[Game] SK - League Of Legends Mafia Game Thread! Fight Or Be Forgotten!! #15

[ScarletCelestial]

Basically what do you think of my reasoning here.

 

[Mendel]

Wasn't this the exact same Town list as yesterday?

For you, the reads progression of @All_Red

Spoiler: the last three town read lists of All_red

Rej - town - the only town who I dont have the best reason for town. Thier posts and overall engagement with others is quite townie. Only reason for my town placement in him. Toenie rating 6/10
ScarletCelestial - town - placed lots of info upon arrival, questioned and stated lots of overall great info, if you want to know what she posted that is quite townie, search her in thread, im sure you'll come to the same conclustion. Townie rating 9/10
Kyte - town - their push on me is town, i doubt wolf would try to lynch a target like me( im not seen as scum by many), taking a controversial stand agaisnt me. I dont think mafia will put that much attention/ effort to lynch a target as controversal as me, or atleast be the head of the train. 8/10

Turns out I only have a total of 3 most likely scum, i miscounted saying 5.

Im am deeply disapointed in the fact that I was absent last hours of DP1. But lookinh at it im sooo happy for town's lynch! One down, 5 to go!

My current town reads:
Kyte
Celestral
Elmage G Ace

Each lf these three have prented posts that I feel are town posts.

Unvote
Kc's death was reallly unexpected. Now I change my town list abit.
Towns atm:
Kyte
Scarlet
Poison
Ansa

 

[ScarletCelestial]

@Scarlett
just to reiterate...

you said poison chans EOD was good?

No, I said her vote movements were unlikely to come from scum.

 

[XDDDDD]

I was confused by his last statement too.

We need to close this case. I'll explain what I think from a personal point of view. XD might have potentially acted on Corazon, and Kc could have either watched Corazon or tracked XD. He thought XD targeted Corazon last night to kill him, and was role-blocked, but Corazon could be a Cop for all he knows.

I don't want any replies on this part of the post, and any further dive into the roles now, especially from XD.

Yes, Mendel, even if it's not the Godfather, any action could still be intercepted by a redirect of the actor, or a transport of the target. And at any rate, I don't really like cutting all doubt in one's result like Kc did, or for anyone following his footsteps after he'd mod-killed just because he's extremely likely to be Town. The situation could very much be misleading, so i'd rather not build any assumptions based on it, especially since the host has advised to not dive much into it. I don't imagine he'd be deviating us from the right investigation track. LOL

First paragraph gave me good laugh, thanks.

 

[Kyte_]

First paragraph gave me good laugh, thanks.

Now that i read it again, I kind of didn't deliver my thoughts in the most comprehensible way, but you're welcome...

 

[ScarletCelestial]

OK For some reason I thought moth replaced Rose so I kinda have to add Rose to my list of suspects.

 

[Corazon]

Before I actually get into the players, I wanted to establish what we already know from SK's posts. We know for sure there's still at least 3, possibly 4, Mafia.

Rhaast, Varus, ??? ( dude with Varus lol ) & Aatrox ( not sure if he's in this game, idk )

We also know that the SK investigates innocent and I'm not sure if there's another one but judging from the lack of kill in the NP, I'm assuming there isn't so I'm going forward thinking there was only one coz it'll drive me crazy trying to figure out if there was more than one. Doe the Kayn thing is throwing me off tbh, smh ( damn you SK for doing this lol )

"GodFather: You investigate innocent"

---

Iss unfortunate KC got mod killed, would've preferred if he didn't but, iss too late now. Sorry man.

Onto the actual game, I'd like to know XD's ( change your name man, iss weird typing that lol ) reason for voting for me. Idk what makes me seem like scum but my lack of posts was due to some personal stuff. Idc doe, I'm not gonna go after you jus for voting for me.

Kyte I'm also curious as to why you voted for me in the last DP. You gave absolutely no reasoning behind it after posting some long paragraph that didn't even have anything to do with me.

 

[Mendel]

The thing about Houtarou is his final post before the Day ended. Vote: Houtarou I don't think he had an awareness of the no self-voting thing, and in the context of that particular EoD, moving his vote from Rej to himself would either cause:

1. A tie or
2. His own lynch.

Either option I believe is very against a scum mindset in the instance of this game, and as stated before is the reason why I'm leaving him alone this phase.

@mothbomb @Mendel

Basically what do you think of my reasoning here.

a) it is hard for me to tell what Houtaro thought the vote tally was when he did that
b) Houtarou has 3 names (Luffy, oreki), I think he has experience playing mafia
c) I do not know how much experience he has playing with the self-vote rule, there are sites/games where you can do that
d) so IF he knows about the rule here, he can WIFOM that (fake it) IF he knows the vote tally (which scum could be keeping in scumchat)
e) if he is scum, maybe a scum buddy knows what the effect of self-voting is, and told him in chat

I'm much too paranoid to clear him for that
and I would have to look up why he started liking Rej
he had voted Rej early on, said his reads were "forced" etc.
so the question I would research would be, WHY did he put his vote off Rej, as Poison chan did?
do you have an answer for that?

