong enough but some people already think that there are characters stronger than the Pirate King.

 

[SMX]

any 16?
luffy
kid
roger
akainu
whitebeard
kaido
blackbeard
dragon
marco
katakuri
sabo
zoro
law
mihawk
kizaru
shanks

 

[TheNuetrix]

16. Katakuri/Luffy
15. Shiryu/Magellan
14. Weevil
13. Rayleigh
12. Marco
11. Sengoku
10. Garp
9. Fujitora
8. Kizaru
7. Mihawk
6. Aokiji
5. Big Mom
4. Akainu
3. Blackbeard
2. Kaido
1. Shanks

Yes i think Magellan is underrated. Also I excluded Dragon, Benn Beckman, Smoothie etc. because they all lack enough info. and feats to be fairly ranked.

 

[chopstickchakra]

This is their pinnacle of strength right so Luffy we haven't seen yet, and how do we remove the MC element from this because we know Luffy will be PK so how can we argue against him?

Anyway we have;
Luffy
Shanks
Kaidou
Whitebeard
Big Mom
Teach
Akainu
Aokiji
Kizaru
Garp
Sengoku
Mihawk
Weevil
Law
Buggy
Sogeking/Usopp w/ prep.

Ace had he stayed alive.

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

16. Katakuri/Luffy
15. Shiryu/Magellan
14. Weevil
13. Rayleigh
12. Marco
11. Sengoku
10. Garp
9. Fujitora
8. Mihawk
7. Kizaru
6. Aokiji
5. Big Mom
4. Akainu
3. Blackbeard
2. Kaido
1. Shanks

Yes i think Magellan is heavily underrated. Also I excluded Dragon, Benn Beckman, Smoothie etc. because they all lack enough info. and feats to be fairly ranked.

But you added wevile?

 

[chopstickchakra]

But you added wevile?

Kizaru said Weevil was comparable to a young WB in strength, the others have hype but this is a measurable hype of sorts because we have a comparison to make that we don't with Smoothie, Ben or Dragon.

 

[TheNuetrix]

But you added wevile?

True Weevil's power set is still a mystery but at least he has some feats:
*His strength was praised by Kizaru and compared to a younger Whitebeard
*He defeated numerous NW pirate crews
*He casually talks about taking down guys like Marco and Luffy, who everyone knows are anything but pushovers, showing great confidence in his own combat abilities.

Also you misspelled "Weevil"

 

[straightup]

Choose any character other than roger! Doesn’t matter what character. As far as final strength vs hype only vs any other issues that may arise will be worked out through the tournament. That’s the fun of it all. Will the majority judge luffy based off of final or current? Who knows. It’s all up to the majority. Same with any other character. If you guys decide in the polls that hype weevil beats marine ford doffy then that is the answer and weevil moves on etc.

Side note. If you picked roger it just won’t be counted. If you want to edit your post then go right ahead but please DONT NOT POST YOUR CHARACTERS AGAIN IN A SEPERATE POST. This will make to where a person doesn’t accidentally get two votes

 

[Sakazuki]

Top 16 to contend for Pirate King?

Shanks
Blackbeard
Whitebeard
Kaido
Linlin
Rayleigh
Mihawk
Garp
Sengoku
Akainu
Aokiji
Kizaru
Dragon
Shiki
Luffy (main character)
Marco/Dogtooth

Those are the people I think are strong enough but some people already think that their are characters stronger than the Pirate King.

Oda said the new generation > last
Current yonkos > (whitebeard, Rogers, shiki)
Current admirals > (garp, sengoku)
That's just what Oda said, just like luffy and his generation of yonkos will be >>> current ones

 

[Lord Tywin]

In order, all time
Luffy
BlackBeard
WhiteBeard
Akainu
Kaido
Garp
Mihawk
Reyleigh
Shanks
Kizaru
Aokiji
Dragon is probably in the top ten. I’d say he’s probably even higher than Akainu. But with no feats I put him last

 

[SixPathsMike101]

In power alone:


Luffy (plot)
Red Haired Shanks
Kaido
Teach
Big Mom
Monkey D. Dragon
Garp
Kizaru
Akainu
Dark King Rayleigh
Marco
Hawk-Eye Mihawk
Katakuri
Kuzan

I'm sure plenty of shanks crew and kaido's crew could be on here with more feats.

 

[Love Cook]

Sengoku
Garp
Shiki
Rayleigh

Fujitora
Ryokugyu
Kizaru
Kuzan
Aokiji -> Akainu
Kong
Mihawk

Blackbeard
Big Mom
Dragon
Kaidou
Shanks

My 16

 

[Passerby]

Sengoku
Garp
Shiki
Rayleigh

Fujitora
Ryokugyu
Kizaru
Kuzan
Aokiji
Kong
Mihawk

Blackbeard
Big Mom
Dragon
Kaidou
Shanks

My 16

Lmao .