This theory may have spoilers, if you have not caught up with FT, please refrain from opening the spoiler.
As crazy as this prediction may be, We never really got to see who Ur had a baby with, and the fact that Ultear died too save Gray may have made him angry. Now some people say I'm wrong because "Silver smells like Gray." We can't say for sure what Gray smells like too decode that. It may be referring to where Gray trained (Ice can have smell ._.).
But so far as much as I can deduct, he can be related to Gray in other ways like a childhood friend or his Father
(Silver being future Gray sounds a bit farfetched considering the Sun Village was frozen a few years/months before anything really happened.)
This, I doubt Ur's husband would know Natsu, and if I remember Silver said something like "out of all the people, it had to be Natsu" or something like that, won't that suggest he might now a little bit of him?
This, I doubt Ur's husband would know Natsu, and if I remember Silver said something like "out of all the people, it had to be Natsu" or something like that, won't that suggest he might now a little bit of him?
I don't know why some people make these farfetched theories, this isn't Bleach or Naruto for gods sake, This is Fairy Tail. ._.
You must be registered for see links
The Sun Village was frozen way before Gray was born, so how can it be future Gray? If he isn't Ur's Husband then so be it. There's a distinctive difference between Silver and Gray's appearance so I refuse to think it would be him.
And nowhere do I see how Future Gray would cease to exist, Gray never officially died. He was only warped to the past, that level of magic would've instantly vanished the Future Gray.
I don't know why some people make these farfetched theories, this isn't Bleach or Naruto for gods sake, This is Fairy Tail. ._.
You must be registered for see links
The Sun Village was frozen way before Gray was born, so how can it be future Gray? If he isn't Ur's Husband then so be it. There's a distinctive difference between Silver and Gray's appearance so I refuse to think it would be him.
And nowhere do I see how Future Gray would cease to exist, Gray never officially died. He was only warped to the past, that level of magic would've instantly vanished the Future Gray.
Just so you know the whole time travel thing does not work like how your describing it in Fairy Tail. The distance distinctive you see between Silver and Gray could be the fact Gray grew up you know.
Also the the present version of someone doesn't have to die for the future version to appear take Rouge and Lucy for example.
To be honest the whole Gray being Silver thing makes perfect sense at the moment with Zeref getting closer to the involvement it is heavily implied Zeref has something to do with the time travel as why would Jellal sense Zeref on Lucy back in the GMG.
Anyway time travel is a thing in Fairy tail that has been shown so Gray being Silver is an actual high possibility and in fact would make sense since I get the feeling the reason Silver hates to be reminded of his time being Gray is due to the fact both UL and her daughter sacrificed themselves to save him. Hiro has shown Gray showing anger at himself over this.
Just so you know the whole time travel thing does not work like how your describing it in Fairy Tail. The distance distinctive you see between Silver and Gray could be the fact Gray grew up you know.
Also the the present version of someone doesn't have to die for the future version to appear take Rouge and Lucy for example.
To be honest the whole Gray being Silver thing makes perfect sense at the moment with Zeref getting closer to the involvement it is heavily implied Zeref has something to do with the time travel as why would Jellal sense Zeref on Lucy back in the GMG.
Anyway time travel is a thing in Fairy tail that has been shown so Gray being Silver is an actual high possibility and in fact would make sense since I get the feeling the reason Silver hates to be reminded of his time being Gray is due to the fact both UL and her daughter sacrificed themselves to save him. Hiro has shown Gray showing anger at himself over this.
This theory may have spoilers, if you have not caught up with FT, please refrain from opening the spoiler.
As crazy as this prediction may be, We never really got to see who Ur had a baby with, and the fact that Ultear died too save Gray may have made him angry. Now some people say I'm wrong because "Silver smells like Gray." We can't say for sure what Gray smells like too decode that. It may be referring to where Gray trained (Ice can have smell ._.).
But so far as much as I can deduct, he can be related to Gray in other ways like a childhood friend or his Father
(Silver being future Gray sounds a bit farfetched considering the Sun Village was frozen a few years/months before anything really happened.)
With all due respect, this is really the oldest theory about Silver's origin so it can hardly be considered 'crazy' at this point nor even original for that matter. From the very first chapter Silver appeared in, two theories were created:
1) Silver is Gray's father
2) Silver is Ul's husband
Now you just repeated it without providing any actual new material to support it. After that people also started to go along the way of he's Gray's older brother or even his very older evil win brother. The reason why so many people now jump on the 'Silver = future Gray' is because they wanted something new.
This, I doubt Ur's husband would know Natsu, and if I remember Silver said something like "out of all the people, it had to be Natsu" or something like that, won't that suggest he might now a little bit of him?
Natsu, and to a certain degree Gray, used to be quite famous 7 years ago at least in the Fiore Kingdom. After the GMG their reputation skyrocketed, so it's not really hard to justify for Silver to know Natsu, regardless of who he is.
I don't know why some people make these farfetched theories, this isn't Bleach or Naruto for gods sake, This is Fairy Tail. ._.
You must be registered for see links
The Sun Village was frozen way before Gray was born, so how can it be future Gray? If he isn't Ur's Husband then so be it. There's a distinctive difference between Silver and Gray's appearance so I refuse to think it would be him.
And nowhere do I see how Future Gray would cease to exist, Gray never officially died. He was only warped to the past, that level of magic would've instantly vanished the Future Gray.
Where did you get the idea the Sun Village was frozen way before Gray was born? That doesn't even make sense considering Flare grew up there. The Sun Village was frozen some days, at best some weeks before Walrod noticed it and requested FT to help the village.
This is something I already explained in the past:
1) It's very unclear whether the Demon Gates are now genuine demons, humans turned demons or a mix of both. Gray noticed that Doriarte was a demon from the book of Zeref due to his past experiences with Deliora and it was confirmed that Doriarte was, similar how currently Minerva and Mira are being changed, turned into a demon. So that makes it already very plausible they can have children as they were originally human.
2) Even assuming they are full-fletched demons and never were human, who says they can't reproduce with humans? It's a fictional story and having humans breed with non-humans is not something that was ever much of a taboo, especially not in Japan. It really surprises me that I see so many people bring up this whole Silver is a demon so he can't have a human kid-stuff. How many series are there that revolve around the kid of such a mix-up? Not to mention who says Gray doesn't have demon blood in him? He is considered human because everyone in the series sees him as such, why would there be a reason for them to consider him having demon blood? I don't believe that myself, but in theory it's not impossible.
For the record I don't believe either that Silver = future Gray and that Silver being Ul's husband or Gray's father is still more likely due to this being FT and that I don't want anymore time travel stuff.
