The sharingan can see through clones - ultimate proof

[Watatsumi]

In Naruto episode 130, Sasuke said that the Sharingan can see through clones, but people refused to believe his statement because it was 'non canon'.

In the latest Manga (i.e, 577), Notice how Madara says that he could see through Hashirama's clone technique with his ocular powers, while others couldn't do the same.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

If the image doesn't appear, please follow this link:

You must be registered for see links

To put it in simple language, the sharingan can distiguish between a clone and the real thing.

Any thoughts?

 

[Ambriel]

I agree, good job

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

maybe its only available if you achieve EMS ?

 

[Vasto Lordé]

This actually ruined my theory >.>

 

[Better]

Itachi couldn't detect the difference between a clone and the real kakashi

i'm sure its just kishi trolling us again or madara is keeping up his arrogance

 

[Uchicha Macho]

The point for most uchiha hater is to underrate the uchiha character inorder to make their character look superior.At the end of the day haters alway going to hate even when proof is at there faces.+ rep for mentioning it

 

[-Hades-]

We just have to wait and see. Madara also says that HE was the only one that could see through his clones... Maybe it is something only he can do (being the most powerful sharingan user so far) or it is unique to the EMS. If regular sharingan could see through clones then this wouldn't be so much fuss, and Madara would have praised the uchiha powers more, instead of himself.

 

[-Vegeta-]

Itachi couldn't detect the difference between a clone and the real kakashi

i'm sure its just kishi trolling us again or madara is keeping up his arrogance

Or that the perception of sharingan increases the further advanced it is. Maybe EMS is required for it.

 

[Better]

Or that the perception of sharingan increases the further advanced it is. Maybe EMS is required for it.

but a clone is when you divide your chakra equally, something the byakugan couldn't tell the difference off and it sees chakra points

idk and pain couldn't tell the difference of a konohamaru clone and the rinnegan is > EMS

 

[Xerotes]

If the Sharingan can see chakra and clones only have a portion of the original persons chakra it would make no sense that they -couldn't- see the difference between a clone and its original.

 

[Onion Soda]

We just have to wait and see. Madara also says that HE was the only one that could see through his clones... Maybe it is something only he can do (being the most powerful sharingan user so far) or it is unique to the EMS. If regular sharingan could see through clones then this wouldn't be so much fuss, and Madara would have praised the uchiha powers more, instead of himself.

you truly got it +rep

 

[Punk Hazard]

maybe its only available if you achieve EMS ?

This. Maybe one of the powers of EMS is the ability to discern between clone and real person based on chakra

 

[Uchiha Josephus]

maybe its only available if you achieve EMS ?

Itachi couldn't detect the difference between a clone and the real kakashi

i'm sure its just kishi trolling us again or madara is keeping up his arrogance

We just have to wait and see. Madara also says that HE was the only one that could see through his clones... Maybe it is something only he can do (being the most powerful sharingan user so far) or it is unique to the EMS. If regular sharingan could see through clones then this wouldn't be so much fuss, and Madara would have praised the uchiha powers more, instead of himself.

Or that the perception of sharingan increases the further advanced it is. Maybe EMS is required for it.

All of the above!!! + rep all around! xd

EDIT - (must spread rep before i can give to 4th Hokage of the leaf)

 

[Illyasviel]

Madara said he's the only ine who can.

 

[-Vegeta-]

but a clone is when you divide your chakra equally, something the byakugan couldn't tell the difference off and it sees chakra points

idk and pain couldn't tell the difference of a konohamaru clone and the rinnegan is > EMS

The rinnegan isn't the sharingan and it grants a completely different set of jutsu. Madara stated he could see through Hashirama's clone so I'm guessing it's something unique to the EMS.

 

[NarutoVsGoku]

Wrong... Its not the sharingan or any other but the user itself. The better the user is with his ocular jutsu the greater the possibility of them seeing through substitutions, shadow clones, element clones.

Look at neji who couldnt pin point the real naruto during their fight in the exams. And the byakugan is superior than sharingan (basic). Look at itachi with his ms who couldnt see past narutos clones when they fought to save gaara. Nagato didnt not see through kakadhis lightning clone with rinnegan. But madara is on a whole level of any other eye user. His eyes were the only ones to see through hashi wood clones. Didnt you notice that his eyes dont include eyes of other uchihas?

Also madara was the only one able to control tailed beasts with his eyes aside from tobi n sage. Madara has developed his eyes to do alot of badass shit but he is madara afterall. Saying that "all sharingan can see through clones" is not true and the manga doesnt support that, it supports the fact madara is strong and able to see through clones

 

[udosohhope]

kage bushin cant be distinguished using any of the doujutsu as chakra is spreed evenly amongst the clones, but i dnt knw of oda substituting jutsu

 

[Kurogane]

Wrong... Its not the sharingan or any other but the user itself. The better the user is with his ocular jutsu the greater the possibility of them seeing through substitutions, shadow clones, element clones.

Look at neji who couldnt pin point the real naruto during their fight in the exams. And the byakugan is superior than sharingan (basic). Look at itachi with his ms who couldnt see past narutos clones when they fought to save gaara. Nagato didnt not see through kakadhis lightning clone with rinnegan. But madara is on a whole level of any other eye user. His eyes were the only ones to see through hashi wood clones. Didnt you notice that his eyes dont include eyes of other uchihas?

Also madara was the only one able to control tailed beasts with his eyes aside from tobi n sage. Madara has developed his eyes to do alot of badass shit but he is madara afterall. Saying that "all sharingan can see through clones" is not true and the manga doesnt support that, it supports the fact madara is strong and able to see through clones

Look @ the bolded part people

 

[nicekabuto]

i reckon it's just that someone who is SKILLED with a sharingan, byakugan and probably rinnegan can just track someone's movement and see the moment when they make the clone. not so much the difference between the two bodies, but just catching the fecker when he makes the clone and following the right one. in theory anyone could do this but these guys have sharp eyes.

 

[itachiEMS]

Sharingan is but a tool, and it's power depends upon the user. Regular Sharingan cannot see through shadow clones, that much is known because chakra spreads equally throughout the body. But EMS can possibly see a difference in substition clones (such as Mokuton clone, Water clone, etc)