Timeline is all wrong

Jiraiyathesannin

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
1,644
Reaction score
137
I actually am enjoying some of these fillers. I didn't particularly like Yamato's backstory (actually i think it was done horribly) but I like the things involving stuff we already know. Sometimes I forget its filler (that can happen when a filler "fills" in parts of the story already established).


However much of the timeline is wrong. First of all:

They said that itachi was the youngest anbu at age of eleven, but we know that yamata was in danzo's anbu (which is still anbu) younger than ten years old.

When itachi shows up in the village in part one, he acts like he's familiar with who kakashi is, but not that he knows him personally. Certainly not like he's his "superior". He also seemed surprised at kakashi's mastery of the sharingan, yet he has a full discussion about his sharingan in this episode.

Itachi should be much older than 11 years old. We know that at the time of the nine tails invasion, itachi was around 7 years old. According to these fillers, 4 years had past between the 9 tails invasion, and yamato trying to kill kakashi. well now even MORE time has passed. Both kakashi's voice is deeper, asuma's growing a beard, and yamato is significantly older. Sasuke looks about the same age he was during the uchiha masacre, showing that this event likely takes place in no more than a year from now (its shown in the preview to the next episode). that means sasuke is 7 years old, so itachi should be at least 14 or 15. but itachi was captain of the anbu when he was twelve? How does that make sense?

I feel like kakashi should have already left the anbu by the time itachi joined. Also they're showing itachi like this hardened killer. He cried like a baby when he killed his parents. It just doesn't fit. Itachi was "truly gentle"
 

Voltron

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
5,821
Reaction score
463
I don't think Kishi is in charge of the anime. So the people in the studios are the ones shitting on the story
 

Flakez

Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
70,977
Reaction score
1,947
Itachi was 5 during the Kyuubi attack. When Sasuke was 7 years old Itachi was 12.
 

denixue

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
May 9, 2013
Messages
511
Reaction score
23
yes filler is filler.. but man.. they are paid..
 

greygoosepapi

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
14
Reaction score
5
timeline and filler or not i say enjoy these episodes because itach and kakashii are fkkin epic to see in action
 

Jiraiyathesannin

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
1,644
Reaction score
137
Itachi was 5 during the Kyuubi attack. When Sasuke was 7 years old Itachi was 12.

Yes, but he was CAPTAIN by twelve. He should have been in the anbu already. Based on this episode, it looks like the coup is about to happen
 

Mr SwizZz

Banned
Regular
Joined
Mar 15, 2014
Messages
1,024
Reaction score
46
I actually am enjoying some of these fillers. I didn't particularly like Yamato's backstory (actually i think it was done horribly) but I like the things involving stuff we already know. Sometimes I forget its filler (that can happen when a filler "fills" in parts of the story already established).


However much of the timeline is wrong. First of all:

They said that itachi was the youngest anbu at age of eleven, but we know that yamata was in danzo's anbu (which is still anbu) younger than ten years old.

When itachi shows up in the village in part one, he acts like he's familiar with who kakashi is, but not that he knows him personally. Certainly not like he's his "superior". He also seemed surprised at kakashi's mastery of the sharingan, yet he has a full discussion about his sharingan in this episode.

Itachi should be much older than 11 years old. We know that at the time of the nine tails invasion, itachi was around 7 years old. According to these fillers, 4 years had past between the 9 tails invasion, and yamato trying to kill kakashi. well now even MORE time has passed. Both kakashi's voice is deeper, asuma's growing a beard, and yamato is significantly older. Sasuke looks about the same age he was during the uchiha masacre, showing that this event likely takes place in no more than a year from now (its shown in the preview to the next episode). that means sasuke is 7 years old, so itachi should be at least 14 or 15. but itachi was captain of the anbu when he was twelve? How does that make sense?

I feel like kakashi should have already left the anbu by the time itachi joined. Also they're showing itachi like this hardened killer. He cried like a baby when he killed his parents. It just doesn't fit. Itachi was "truly gentle"

So much wrong in this post i cant believe.

Maybe Itachi was the youngest member of ANBU under Hiruzen's command.

Killing your parents and killing some fodder ninjas who betrayed your and your village's trust is something else.

3rd of all, him being captain at 13 makes sense since he is only 11 now.
Itachi was captain at 13, not 12.

Itachi is only 5-6 years older than Sasuke, not 7-8 like you wish. Therefore, Sasuke being 5-6 and Itachi 11 makes complete sense. If sasuke is 7 at the Uchiha massacre and itachi 12/13 everything ties up.


A full discussion is not 45 seconds, Kakashi didnt start telling him about Obito and his mission, how was that a full discussion?
 

Jiraiyathesannin

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
1,644
Reaction score
137
So much wrong in this post i cant believe.

Maybe Itachi was the youngest member of ANBU under Hiruzen's command.

Killing your parents and killing some fodder ninjas who betrayed your and your village's trust is something else.

3rd of all, him being captain at 13 makes sense since he is only 11 now.
Itachi was captain at 13, not 12.

Itachi is only 5-6 years older than Sasuke, not 7-8 like you wish. Therefore, Sasuke being 5-6 and Itachi 11 makes complete sense. If sasuke is 7 at the Uchiha massacre and itachi 12/13 everything ties up.


A full discussion is not 45 seconds, Kakashi didnt start telling him about Obito and his mission, how was that a full discussion?

Based on this episodes ending and the preview of the next episode, it appears that the coup is about to happen. If itachi is captain by thirteen, how does that line up with the coup? Kakashi and itachi definitely didn't act like they once were team mates. you can't even refute that. I acknowledged that there are 2 types of anbu, i just pointed out that it appeared as though they said that he was the youngest anbu period, i covered my tracks on that one. I don't remember it ever saying how old itachi was during the time of the uchiha masacre. I can re-read but i don't remember it saying his age ever besides him being captain (and i could swear it was 12). Based on his appearance, i put him at 7/8 years old. I wish? why would i wish? I dont care. I don't like sasuke OR itachi, i'm just pointing out that it doesn't seem to fit with me.
 

Jarex

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
May 23, 2013
Messages
934
Reaction score
22
Just enjoy the fillers and forget timeline accuracy
 

IKSOKRIPS

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 17, 2011
Messages
9,670
Reaction score
925
You are doing one thing wrong - trusting the fillers, which are by the way Non-Canon. . . :yeah:

Itachi is one of the characters that has the most fitting Timeline in Naruto:

Itachi is five years older than Sasuke - at the beginning of the series Itachi is seventeen and Sasuke is twelve (17 - 12 = 5)/in the beginning of Shippuden Itachi is twenty while Sasuke is fifteen (20 - 15 = 5).

Itachi - four years old - Obito's attack on the Hidden Leaf village. Sasuke is only a few months old.

Itachi - seven years old - graduates from the Ninja Academy aka becomes a Genin. Sasuke is two years old.

You must be registered for see images
Itachi - eight years old - masters the Sharingan. Sasuke is three years old.

You must be registered for see images
Itachi - ten years old - becomes a Chūnin, and half a year later becomes an ANBU member. Sasuke is five years old.

You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
Itachi - thirteen years old - becomes an ANBU Captain (the same year of the Uchiha Massacre). Sasuke is eight, wich means he has already been in the Ninja Academy for three years.

You must be registered for see images
If you want to see the whole situation from a wider perspective, you can go to my Naruto - Overall Timeline:
 
Top