Theory: Could there be survivors of the Uchia clan massacre?

Odemgee

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2012
Messages
136
Reaction score
9
Just a theory on how there could be a surprise twist to the Uchia Massacre. What if Itachi didn't kill all of the Uchia and Sasuke has a bigger role is his plan then we think. The one thing we do know about the massacre is that Itachi had no other choice but to go with Danzo's plan or the whole village would be in danger and his brother could be killed in the process. So he could have came up with a plan in order to stop the rebellion and save the uchia which Danzo was dead set on completely destroying.

The first step:
Figure out who were the main people that want to cause the coup d'etat and go after them during the massacre to prevent this from happening again amongst those that were spared, lets also note that Itachi was against the coup and was ashamed of the uchia leadership for wanting to start an uprising. This was the easy part, since he was spying already he know who the main players were which include his father who was the head of the Uchia (we may also find out that his parents had a part in the nine tails attack).

Second step:
Find a way to remove those that he did have to kill without it being noticed and without any knowing that they still may be alive in order to prevent Danzo from going after them. This is were the help from Obito was needed. Itachi already knew of his abilties by observing him during his attack on Konoha so he knew that his Kamui and he ability to move around unnoticed would be perfect to remove those he chose to keep alive without anyone noticing.

Final step:
In order for the remaining Uchia to live on with pride, honor and still be respect amongst the rest of the villiages they great leader. Which is were Sasuke comes in. This is possibly the reason why Itachi didn't want Sasuke to know the truth, because he knew it would only lead him to want to do the same thing the current leaders wanted to do. It could also be the reason he push him so hard to get the mangekyo which was rare and well respected amongst uchia so they would gladly accept him as a leader by awaking it just as they did Madara.

Long post, but this is just a theory on how the Uchia massacre could have a surprise twist to it. May have missed something concerning the Uchia massacre, but do you thing there is a possibility for this to happen or not?
 

TheWillofFire

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Sep 4, 2012
Messages
1,421
Reaction score
61
Itachi killed all
Sasuke does have bigger role, kill madara
 

Sasunarufan13

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Messages
3,556
Reaction score
276
Itachi only spoke about saving Sasuke and only cared for his brother. If he had cared for more, I think he would have mentioned those people as well, but he only asked to spare Sasuke.
Other Uchihas being left alive would ruin the plot a bit, because where would they be then? Itachi pushed Sasuke so far because he wants him to be strong enough to survive.
So no, I doubt there are any Uchihas aside from Sasuke, left alive during the massacre
 
Joined
Jun 14, 2012
Messages
320
Reaction score
22
This couldn't have happened because Itachi did not destroy the bodies.

Danzo being one of the village leaders would have known everyone involved and would have expected to see all their bodies.

Obito stole all their eyes and Danzo would have thought this was Itachi trying to prevent Danzo from stealing their secrets.
 

Hikari Uchiha Senju

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Sep 21, 2012
Messages
1,530
Reaction score
297
Itachi only spoke about saving Sasuke and only cared for his brother. If he had cared for more, I think he would have mentioned those people as well, but he only asked to spare Sasuke.
Other Uchihas being left alive would ruin the plot a bit, because where would they be then? Itachi pushed Sasuke so far because he wants him to be strong enough to survive.
So no, I doubt there are any Uchihas aside from Sasuke, left alive during the massacre

This
 

huzaifa555

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
861
Reaction score
27
It has been stated many times all of ehm dead expect sauske and obito.
 

Dr Strangelove

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 20, 2011
Messages
10,057
Reaction score
608
Im pretty sure someone would have noticed a missing body(s). Especially since the village elders were involved. Im guessing Danzo and Itachi would have noticed.
 

Drio Osiamo

Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2012
Messages
299
Reaction score
10
Its possible, but Im sure Kishimoto would have showed uus a hint or something before hand.
 

