[Discussion] So about Itachi

[ShadowBandit]

So it seems that Madara recruited Obito. Now I don't quite understand, if Madara did it while in some death dimension or he just fixed obito.

Now Itachi said that Tobi was Madara. And I can't imagine Itachi being wrong about anything.

So was Itachi referring to be Tobi representing Madara? That he knew Tobi(obito) wasn't really Madara but knew that Tobi worked for him?

Because maybe since it seemed Madara survived that he went out and recruited young uchiha to try and fight for his cause.

Now my theory is that Madara tried to do the same thing with Itachi. However Itachi refused to follow Madara's idealism. Thats why when Sasuke asked Itachi who helped him kill the uchiha clan, Itachi said Madara but was really referring to a person (obito), who was under Madara's control.

Idk, it just always bugged me that, itachi would be wrong about anything since he's the master troll badass, so when he says Madara's tobi, he just means the tobi(obito) or nameless, is the embodiment of Madara's ideals.

 

[Ultimate Beast]

Itachi was wrong, like about alot of stuff

 

[נıм]

I have a theory, but its to long and I can proof evryfing.

 

[Simple Math]

even obito tricked itachi lol

 

[Solo]

Itachi also stated that Madara was a shell of his former self.(Which seems to be the old Madara) It's possible he was talking about him.

Also, He stated Madara was his mentor.

Whether he met Madara or Obito is still a mystery.

 

[kibaclaw]

In the flashback it showed itachi meeting with long haired tobi who I believe to be Madara. Why itachi didn't tell anybody there were 2 tobis is beyond me, since itachi obviously met both and his sharingan should have been able to realize they have different chakras.

 

[ekichi onizuka]

edo itachi called him tobi i think he was awere of it

 

[Takos]

Itachi was simply wrong. /thread