Conditions: Toneri's Gaudodama cannot negate Ninjutsu since he hasnt shown the ability to do so .
Not in order .
1-kinshiki
S1- Kinshiki is purely a CQC fighter, so he most likely gets atomized by Truthseekers since he possesses no senjutsu to counteract their effects.
S2-Same as S1, though the Statue can't really do anything to Kinshiki.
S3-Naruto would die since he can't release Kurama. Kinshiki would manhandle him in CQC and all of Naruto's offense would be blown away by his Shinju cutter.
S1- Sasuke would probably lose. V3 Susano'o can't really pressure Toneri since it doesn't have the firepower to get through Truthseekers on its own. Sasuke's Susano'o eventually gets dismantled since he doesn't have senjutsu to negate the atomization effect, then he dies.
S2- Sasuke loses since the Statue could physically compete with 100% Kurama. He can't handle Toneri alone, so he isn't handling the Statue as well.
S3- This has more so to do with matchup. Sasuke wins this since Naruto has no move that can bust Susano'o without the Kurama avatar.
S1- Manga BSM Naruto wins most likely since Toneri in this scenario doesn't have the Statue to occupy Kurama.
S2- Naruto loses. The Statue could physically fight on par with 100% Kurama, so 50% Kurama is overwhelmed and Naruto is killed by it and Toneri together.
S3- Manga BSM Naruto wins since The Last Naruto can't do anything to the Kurama avatar.
S1- Minato doesn't have senjutsu, but I can see him winning this scenario due to Hiraishin's utility. Toneri's sword can easily be avoided by Hiraishin. Truthseekers can potentially be warped away and Bijudama could end this.
S2- Minato loses since 50% Kurama would be physically overwhelmed by the Statue and he can't handle it in conjunction with Toneri.
S3- Minato would win this easily since Naruto without his avatar can't do anything to Kurama.
5-BSM Naruto and EMS Sasuke
S1- Toneri isn't on par with any Ten Tails Jinchuriki. Iso Susano'o demolishes him. Nothing in Toneri's arsenal is breaching PS, let alone breach PS and breaching the Kurama avatar underneath.
S2- Iso Susano'o slices up the Statue with ease, then Bijudama barrage launches it from the battlefield. Toneri is then demolished just like in S1.
S3- The Last Naruto is killed with no effort at all. None of his moves can scratch PS without his avatar.
S1- Madara demolishes him. None of Toneri's defenses can withstand a single PS slash and his strongest offensive move being Kinrin Tensei Baku, can't destroy PS.
S2- No different than S1. PS slashes up the Statue and Toneri dies.
S3- Naruto gets one-shotted without Kurama.
S1- Iso Susano'o bladed Bijudama barrage literally one-shots while Toneri can do nothing back.
S2- Same as S1. The Statue is launched far from the battlefield by Madara's bladed bijudamas.
S3- Naruto gets one-shotted.
S1- Toneri can't put a scratch on the Mokujin or Shinsuusenju. Both paste him pretty easily.
S2- The Golem is smashed by the Mokujin or Shinsuusenju then a Mokuryu restrains it. Alternatively Shinsuusenju smacks it miles away from the battlefield, then Toneri gets pasted just like in S1.
S3- Naruto gets one-shotted by the Mokujin or Shinsuusenju.
S1- Toneri wins. The moon sword blocking feat isn't transitive to Six Paths Sage Mode Naruto without the cloak. Toneri overwhelms him, then kills him.
S2- Naruto can't do anything to the Statue to remove it completely from play and Toneri alone can overwhelm him just like in S1.
S3- The Last Naruto would eventually connect with the punch that he used to defeat Toneri.
S1- Based on his feats against Madara, I'm inclined to say that Gai would win. Toneri isn't on par with a Ten Tails Jinchuriki featwise, but he still shares the same skillset as them, which makes me hesitant on deciding a clear winner. I'm siding with Gai though.
S2- Same as S1 really, but the Statue has horrible durability feats, so it probably gets buried pretty easily by Evening Elephant.
S3- Gai kills The Last Naruto with ease. Night Gai one-shots since Naruto has no avatar to defend himself with.