@Michelle I would like your opinion on them as well.@Grammaton what's your reads on SK, XTMF and Ekkologix?
@Michelle I would like your opinion on them as well.@Grammaton what's your reads on SK, XTMF and Ekkologix?
There's a difference between forcing scum to dig themselves into a hole, and trying to dig a hole for a player with pointed questions. I'm not sure if this is a deliberate misinterpretation or not, but I perceived that you were doing the latter. Do you think all forms of questioning are inherently proactive?The post previous where Ultra stated that trying to make players look worse is scummy, when thats literally how you secure lynches on scum by making them fall apart under questioning. I legitimately dont understand how that could be a sentence written in a game of mafia.
Proactive? I mean were digging into semantics here, but generally yes, the act of trying to engage other players in such a way is a net positive as it at least gives the rest of the thread something to discuss, even in a world where the questions themselves are totally useless (which I dont think mine are).There's a difference between forcing scum to dig themselves into a hole, and trying to dig a hole for a player with pointed questions. I'm not sure if this is a deliberate misinterpretation or not, but I perceived that you were doing the latter. Do you think all forms of questioning are inherently proactive?
Soulkiller Im undecided on, he recently made a post I quite liked but pretty much anything before that I could take or leave. The other 2 have basically 0 contribution so cant even begin to feel one way or another.@Grammaton what's your reads on SK, XTMF and Ekkologix?
These are dangerous reads. You should explain them.Upto page 8,
Good people
Michelle
Grammaton
Ultra
Not liking:
XTMF
SK/Alice
Ekko (?)
Bro, this feels like an advanced reason or read on Alice when she only has a few posts. Pretty sure her entrance was NAI.I dont follow the analogy. In the post you quoted, Michelle did something that I perceived as very unlikely to be scum, which is why I retracted the read because it superseded anything I thought that went into the read. My reason for voting her in that game was more of a general 'I felt her posts were wallpaper' kind of thing than a specific event.
In this game, I would be theoretically voting Alice if I could, because I feel her posts are basically padding, but the difference is she hasn't shown me anything that contradicts or supersedes that. Unless you firmly believe Alice is town, I dont really see your objection to my questioning, and triumphantly declaring im scum doesnt change that
You hunt your way, Ill hunt mineBro, this feels like an advanced reason or read on Alice when she only has a few posts. Pretty sure her entrance was NAI.
Kind of dismissive, but sure.You hunt your way, Ill hunt mine
Well yes, youre telling me im wrong and I flat out disagree, so theres not really much to discuss there atm is there?Kind of dismissive, but sure.
You just seem to be quite content with your three post tunneling of Alice and it irks me. Not going to discuss this, though, because you and Ultra already have.Well yes, youre telling me im wrong and I flat out disagree, so theres not really much to discuss there atm is there?
Erm, gun to head Id say so yeah. He tried to provide examples of what he saw as different behaviour from another game, which at least implies some level of sincere effort on his partYou just seem to be quite content with your three post tunneling of Alice and it irks me. Not going to discuss this, though, because you and Ultra already have.
Did Ultra have townie vibes in his exchange with you?
I'm just trying to spark some content with my votes. Alice is null for me and I guess so is Michelle because I literally can't read her posts. I also feel like half the players haven't shown up on the first twenty four hours and that concerns me because I'm not a fan Poison's 'POE' here. I think her and Soul are always at each other, so easy to park suss there. And I feel like me and Ekko have had very little presence to warrant being options for the lynch here.You are of course welcome to provide a better direction, or indeed any direction of your own - which is doubly relevant seeing as youre currently 'voting' michelle because you cant decipher her posts, and prior to that, you were 'voting' the player that Im pushing?
Id say so, dont think this is a game that calls for an indieAlso do you guys think we're dealing with three wolves versus nine townies? Makes the most sense to me.
1 7h1nk 1 4m Lhf 83c4u53 0f 7h3 91mm1ck 4nd 3kk0 pu5h1n9 m3 4nd c4LL1n9 4LL 7h3 pL4y3R5, m4f14 4Nd 70wn, 70 v073 m3 15 5cummy, 50 1 pu7 h1m 1n 5cum p1L3. x7mf v073d 4L1c3 4f73R 1 541d 1 TR h3R, 4nd h3 d1dn'7 qu35710n my R34d 47 4LL, 8u7 h3 5h33p3d 3kk0 1n h15 v073 f0R m3 - 1 d0n'7 11k3 7h15 s0 1 7h1nk h3 15 m4f14.@Michelle I would like your opinion on them as well.
Why 7h3 v073?Alice is null for me
and I guess so is Michelle because I literally can't read her posts