Well thats probably the first time i've seen someone get that wrong.
No you are wrong.
Your answers were too vague. Fire Is one of the five basic elemental ninjutsu, but it is made by increasing the temperature of your chakra. Fire has many offensive abilities but can also be used for defense. Fire is strong against Win, because the fire feeds the flames.And it is weak against Water, because the water extinguishes the flames.
Got that?