Here's an ISO on XTMF. Note, that I am doing this ISO with the intention of trying to establish a town core. I am doing it on XTMF because based of my theory that those who voted Posion early in the last dp are most likely not mafia. And XTMF having done that, immediately goes atop my list. This ISO is to see if he should stay there, or be locked there, as a town core to me.
His first post:
I'm not going to dig deep into this, that'll be stupid. I just want to point out here that its not a fluff post. The user, starts off with an accusation, in game.
Upon his third post:
He votes poison. The only evidence that this probably wasn't a RVS was his second post on Posion:
[To Poison]
This still doesn't mean his onto Poison here, and could still just be RVS.
He makes a few more posts, all mostly just weak jabs at people:
Te majority of his following posts, from post 186 - 302 can be summed up in this one post from his:
@bold, he is mostly just asking players of this game. Very similar to AL's playstyle early on.
Okay, after aprox. 40 posts from him, I'm going to start applying my method for finding out if someone is scum. So I'll be running it by this criteria:
1) Do they have contradictions
2) Are they reaching?
3) Do they have incomplete statements[as in saying an idea or thought but leaving it open to mean two have two separate contradicting interpretations. This is scummy because you are speaking without actually contributing your actual opinion. By waiting till someone infers what you did, or asks you, you can complete the statement to fit the narrative that suits you best at the moment.]
4) No clear stance on players
From post 962 - 1309
X states thier stance on a player:
It's a very in-depth stance, that is very clear as to what they see in the players so far. + Town cred for me.
X is also very consistent on his stance with Toujo:
+ town cred, no contradictions here
Following these bunch of posts the next batch-- 1310 - 1632
I'd like to point out this post:
It's his first post, that is following up with his original vote on Poison. Not much is discussed here, more of an observation on his part.
He goes on about Poison here:
This post, backs his lynch candidate Posion. Note, that this was done about 30-35ish pages before the eod, and apox, 20ish pages from the explosion event stated by SK
+ Town cred for consistency
+ Town cred for having this early read on Poison before she was the clear lynch candidate for DP 1
The following posts within this section are nothing much of significance.
His next 20 posts:
This post is a response to the explosion event made by SK.
He claims he sees it as a mafia move.
[I asked him earlier this dp what he thought, and he still echoed this same belief]
+ Town cred no contradiction here
X
keeps his stance on Ratchet:
I keep pointing this out because its a significant fact. X has, since his first read kept to his reads, without, out of the blue changes or contradictory posts against his reads.
He does this a couple more times:
I'd like to point out this action could very well be scummy behavior, hard protecting a scum buddy, and when that buddy flips scum, they could use the idea that them hard protecting them was too scummy to be actually considerable. "Why would scum hard protect their own partner so obviously?" But, I doubt such a sanrio is in play. Thus why I'm not really considering scummy but quiet the opposite here.
These next posts are all taking place in DP 2
Of them, X exhibits the same habits as the DP 1. He questions,
He keeps consistent on his reads on Toujo:
And there stance on the event hadn't changed:
Okay. I'm going to stop here. After reading the last few pages, of his post, I'll simply be confirming what I said here. This whole ISO can litterly be seen as a love letter or a hard pocket, but do one yourself and come back and tell me X is scum. He checks, all my boxes and he hasn't contradicted, reached, incomplete stated, or had no clear stance on a player. If there is a player, I intend to put into my town core its X, and this ISO is why.
(I was supposed to do two more ISO's one on Michelle to see who she focused, and one on Bee because I legit cant get a clear read on them. Buuut, the eod is almost here)