[Tier] Spent an hour on making this list lol

[Uzumaki Macho]

Tier 0- Roger/Prime WB /Prime Garp

Tier 1- WB/ Kaido /Akainu /Shanks / Mihawk / Dragon /Prime Rayleigh /Kuzan / Big Mam / Shiki / Prime Sengoku / Fujitora / Kizaru / Green Bull / Blackbeard, Old Garp

Tier 2- Beckman / Marco / Old Rayleigh / Old Sengoku / Weeble / Jack

Tier 3- Doflamingo/ G4 Luffy / Don Chinjao / Sabo / Ivankov/ Hancock / Jozu / Tsuru / Onigumo / Sentomaru

Tier 4- Luffy / Law / Kidd/ Jinbe/ Zoro / Sanji / Kuma / Drake / Hawkins / Apoo / Vergo / Lucci / Magellan

Tier 5- Pica / Killer / Urouge / Capone / Smoker / Crocodile / Kaku / Jabra / Caesar / Burgess / Shiliew

Tier 6- Kyros / Diamante / Trebol / Bartolomeo / Cavendish / Gladius / Brooke / Kin'emon / Franky / Monet / Robin / Hajrudin

Why is Chinjao above Zoro when Luffy mid diffed him without using G4?

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Doffy completely restored his organs within 30 minutes since if he didn't, he would have died since the strings repairing his organs disappeared when he got knocked out.

How does string repair organs that were ripped apart? I'm pretty sure if you stitch a severed arm together, it'll still be severed until it heals. The strings was simply keeping Doffy alive by keeping his organs in place. It wasn't healing.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Now you can't justify the strength of the Gorgon sisters by saying that. The way that battle progressed it looked more like they were showing off their feats then actually trying to kill Luffy.

It doesn't make any sense for the first mates of someone who is equal to current Luffy to be weaker than the average vice admiral. Also SH's are not the only ones who grow stronger over the timeskip :lol

That makes no sense.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

How does string repair organs that were ripped apart? I'm pretty sure if you stitch a severed arm together, it'll still be severed until it heals. The strings was simply keeping Doffy alive by keeping his organs in place. It wasn't healing.

And his strings would disappear once he was knocked out. His organs would be destroyed if those strings hadn't repaired them yet.

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Why is Chinjao above Zoro when Luffy mid diffed him without using G4?

Luffy didn't med-diff Chinjao. It was high-diff due to circumstances. Chinjao was beating Luffy in G2; Chinjao didn't have a scratch on him while Luffy was covered in bruises, got hit multiple times and had his guard broken. It wasn't until Chinjao decided to match Luffy's G3 instead dodging that he lost.

If Chinjao had his drill head, Luffy's G3 Thor Elephant Gun would've been overpowered since Luffy was just able to overcome the flathead butt and a casual drill head attack is way stronger than a full strength flat headbutt.

G2=Chinjao stronger
G3=too slow and Chinjao drill head is stronger
G4=needed to beat Chinjao

 

[Legend Slayer]

The difference between GK and the pain is that GK is actual physical damage while the pain bubble is just that: Pain. The stress caused Zoro's body to lose a lot of blood, but that's nothing like actually having his organs destroyed, which Zoro can't fix.

Plus, that logic doesn't make sense. That's like me saying if you take away WB's durability and his Quakes, he'd be equal to Zoro, so let's put them on the same tier.

It's not the same thing. I didn't take away Law's abilities I just meant that if he doesn't use his abilities on Zoro's swords because that would be unfair.

And I'm pretty sure that Kuma's technique did some serious internal damage as well. Not as much as GK but I see what you meant.

 

[Vandenre1ch]

And his strings would disappear once he was knocked out. His organs would be destroyed if those strings hadn't repaired them yet.

String doesn't repair cuts......they were simply keeping his organs in place....Doffy was never stated to have healing properties
and Doffy himself said that it wasn't healing.....I already gave an example....

