Sharingan or Byakugan

[Sharpism]

Sharingan can do a lot More things then that <.< MS can destroy Byakugan 99.9% The Mangekyo Sharingan is a heightened form of Sharingan. The Mangekyo Sharingan gives the user access to powerful and forbidden techniques. The Mangekyo Sharingan is distinguished from a normal Sharingan through its appearance, which changes the form of the tomoe seal.

We're talking about the eyes themselves not the Dojutsu derived from the eyes.
This would include Amaterasu, Tsukuyomi, Susano'o; Which are all Mangekyo Sharingan Dojutsu.

Its quite obveous that Mangekyo Dojutsu would destroy the abilities of Byakugan Dojutsu, but the Byakugan is more or less used for tracking, where as the Sharingan is used for battling.

 

[Pain..]

We're talking about the eyes themselves not the Dojutsu derived from the eyes.
This would include Amaterasu, Tsukuyomi, Susano'o; Which are all Mangekyo Sharingan Dojutsu.

Yeah All Mangekyo Sharingan can destroy Byakugan and this is Byakugan or Sharingan Those not says Sharingan 1-3 Tomeo only U_U

 

[Shika Love]

We're talking about the eyes themselves not the Dojutsu derived from the eyes.
This would include Amaterasu, Tsukuyomi, Susano'o; Which are all Mangekyo Sharingan Dojutsu.

Its quite obveous that Mangekyo Dojutsu would destroy the abilities of Byakugan Dojutsu, but the Byakugan is more or less used for tracking, where as the Sharingan is used for battling.

Again, I agree. It's really difficult to compare the two when you consider the dojutsu because they are used for such different things. You can easily compare the basic abilites of the eyes (with Byakugan coming out on top) but its much more difficult when you consider the dojutsu. It's like comparing medical ninjutsu to shadow techniques - both useful, both strong, but in totally different ways.

 

[Shika Love]

Yeah All Mangekyo Sharingan can destroy Byakugan and this is Byakugan or Sharingan Those not says Sharingan 1-3 Tomeo only U_U

We've been comparing the basic Sharingan, tomoes 1-3, with the Byakugan's basic abilites (seeing chakra flow, etc), and think Byakugan is stronger in that regard.

Mangekyo Sharingan dojutsu (Amaterasu, Tsukoyomi, etc) would be comparable to the techniques the Hyuuga's use with Byakugan. And yes, here Sharingan seems to come out on top.

 

[Sharpism]

Ok to clear things up.

Byakugan can see chakra a lot better then Sharingan, flow/tenketsu is what the Byakugan can see, Sharigan can only see the flow.

However the Sharingan can slow down perceptive time, allowing the user to predict movements, and the Byakugan has a 360 degree view naturally.

The difference of the eyes themselves is that;

Sharingan/Byakugan can see chakra flow.
Byakugan can see Tenketsu.
Sharingan can "slow down" time.
Byakugan has a 360 degree view.​

Since the Byakugan has ONE more ability then the Sharingan it makes it a superior eye, WITHOUT Dojutsu.

Now if you include Dojutsu, the Byakugan is screwed the second Tsukuyomi is cast, as the 360 degree view cannot let you focus on ONE specific thing. You eyes see 360 degree's, aside from the Thoracic Vertebre, in which a Byakugan user would have to use the SMALL area of that to block the ability to see into the Mangekyo Sharingan users' eyes, in order to do this the Byakugan user would have to be facing backwards; this is neither realistic nor relieable, and thus the Byakugan user would instantly get put under Tsukuyomi.

Now this is where things get a bit more complected, as earlier on in the series we learn that Genjutsu effect the brain only, where as in the Kakashi gaiden Rin's body chakra was screwed up as well; along with that Tsukuyomi is an advanced Dogenjutsu, and we don't exactly know 100% how it works.
If it worked with only the brain the Byakugan user would be able to see the chakra flow in his/her brain being abnormal and instantly break out of it, WHILST still being able to view the opponent, 360 degree view. Since that is the Sharingans way of battling Genjutsu, I would assume the same theory would be accurate for "Superior" eyes.

 

[Pain..]

Ok to clear things up.

Byakugan can see chakra a lot better then Sharingan, flow/tenketsu is what the Byakugan can see, Sharigan can only see the flow.

However the Sharingan can slow down perceptive time, allowing the user to predict movements, and the Byakugan has a 360 degree view naturally.

The difference of the eyes themselves is that;

Sharingan/Byakugan can see chakra flow.
Byakugan can see Tenketsu.
Sharingan can "slow down" time.
Byakugan has a 360 degree view.​

Since the Byakugan has ONE more ability then the Sharingan it makes it a superior eye, WITHOUT Dojutsu.