I also want to alert you that I noted that Houtarou was kinda echoing your observations from your early posts shortly after you posted them (I'm talking about your very first D1 posts here, with the collections of catch up remarks), and if you saw that, you may be liking him for that.

 

[Kyte_]

I really wanna hear more from AL and Alice

Alice escaped death by a hair strand last DP and I'd expect her to put some effort into clearing herself, which i'm not seeing at all. Granted, she's lurking almost all day and every day.

AL didn't contribute much besides questioning and interrogating, and it seems he's been more cautious about that attitude after i confronted him about it. He's barely seen since the second half of DP1 and DP 2.

 

[ScarletCelestial]

Page 57 is an effing mess. By the sounds of it Karote was out of it (which seems to be their default setting so ) whilst kc hinted at something which sucks.

 

[ScarletCelestial]

Unvote
Kc's death was reallly unexpected. Now I change my town list abit.
Towns atm:
Kyte
Scarlet
Poison
Ansa

What made you remove Mendel and replace them?

 

[ScarletCelestial]

If I remember rightly, Karote was in Terra Mafia as third party, and when they were caught they were like "oh OK" so I don't really think it would be alignment indicative. (@XDDDDD correct me if I'm wrong.)

The thing is, we can't exactly say if kc's role does clear/condemn anyone, because their hinting was a bit too vague for my liking, and they did say it was possible they were just Town.

 

[Houtarou]

a) it is hard for me to tell what Houtaro thought the vote tally was when he did that
b) Houtarou has 3 names (Luffy, oreki), I think he has experience playing mafia
c) I do not know how much experience he has playing with the self-vote rule, there are sites/games where you can do that
d) so IF he knows about the rule here, he can WIFOM that (fake it) IF he knows the vote tally (which scum could be keeping in scumchat)
e) if he is scum, maybe a scum buddy knows what the effect of self-voting is, and told him in chat

I'm much too paranoid to clear him for that
and I would have to look up why he started liking Rej
he had voted Rej early on, said his reads were "forced" etc.
so the question I would research would be, WHY did he put his vote off Rej, as Poison chan did?
do you have an answer for that?

I also want to alert you that I noted that Houtarou was kinda echoing your observations from your early posts shortly after you posted them (I'm talking about your very first D1 posts here, with the collections of catch up remarks), and if you saw that, you may be liking him for that.

I have played around 23-24 games where I died early or sub out early like DP1 or DP2 at best in 7-8 games. Now you can conclude with that how much experience I have

I play in OJ aka Oro Jackson, and yes you can vote for yourself in Oro Jackson mafia.
My first vote on Rej was nothing but RVS

 

[ScarletCelestial]

I might be writing an essay but it still won't help because town really has convinced itself I'm scum.

So in return, I'm gonna troll town too.

I'm starting to regret what I said.

 

[Houtarou]

@XDDDDD can you provide us with your scum reads?

 

[Mendel]

On another site I know, players keep a vote tally themselves. Everyone who votes posts the updated tally with their vote or unvote, others watch and check (easy to do here, just like if it checks ok) and correct, or add it when a voter forgets. Does this seem like something you would want to do here? It could look like this:

Votes
Player A: 3 (Player B, Player C, Player D)
Player E: 1 (Player F)
not voting: Player G, Player H

 

[Kyte_]

That reminds me, if no one is gonna take the initiative in analyzing the highlights of the write-up, I might do it, when I get some free time.

Kyte I'm also curious as to why you voted for me in the last DP. You gave absolutely no reasoning behind it after posting some long paragraph that didn't even have anything to do with me.

Ah, i was actually looking forward to a no lynch by balancing out the votes, and more importantly, i didn't town read you among the players who were up for a lynch such as Luffy and Michelle, and i still don't. Even Rej, i threw a lot of shade on him, but he was a fun piece to hold into, and needless to mention, his flavor knowledge was great.

You don't need to dive much into it.

 

[ScarletCelestial]

For you, the reads progression of @All_Red

Thanks Mendel!

 

[Mendel]

What made you remove Mendel and replace them?

I wasn't on the old list, but this did happen:

Currently I feeling the new memebr: mendel is town. He has put pressure and confronted lots of players. I think has put too much effort/attention on himself to be wolf, unless he plans on power wolfing

so I want to be on the new list, @All_Red !

 

[ScarletCelestial]

I'll have a look at Houtarou later. I still think that the EoD thing is indicative of Town, but it would be good to go through his ISO again to be sure.