Iguess u r right but, Kisame saw his face and commented, we all saw he jaw and eye sidehe's anything you want him to be; I think that's what kishi is trying to show us like he is the embodiment of evil or something (he has no real face but a mask on to show that anybody is capable of this) xd
i understant your point......and knowing kishi.....it could be anything.....but kisame new tobi's face because when they got back on kisame's past he saw that the mizukage was being controlled by tobi probably told kisame that he is madara just like he told everybody else...and the part that tobi said that rinnegan was his in the first place is because right before the end of hashirama and madara's fight....madara's eyes went rinnegan and because madara's eyes was izuna's in the first place...tobi cant be madara unless like you say he invented tobi or somethingAt first, everyone who reads or views Naruto thought Tobi was/is madara.
Madara left Konoha for some time; he could possibly not be idle. (he could have developed a jutsu to create Tobi or something like it)
Tobi knows everything or almost everything about madara. (he could be Izuna or Madara OR someone close t him)
Tobi claims that he owned the rinnegan Nagato had. ( it cant be izuna cos he lost his Mangekyou to Madara)
When tobi showed his face to Kisame, he said,"... former lord Mizukage, I mean, Madara...." (this should clarify what Madara went away for in point one or after the death of prime Madara)
So the point are 1) Tobi was the former Mizukage before and led during Kisame's time.
2) provided Tobi was serious about the rinnegan, he is possible Madara cause no other person can have the rinnegan and still use the sharingan liesurely
3) Itachi ranks third on my list of smart genius (dint mind the repeatition) so I don't think Madara(Tobi) can play him to think he is Madara he is not.
So Tobi Is either a continuation of Madara from Hashirama's time or a cryptic creation of Madara's idle time.
Nuuu, that only feeds the theory that he's a non-Uchiha. The Uchiha's can activate their Sharingan at will, meaning that they can turn it on and off. But if the Sharingan is transplanted to a non-Uchiha, like Kakashi, it's always activated and it drains your chakra pretty easily.Ok, so i just replied to this thread and didn't read any posts so I don't know if anyone said this before me.
There are a couple of things we need to take into account when solving this mystery!
First: Since Tobi has his sharingan activated 24/7 since his "true" identity was revealed, we can assume that he is part of the uchiha clan.
He referred to Tobi as Madara because they had reached an agreement, and Kabuto wanted to show him that he would play along.Second: When kabutomaru confronted Tobi on joining forces, he referred to him as Madara, when he knew that he had the real one in the casket.
- BUT! Later when he is talking to the real Madara he referrs to tobi as the "fake" Madara.
Anything is possible at the moment.FIIIIIIIIIIIIIINAAAAAAAAAAAAAAL SUMMATION:
We can assume that he is from the uchiha, unless he somehow has god's, SO6P and the Juubi's chakra supply, together! But there is also a slight possibility that he can be a weak replica of the real Madara, (zetsu kinda?)
OR he is someone like Izuna, which i personally doubt for some reason! xdxd
or maybe tobi actaully is madara, i am 70 percent sure that it isnt, but kisame saw the real madara when he controlled yagura, and then saw tobis face and recognized him as madara, so by that argument it would be extremely possible that tobi is madaraYes, tobi new that Itachi was really doing a good thing for his village.. how does this prove it was real Madara who helped him? It shows him speaking to Tobi and the fact that he refers to Tobi as Madara proves he doesn't know who Tobi really is.
izuna was shown dead (madara could have brought him back with rinnegan yes) but if he is izuna why does he need to steal nagatos rinnegan since he has both dna in him why can he not awaken it himself?Im pretty sure its Izuna... Because I did a bit of reasearch and found an old picture of Tobi with his older mask. when I compared it the hairstyle to both Madara and Izuna it turned out closest to Izuna....
See for yourself Links are below:
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
Also see: Naruto Shippuden Episode 136
You must be registered for see links
By looking at these pictures I conclude that it is Izuna Uchiha - Madara's Brother.... If you looks closely enough u can see the similarities. The only difference now is that Izuna doesnt have his hair tied back....
Also I would like to point out that both Madara and Izuna are twins by the look of things.... Madara just has his hair let out loose and his brother has it tied up...
See:
You must be registered for see images
What do you think?? Who is behind the mask???
Okay, his reason for saying tobi is juubi is not enough.Tobi isn't the Ten-Tails, that's the stupidest idea I've heard on these forums, it's even worse than those who think Tobi is Obito.
The Ten-Tails doesn't even exist. It's body is in the moon and it's chakra is split into the 1-7 beasts Tobi has and Bee and Naruto.
Yes because he wants to become its jinchuuriki.