Suigetsu Plot Holes

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

There are numerous plot holes regarding Suigetsu's statements:

1. Suigetsu said with the scroll they can rule the world. It's one thing to release the Hokages' souls from the Reaper it's another to reanimate them with Edo Tensei, since neither he nor Sasuke nor Jugo know Edo Tensei, how are they going to use them? and since he protested in reviving Orochimaru, what are his means of actually using their souls to rule the world?

2. In the first pannel of ch. 593 Suigetsu asked why Sasuke wanted to revive Orochimaru, then asked "And who is the ones who know everything?" assuming Suigetsu knows the Reaper has the souls of the previous Hokages (in connection with his statement of ruling the world) then at least he should have an idea who Sasuke wanted to talk to (The 4 Hokages) but he was completely baffled as to who Sasuke sought for just after the latter read the scroll to unseal the RDS.

3. Suigetsu said that if Sasuke took time to learn the power in the scroll, he could use it without the need of reviving Orochimaru, but like I pointed out, how would they use the souls if they can't reanimate them because they do not know Edo Tensei? so it would be proper for Suigetsu to tell Sasuke to learn to use the scroll and learn Edo Tensei and not the power of the scroll per se.

 

[A$AP Wap]

Ask Kishi.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

Ask Kishi.

I would if I could.

 

[Ciao]

Makes sense to me. Good point.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

Makes sense to mee. Good point.

thanks.

 

[TheBattousai]

We don't know what the scroll actually said. For all we know it gives some alternate method of reanimating the souls.

 

[gameove]

well sasuke did learn the signs for edo .i think sasguto was meaning the self sacrifice part

 

[Frankenstein]

I completely agree with number 1.
Either Kishimoto screwed up or Suigetsu is plain dumb.

 

[Chibiusa]

You're right cuz Suigetsu shouldn't have known bout the Hokage being in there in the first place. Unless that's common knowledge in the Naruto world or something? It's crazy there's still confusion over his statements even after TOWKE was revealed

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

well sasuke did learn the signs for edo .i think sasguto was meaning the self sacrifice part

They were the hand seals for releasing Edo, not creating them.

 

[KuroKaze]

actually i was wondering the same thing....but simply not able to reach to any definite conclusion...kishi should explain these in near future...

 

[Twin Steps]

Maybe there's more to the scroll.

 

[Frikid]

seems legit to me.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

actually i was wondering the same thing....but simply not able to reach to any definite conclusion...kishi should explain these in near future...

Well it's either the scroll has more power than just unlocking RDS or Kishimoto made a glaring error.

 

[JDuzumaki92]

I agree, Suigetsu should of said that about learning Edo Tensei not the power of the scroll. I guess Kishi didn't want to give away any hints(even though there was a picture of the reaper on the black board in 574).

 

[Kages]

Seems legit. Good points

 

[xXBlazinNinXx]

Nice

 

[Space Cowboy]

Derp

 

[captainEO]

You make a good point. There seems to be a problem there.

 

[godzillard]

there are numerous plot holes regarding suigetsu's statements:

1. Suigetsu said with the scroll they can rule the world. It's one thing to release the hokages' souls from the reaper it's another to reanimate them with edo tensei, since neither he nor sasuke nor jugo know edo tensei, how are they going to use them? And since he protested in reviving orochimaru, what are his means of actually using their souls to rule the world?

2. In the first pannel of ch. 593 suigetsu asked why sasuke wanted to revive orochimaru, then asked "and who is the ones who know everything?" assuming suigetsu knows the reaper has the souls of the previous hokages (in connection with his statement of ruling the world) then at least he should have an idea who sasuke wanted to talk to (the 4 hokages) but he was completely baffled as to who sasuke sought for just after the latter read the scroll to unseal the rds.

3. Suigetsu said that if sasuke took time to learn the power in the scroll, he could use it without the need of reviving orochimaru, but like i pointed out, how would they use the souls if they can't reanimate them because they do not know edo tensei? So it would be proper for suigetsu to tell sasuke to learn to use the scroll and learn edo tensei and not the power of the scroll per se.

he actually did suggest to sasuke that sasuke might take time to learn the same things oro knows.
He thought sasuke could train and learn them....after all.....
Sasuke did defeat orochimaru in suigetsu's and juugo's opinions.