Ay winning scenario 1 is probably the biggest joke I've heard today.
-MS Sasuke and Jugo were tracking and reacting to V1 Ay. SM Naruto reacted to, evaded, and countered his father without much difficulty, who is just as fast as him when V2 isn't taken into account, so speed blitz won't happen here.
-I find it amusing that people are using Ay being able to dodge FRS head on as an argument for Naruto's defeat, but I bet you nobody would make that argument for Hebi Sasuke, Itachi, or anyone as fast as or faster than Deva Path. Lol. Being able to dodge a head on attack only means that Naruto shouldn't throw it head on.
FRS isn't even needed to beat V1 Ay. Ay comes in for the attack, and Naruto responds by slamming a Senjutsu Rasengan right into him, which would kill him since Chidori pierced his body slightly, and SM Rasengan>>Chidori=Rasengan. He can do this head on or he can pull what he did against the Raikage, meaning he won't be able to evade in time.
Ay can win S2 if he can blitz Naruto w/ no reaction. If he can't, then Naruto simply blocks the hit and after he gathers himself he forms clones and it's only downhill for Ay.