Ali G MPGH
Active member
Awards
my first sig in 2 months..lawl..
I may be rusty, thats why it sucks.. D:
I may be rusty, thats why it sucks.. D:
You must be registered for see images
[Photoshop] Soul - People Disappear
- Thread starter Ali G MPGH
- Start date
Ali G MPGH
Active member
Awards
Gobi Gobletsson
Active member
Awards
Well I guess I was a little harsh with that but considering your usually a lot better and well I guess now I have had time to think I guess I would consider this 6/10. ._. But seriously you don't need to bash my skills, my skills is not what this thread is about.
Ali, criticism is not based on someone's skills but his view, I believe you already know that well. I didn't like the signature either, when I looked at it I was like "Eww! What the..?"
I understand that you are rusty, but you can't go all mighty and harsh on the people who don't like it.
If I were to rate a signature made from you and to someone who's new with photoshop, of course I would be harsher to you. I would expect from you to understand that either.
You said that Sin gave 7/10 to a signature with no flow, depth... but, tell me please, do you see flow in your signature? Depth? The render, the background and the effects doesn't go well together. You have a very dark abstractive background and a bright render which at some parts doesn't even blend well.
So, yes, based on your skill level I give that signature 3, tops 4 out of 10.
Ali G MPGH
Active member
Awards
yh i know, but still . this sig has depth and flow. Even if a little of it, it still has it.
Nvm guys, thanx for the comments. If i would argue, this would never end.. lolz.
Nvm guys, thanx for the comments. If i would argue, this would never end.. lolz.
~ Killer S ~
Active member
kisamexRocks
Active member
I like the whole signature, like the way the C4D's and the whole darkness feel to it, but the Render itself for me personally ruins it. I was thiking that if you had a Gears of War render or something and shaded it changed it to the same lighting or style to fit the background, it would be insanely good. but thats just MO.
Ali G MPGH
Active member
Awards
killer.. idk who he is,, just a random guy 
@kisame
Yh, i think ur right. but i was just too lazy to search for a good one. I just took the first one from my renders folwer
@kisame
Yh, i think ur right. but i was just too lazy to search for a good one. I just took the first one from my renders folwer
Alternative
Active member
Awards
It's nice and all, but like everyone else, I'd like to see the render being bigger. As for the other effects, they're nice if they were to be used on their own, but I don't think they work here. What you've gone for is a dark blue - black theme, and it doesn't really work with people/real life stocks. I think something like this would have more beige colours against the black, which would work for a signature like this. The blue is also a strong colour, naturally and is somewhat overpowering. There is depth in the tag, which is a good thing I guess.
Overall, I'd give it a 5/10.
Overall, I'd give it a 5/10.
Ali G MPGH
Active member
Awards
yh, i udnerstand what you mean.
I dont rlly like real life renders neither, but it was just the first one in my folder.. so i took it