[Theory] The True Mechanics of Chibaku Tensei.

[Wolfus]

They tore trillions of tons of rock seperately. Just imagine if they were one. That would be too much. Not saying it's a black hole, but it's still pulls strongly.

Those were little rocks compared to the entire plannet. And this small plannet is also not evne clsoe to being not even close to the enough amount of gravity needed.

Madara is not close enough to do something like that. Not even rikudou is.

 

[Harry Balzac]

Actually each one individually is bigger than Nagato's. But he isn't able to create one big one like the moon. All of them has to be seperate.

He IS ABLE too, but that would mean crushing everyone on the planet. Last I checked that's not his goal. The reason he split chibaku into so many was to use it for distraction purposes and that's it.

 

[flyboyissac]

madara created chibaku tensei far bigger then that one

 

[Tdogg]

C'mon bean, there has been multiple posts illustrating the fact that Kaguya used Mugen Tsukuyomi before Hagoromo created the moon and you've just ignored it.. You're better than that

 

[Ultimateone]

just looking at the size of madara's planetary devastation and negato's, i still think nagato's was bigger, even though in the chap they claim that madara's was bigger. just look at the picture of nagato's. it makes the mountains look small and it separating clouds. i don't really see a reason why madara couldn't use one big planetary devastation. i think he did many so that he could distract them long enough so he could cast the infinite tsukiyomi.

 

[Senju Bean]

C'mon bean, there has been multiple posts illustrating the fact that Kaguya used Mugen Tsukuyomi before Hagoromo created the moon and you've just ignored it.. You're better than that

Perhaps the fruit has way of bypassing. Or perhaps she has her own way of creating a moon and it was blown up.

Eitherways, for Hagromos rinnegan tablet version to work, the moon is needed.

 

[so12p]

The whole" created the moon" thing is myth or a blatant plot hole. The real moon is just over a quarter the size of the earth. So a quarter of the planet would be consumed in order to create a moon. Assume NV is relative dimensions (since it looks so similar and acts so similar).

Everyone in the five nations would be sucked into a CT big enough to form the moon, not to mention NV would no longer be round.

It's only manga (see my status), but that one is a kishi mega a$$ pull... missing 25% of his a$$ on that one.

 

[Senju Bean]

C'mon bean, there has been multiple posts illustrating the fact that Kaguya used Mugen Tsukuyomi before Hagoromo created the moon and you've just ignored it.. You're better than that

Read my sig. It's explained in much further detail in "Paths to Dark Dreams"

The fruit gives a type of omniscience.

 

[Senju Bean]

Those were little rocks compared to the entire plannet. And this small plannet is also not evne clsoe to being not even close to the enough amount of gravity needed.

Madara is not close enough to do something like that. Not even rikudou is.

It's hard to say. Maybe. I mean those small ones were already tearing up mountains. Maybe Naruto can survive it due to automatic regenration is impervious sage body, but the rest of team 7 are made of soft flesh and bone. Mountain tearing force all combined to one point? Flesh and bones would not last. Sasuke can teleport. But Sakura and especially Kakashi are screwed.

 

[Ultimateone]

The whole" created the moon" thing is myth or a blatant plot whole. The real moon is just over a quarter the size of the earth. So a quarter of the planet would be consumed in order to create a moon. Assume NV is relative dimensions (since it looks so similar and acts so similar).

Everyone in the five nations would be sucked into a CT big enough to form the moon, not to mention NV would no longer be round.

It's only manga (see my status), but that one is a kishi mega a$$ pull... missing 25% of his a$$ on that one.

you know the real moon is made from a peice of the earth that broke off right? the only diff here is that hogoromo was the cause of it.

 

[ninjarasengan]

The whole" created the moon" thing is myth or a blatant plot whole. The real moon is just over a quarter the size of the earth. So a quarter of the planet would be consumed in order to create a moon. Assume NV is relative dimensions (since it looks so similar and acts so similar).

Everyone in the five nations would be sucked into a CT big enough to form the moon, not to mention NV would no longer be round.

It's only manga (see my status), but that one is a kishi mega a$$ pull... missing 25% of his a$$ on that one.

Aren't a lot of your statements based on assumptions...when was it ever stated that NV was our Earth? or even our moon? or whether he got the materials for his chibaku tensei from their planet or space rocks....

Just seems like an excuse to insult the author to me...

 

[Divine Uchiha]

just looking at the size of madara's planetary devastation and negato's, i still think nagato's was bigger, even though in the chap they claim that madara's was bigger. just look at the picture of nagato's. it makes the mountains look small and it separating clouds. i don't really see a reason why madara couldn't use one big planetary devastation. i think he did many so that he could distract them long enough so he could cast the infinite tsukiyomi.

Madara's planetary devastation is larger than nagato's became naruto says so and he has went up against the technique...twice plus we saw Madara's mini moon from a zoomed out point while nagato's mini moon was close up.

 

[so12p]

you know the real moon is made from a peice of the earth that broke off right? the only diff here is that hogoromo was the cause of it.

I hope you meant that as a joke.