Hippy

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
722
Reaction score
52
At one point we only thought it was Kakashi, Itachi, Sasuke with the sharingan so I mean he really didn't give us any insight about tobi at all for awhile some info about akatsuki with zetsu itachi and kisami thats about it but now there was danzo, well was danzo D=
 

Odemgee

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2012
Messages
136
Reaction score
9
Danzo wanted all of the Uchia killed because he felt they were a threat so asking to save anyone beside his brother probably wouldn't have went over to well. They shakey part is where would they be now and possible why hasn't he mentioned it to Sasuke during there final meeting. Well keeping there location hidden would have been important because Danzo getting any wind of there location or any existence of them would have only led him to hunting them down and finishing the job. So they could possibly be at some secret hidden village away from everyone in order to start over. As far as not mentioning anything to Sasuke at the time could possibly be because Sasuke was hell bent of destroying Konoha so he may have feared Sasuke would lead to Uchia down the same path of hatred that they have been on throughout there history. Also I wonder if the scroll Sasuke gained could hold the secrets to there location which was put in place just incase the uchia had to go into hiding for some reason.
 

Odemgee

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2012
Messages
136
Reaction score
9
Itachi only spoke about saving Sasuke and only cared for his brother. If he had cared for more, I think he would have mentioned those people as well, but he only asked to spare Sasuke.
Other Uchihas being left alive would ruin the plot a bit, because where would they be then? Itachi pushed Sasuke so far because he wants him to be strong enough to survive.
So no, I doubt there are any Uchihas aside from Sasuke, left alive during the massacre

Danzo wanted all of the Uchia killed because he felt they were a threat so asking to save anyone beside his brother probably wouldn't have went over to well. They shakey part is where would they be now and possible why hasn't he mentioned it to Sasuke during there final meeting. Well keeping there location hidden would have been important because Danzo getting any wind of there location or any existence of them would have only led him to hunting them down and finishing the job. So they could possibly be at some secret hidden village away from everyone in order to start over. As far as not mentioning anything to Sasuke at the time could possibly be because Sasuke was hell bent of destroying Konoha so he may have feared Sasuke would lead to Uchia down the same path of hatred that they have been on throughout there history. Also I wonder if the scroll Sasuke gained could hold the secrets to there location which was put in place just incase the uchia had to go into hiding for some reason.
 

cLang cLang

Banned
Regular
Joined
Sep 23, 2012
Messages
531
Reaction score
29
I read a thread a few month's back stating that after the war is all over and done with a never before seen majestic Uchiha will appear from the shadow's...
 

Narutofan4203

Banned
Regular
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
1,026
Reaction score
51
There could be some who managed to somehow Izanagi out, or some who broke into smaller families way before it happened, so yes.
 

Sasunarufan13

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Messages
3,556
Reaction score
276
Danzo wanted all of the Uchia killed because he felt they were a threat so asking to save anyone beside his brother probably wouldn't have went over to well. They shakey part is where would they be now and possible why hasn't he mentioned it to Sasuke during there final meeting. Well keeping there location hidden would have been important because Danzo getting any wind of there location or any existence of them would have only led him to hunting them down and finishing the job. So they could possibly be at some secret hidden village away from everyone in order to start over. As far as not mentioning anything to Sasuke at the time could possibly be because Sasuke was hell bent of destroying Konoha so he may have feared Sasuke would lead to Uchia down the same path of hatred that they have been on throughout there history. Also I wonder if the scroll Sasuke gained could hold the secrets to there location which was put in place just incase the uchia had to go into hiding for some reason.

Why would Itachi risk his brother's life for a few clan members who he doesn't have a close relationship to? And how would he have managed to get them away under Danzo's radar?
If there are, for some unknown reason, still some Uchihas left, I doubt they would make an appearance. It just wouldn't fit in the plot. And honestly, I would be disappointed if there were indeed left alive, because then the whole plot with Sasuke would be a bit pointless
 

Prime Rib

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
8,900
Reaction score
208
nope its been confirmed the sauske was the lone survivor
 
Top