Should the Uchiha Clan get Justice?

[Zenobs]

Title

 

[Chikombo]

You mean they should be recognized and apologized to or they should be shamed for having attempted a coup?

 

[Reviewing Logic]

well all the people that conspired and wronged them are dead

 

[Zenobs]

You mean they should be recognized and apologized too or they should be shamed for having attempted a coup?

they should be recognized and apologized too

 

[SumnNarutoRelated]

they tried.

Itachi silenced them.

 

[Tauren Chieftain]

The only relevant member is former criminal who wanted to destroy Konoha and kill 5 Kages. He ain´t getting sh1t except another loan for his house.

 

[Zenobs]

What Inspire this question was many anti- Enders on Tumblr were calling Naruto a bad Hokage for sweeping the massacre under the rug and not giving Justice to the clan

 

[To Whatever]

Short answer: Yes.

What Inspire this question was many anti- Enders on Tumblr were calling Naruto a bad Hokage for sweeping the massacre under the rug and not giving Justice to the clan

Does she know that it isn't Naruto's place to do that? Sasuke Uchiha has the authority in regards to his clan. If he wants the clan to keep their honor and keep the coup under wraps and in the past, then so be it. If he wants preparations, then so be it.

 

[Chikombo]

I think they should. They should have their name up there as a co founder of konoha and a sense of pride and stuff.

 

[To Whatever]

I think they should. They should have their name up there as a co founder of konoha and a sense of pride and stuff.

They are known as the noble clan and one of the founders, They weren't written out of history. The only thing that isn't disclosed was the coup/massacre.

Sarada and the Uchiha are still seen as prestigious and gifted with special eyes in a positive light.


I could understand Sasuke or Naruto not wanting this information to get out to the public as it would cause a divide and could potentially dishonor his clan.


Itachi took sole blame and dishonor for the sake of his brother and konoha. That was his wish to Naruto and Hiruzen.

 

[Chikombo]

They are known as the noble clan and one of the founders, They weren't written out of history. The only thing that isn't disclosed was the coup/massacre.

Sarada and the Uchiha are still seen as prestigious and gifted with special eyes in a positive light.


I could understand Sasuke or Naruto not wanting this information to get out to the public as it would cause a divide and could potentially dishonor his clan.


Itachi took sole blame and dishonor for the sake of his brother and konoha. That was his wish to Naruto and Hiruzen.

The truth should be out there aswell, if anything Itachi would get cred for it.

 

[Darth AniCetuS]

Other than Sasuke and Sarada who's left of the clan lol.

They plotted a coup and paid for it. Only bad thing about it is that a lot of innocents died too and for that people who went along with Danzo's plan must be punished. But I guess they're already dead too.

Doing anything beyond that will also bring out the truth about the uchiha clan and Naruto and Sasuke wouldn't wan't that.

 

[To Whatever]

The truth should be out there aswell, if anything Itachi would get cred for it.

For killing his clan? He's seen as the villain as he wanted to. He did it for Konoha and the honor of his clan. He explicitly stated that.

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Sasuke probably feels the same. Especially given the fact that he wanted to "destroy" the past rather than look back at it.

The only one who deserves to know the truth is Sarada and maybe Sakura.

Otherwise, the Uchiha keep their honor.

 

[JStar King]

Yes, they should have justice. They wanted peace, but got the short end of the stick.

 

[To Whatever]

Yes, they should have justice. They wanted peace, but got the short end of the stick.

I think their justice would be keeping their honor and Sarada and Sakura knowing the truth.

Sasuke is widely known as the Hokage's Shadow and the uchiha are seen as great people of nobility.


The uchiha who will be known in history as bad people would be Madara and Itachi.

Obito too, but he "died" when he was 12 and I doubt anyone can identify him.

 

[Greatness23]

The only relevant member is former criminal who wanted to destroy Konoha and kill 5 Kages. He ain´t getting sh1t except another loan for his house.

You forgot, " And would've succeeded in destroying the leaf had he been the emotional fuhh he's made to be"

 

[Chikombo]

For killing his clan? He's seen as the villain as he wanted to. He did it for Konoha and the honor of his clan. He explicitly stated that.

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Sasuke probably feels the same. Especially given the fact that he wanted to "destroy" the past rather than look back at it.

The only one who deserves to know the truth is Sarada and maybe Sakura.

Otherwise, the Uchiha keep their honor.

I think the truth should be out there anyway. But also the truth that Tobirama persecuted the Uchiha and that they had them killed to prevent a war.

 

[Tauren Chieftain]

You forgot, " And would've succeeded in destroying the leaf had he been the emotional fuhh he's made to be"

cool fanfiction

naruto would stop him he wouldn´t restrain himself like he did in vote 2

 

[To Whatever]

I think the truth should be out there anyway. But also the truth that Tobirama persecuted the Uchiha and that they had them killed to prevent a war.

Tobirama didn't have them killed.

The truth would upset the balance and the responsibility falls on the sole leader of the Uchiha, Sasuke.

For him to expose the truth to the entire world would disgrace his clan, konoha, and more importantly, his brother's dying wishes.


It would be best known by clan members only. As a story, lesson, moral, and reminder.


I do see your point of view though. The truth is for everyone but not always. Thats why secrets exists.

 

[Zenobs]

The post was basically calling out all of Naruto's fault as being hokage she states that Naruto stills uses child soldiers, how he didn't change the Shinobi system, he didn't achieve peace and ultimately failed at accomplishing anything he said he would do in the original series of Naruto