You are also assuming that Doffy's string disappear when he loses consciousness and its very flawed...
-Why is Luffy still rubber when he is unconscious?
-Would Sabo's flames and burns disappear if he gets knocked out?
-Why is all the stone that Pica manipulated still messed up?
-Moirah said that even if he gets knocked out or dies, the effects of his shadows will remain.

Dfs have different properties.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

String doesn't repair cuts......they were simply keeping his organs in place....Doffy was never stated to have healing properties
and Doffy himself said that it wasn't healing.....I already gave an example....

You are also assuming that Doffy's string disappear when he loses consciousness and its very flawed...
-Why is Luffy still rubber when he is unconscious?
-Would Sabo's flames and burns disappear if he gets knocked out?
-Why is all the stone that Pica manipulated still messed up?
-Moirah said that even if he gets knocked out or dies, the effects of his shadows will remain.

Dfs have different properties.

Doflamingo's strings disappear when he is unconscious. That's why Birdcage disappeared when he got knocked out.

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Roger deserves own tier Also to have akainu up there with shanks is dumb and doffy isn't sabo lvl either . He lost to luffy some ppl say luffy had help yea but so did doffy look what luffy went through

By feats and even portrayal doffy>sabo

We already have had 2 organizations/ groups where the person deemed the number 2 wasn't the right hand man

White beards crew ace was hailed as number 2 whereas Marco was 1
Crocodile bonchan was number 2 whereas the knife guy was number 1
Doffy group pica for most part #2 but we all know Vergo was his most loyal...


Sabo hasn't done nothing to put him on doffy level so get out of here with that

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Doflamingo's strings disappear when he is unconscious. That's why Birdcage disappeared when he got knocked out.

It's unclear cuz by that logic his organs should have failed or fell apart cuz they were destroyed

 

[Lance171]

luffy beat doflamingo who is he below him? not saying the list is compete garbage but definitely some inconsistency's but then again one piece is tough because nobody ever fights to the death and its always group battles

 

[Legend Slayer]

luffy beat doflamingo who is he below him? not saying the list is compete garbage but definitely some inconsistency's but then again one piece is tough because nobody ever fights to the death and its always group battles

You've got a very poor sense of conception

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

It's unclear cuz by that logic his organs should have failed or fell apart cuz they were destroyed

Exactly. His organs were able to be fully repaired in 30 minutes, so the injuries Doffy received from GK aren't as severe as some people make it out to be.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

By feats and even portrayal doffy>sabo

We already have had 2 organizations/ groups where the person deemed the number 2 wasn't the right hand man

White beards crew ace was hailed as number 2 whereas Marco was 1
Crocodile bonchan was number 2 whereas the knife guy was number 1
Doffy group pica for most part #2 but we all know Vergo was his most loyal...


Sabo hasn't done nothing to put him on doffy level so get out of here with that

Marco was called the first division commander, not #1. WB was #1. Daz was called Mr.1, not #1. Crocodile was #1.

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Marco was called the first division commander, not #1. WB was #1. Daz was called Mr.1, not #1. Crocodile was #1.

R u serious -.- my point is in these organizations ppl were ranked number 2 in what ever organization but they had someone higher then them that was in number 1 spot (not captain but right hand of sorts)

Sabo being number 2 signify's at least by previous groups within one piece that someone else is above him bar dragon who is the head

In whitebeard fleet

Ace like sabo was hailed number 2 whereas Marco was #1 then whitebeard the leader

Same with crock and doffy group

So following that logic

For the revs sabo is hailed as number 2 someone is in between then dragon

Sabo fanboys deny this so much when it has been constant within one piece....

Besides sabo is too weak to b a force to b recon with amongst the WG cuz he can't hold a candle to one of the admirals and there's 3 of them a fleet admiral Kong and garp.. So if all dragon has is sabo in his corner he better hope no one ever finds him...