Now if you include Dojutsu, the Byakugan is screwed the second Tsukuyomi is cast, as the 360 degree view cannot let you focus on ONE specific thing. You eyes see 360 degree's, aside from the Thoracic Vertebre, in which a Byakugan user would have to use the SMALL area of that to block the ability to see into the Mangekyo Sharingan users' eyes, in order to do this the Byakugan user would have to be facing backwards; this is neither realistic nor relieable, and thus the Byakugan user would instantly get put under Tsukuyomi.

Now this is where things get a bit more complected, as earlier on in the series we learn that Genjutsu effect the brain only, where as in the Kakashi gaiden Rin's body chakra was screwed up as well; along with that Tsukuyomi is an advanced Dogenjutsu, and we don't exactly know 100% how it works.
If it worked with only the brain the Byakugan user would be able to see the chakra flow in his/her brain being abnormal and instantly break out of it, WHILST still being able to view the opponent, 360 degree view. Since that is the Sharingans way of battling Genjutsu, I would assume the same theory would be accurate for "Superior" eyes.

Well if you 3 are taking about 1-3 Tomeo Byakugan can destroy Sharingan 1-3 Tomeo Only.

 

[xanderthevampire]

personally I would go for byakugan and here's another little thing i noticed- when kakashi fought zabuza, zabuza was able to make the mist so dense that even the sharingan wasn't able to see through it and i got to thinking, the sharingan has sharper sight and can see things practically in slow motion which is like enhanced human sight but the byakugans chakra sight and almost x-ray vision properties seem like completely different forms of vision alltogether. this would lead me to believe that in pitch darkness, the sharingan would be blind while the byakugan would still be able to see.

 

[Miggy69]

has any1 ever wondered if the byakugan has special abilities that we dont kno of anyway rite now i would say sharingan

 

[Issu]

I'm gonna have to go with the Sharingan. The sheer power of it demands some sort of respect. Although each has their own abilities..

 

[Tsukuyomi47]

sharingan.
if itachi had byakuyan than its byakuyan.

 

[Pain..]

sharingan.
if itachi had byakuyan than its byakuyan.

xd you just say sharinga because istachi have byakugan ? lmao

 

[Sharpism]

Well if you 3 are taking about 1-3 Tomeo Byakugan can destroy Sharingan 1-3 Tomeo Only.

Yes but Mangekyo doesn't make the EYE itself any better, it gives the user a wide range of techniques and allows access to another Kekkie Genkai, however these are all Dojutsu and that isn't what we're comparing.
Even a Mangekyo without the Dojutsu; the Byakugan is still the BETTER eye. The way the eye is used by people and the techniques that each user has is what would make the Sharigan the better eye.

Of course Mangekyo is better then a Byakugan with Dojutsu because it unlocks an advanced Element, and techniques right away.

 

[Shinjitsu]

lol i love how you seem to always analyze everything in full details in most threads Sharpism yet no one rarely listens to your explanations even when backed up with actual fact ! ha

Byakugen > Sharingan
Byakugen < Sharingan - When Dojutsu is involved

Pretty sure Sharpism wrapped this "debate" up on page one but please feel free to continue ha...

 

[the spirit]

i would say sharingan....coz it is very dangrous and hypnotizes the person....it can read the movements and at the same time hypnotizing the enemy...each of the sharingan users has their unique ability....!!!

 

[starhuda]

Sharingan is the best.

 

[Uchiha Riyo]

The sharingan allows you to percept things very clearly and avoid attacks and copy jutsus.When the user activates the third tomoe you can do these things to the maximum level.The magenkyou sharingan gives you three owning jutsus that is really powerful,take amateratsu for example,a very powerful jutsu.Eternal magenkyou sharingan gives you immortality and lets you keep the three owning jutsus and doesn't let you lose your eyesight.The byakugan lets you see as far as 360 degrees but has a blind spot. and well you know the byakugan abilities.My point is sharingan is way better than byakugan.

 

[Uchiha_Cougar]

u know.. byakugan can also slow time down... when they do the divination . 128 plams ...(remember the fight with the spyder-guy from the sound ninja five.) . When spiders are falling.. we get to se from his eyes how slow the spiders are falling.

 

[Shunsui]

havent seen anything special from Byakugan, Sharingan so far delivers

 

[Pain..]

havent seen anything special from Byakugan, Sharingan so far delivers

That's what am saying U_U

 

[Pin]

sharingan! because it can copy stuff (or is that just kakashi?) but then again, going blind would be sucky and ironic -.-