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

R u serious -.- my point is in these organizations ppl were ranked number 2 in what ever organization but they had someone higher then them that was in number 1 spot (not captain but right hand of sorts)

Sabo being number 2 signify's at least by previous groups within one piece that someone else is above him bar dragon who is the head

In whitebeard fleet

Ace like sabo was hailed number 2 whereas Marco was #1 then whitebeard the leader

Same with crock and doffy group

So following that logic

For the revs sabo is hailed as number 2 someone is in between then dragon

Sabo fanboys deny this so much when it has been constant within one piece....

Besides sabo is too weak to b a force to b recon with amongst the WG cuz he can't hold a candle to one of the admirals and there's 3 of them a fleet admiral Kong and garp.. So if all dragon has is sabo in his corner he better hope no one ever finds him...

Marco was the #2 and Ace was the #3. Just because he had 2 in the name of his position doesn't mean that he was number 2.

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Marco was the #2 and Ace was the #3. Just because he had 2 in the name of his position doesn't mean that he was number 2.

No Marco was 1st division commander

Ace was second -.- u sound stupid af -.-....

The captain doesn't count he is the head he doesn't get a number hell even croc called himself zero to signify that he has a number one in his crew... Captains r the heads

 

[ssjelf]

Law and Luffy are in the same tier.

Teach and Mihawk are in the same tier as Shanks.


What Luffy went through? He fought in a tourney hours before the fight for one round and regained his energy through eating. He then knocked down fodder and spent his time running, except he was on a horse's back and a bull's back, rather than expending his own energy to do so. Bellamy hit him, but Bellamy isn't capable of significantly damaging Luffy. There's no way Luffy is on Doffy's level when Luffy bashed him for 55 minutes after he was brought to near death and that STILL wasn't even to beat Doffy, not to mention the fact that it was strongly indicated the only reason G4 did as much damage as it did was because it undid the stiches that were holding his organs together.

Nothing about Roger suggests he was in his own tier. Inb4 "But he was Pirate King" fallacy

It was said white beard was the only one that could fight equally with roger. Garp and roger nearly killed each other multiple times. That says that white beard and roger were in their own league and Garp is in there depending on if you think fighting equally means the same as nearly killing each other.

No other characters have that said about them. Therefore roger wb and Garp are in their own tier.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

No Marco was 1st division commander

Ace was second -.- u sound stupid af -.-....

The captain doesn't count he is the head he doesn't get a number hell even croc called himself zero to signify that he has a number one in his crew... Captains r the heads

Your reason as to why Whitebeard gets no number doesn't make sense. This is how it works:

Crocodile- Number 1.
Mr.1- Number 2.
Mr.2- Number 3.

Whitebeard- Number 1
Marco- Number 2
Other division commanders.

The number in their name doesn't correspond to their ranking. I don't get why this is so hard for you to understand.

 

[TheHokage]

Tier 0- Roger/Prime WB /Prime Garp

Tier 1- WB/ Kaido /Akainu /Shanks / Mihawk / Dragon /Prime Rayleigh /Kuzan / Big Mam / Shiki / Prime Sengoku / Fujitora / Kizaru / Green Bull / Blackbeard, Old Garp

Tier 2- Beckman / Marco / Old Rayleigh / Old Sengoku / Weeble / Jack

Tier 3- Doflamingo/ G4 Luffy / Don Chinjao / Sabo / Ivankov/ Hancock / Jozu / Tsuru / Onigumo / Sentomaru

Tier 4- Luffy / Law / Kidd/ Jinbe/ Zoro / Sanji / Kuma / Drake / Hawkins / Apoo / Vergo / Lucci / Magellan

Tier 5- Pica / Killer / Urouge / Capone / Smoker / Crocodile / Kaku / Jabra / Caesar / Burgess / Shiliew

Tier 6- Kyros / Diamante / Trebol / Bartolomeo / Cavendish / Gladius / Brooke / Kin'emon / Franky / Monet / Robin / Hajrudin

Lol Sanji and Zoro are not a league above Smoker, Crocodile and Shiliew.