Sharingan can distinguish clones

[-Yard-]

Naruto (regular series) episode 130. It's at the beginning and possibly just a few minutes in really. Naruto makes a bunch of clones that charge at sasuke which sasuke easily defeats and then Sasuke says

"With the sharingan, I can see the real you right away"

I've heard from so many that Sharingan can't tell the difference between a clone and a real person and I believe this may prove that wrong.

 

[Gatsndshanks]

Clones are for pussies anyway.

 

[Talk No Jutsu]

The manga doesn't say anything about the Sharingan being able to tell the real person from Shadow clones, so the anime most likely made a mistake.

 

[Hammy120290]

The manga doesn't say anything about the Sharingan being able to tell the real person from Shadow clones, so the anime most likely made a mistake.

What he said

 

[Capn FlapJak]

probly i mean if he can see chakra im guessin he can telll these r clones that huge chakra hidin over there tho is naruto

 

[Kurogane]

In an episode of the Naruto anime, Sasuke Uchiha claims that the Sharingan can distinguish clones from the original. This contradicts the manga and other anime episodes.

The anime always messing up

 

[Swizzik]

Nah even on Narutopedia it says the sharingan can tell them apart.

 

[Deadai]

Naruto (regular series) episode 130. It's at the beginning and possibly just a few minutes in really. Naruto makes a bunch of clones that charge at sasuke which sasuke easily defeats and then Sasuke says

"With the sharingan, I can see the real you right away"

I've heard from so many that Sharingan can't tell the difference between a clone and a real person and I believe this may prove that wrong.

It sounds legit/good to me:y

 

[Hammy120290]

Disagree Sharingan can distinguigh chakra.

But it is still the USERS chakra. All the chakra would be the same distributed evenly.

Byakugan cannot tell the difference and they can see chakra flow.

 

[Protozoid]

Disagree Sharingan can distinguigh chakra.

But it is still the USERS chakra. All the chakra would be the same distributed evenly.

Byakugan cannot tell the difference and they can see chakra flow.

This is wrong. Not gonna explain why, just know it is. It'll save you and I both the effort. The sharingan in fact can distinguish between the chakras of a clone and the actual shinobi.

 

[Hammy120290]

From Npedia "The Sharingan's second-most prominent ability grants the user an incredible clarity of perception, allowing them to easily recognise genjutsu and different forms of chakra, though not to the same extent as the Byakugan."

If Neji couldn't find Naruto in their Chuunin fight how could a 3T sharingan?

 

[the narukudo]

the sharingan can not tell the differents becoze all narutos have the same amount of chakra as the original i mean even the byakugan could not tell the real naruto.-- that was sasuke being cocky as he always is--.

 

[Swizzik]

From Npedia "The Sharingan's second-most prominent ability grants the user an incredible clarity of perception, allowing them to easily recognise genjutsu and different forms of chakra, though not to the same extent as the Byakugan."

If Neji couldn't find Naruto in their Chuunin fight how could a 3T sharingan?

From Npedia " Sasuke Uchiha claims that the Sharingan can distinguish clones from the original." meaning sharingan can.

 

[Igneel]

for your info...that part you mentioned in episode 130..its not in the manga

 

[Protozoid]

for your info...that part you mentioned in episode 130..its not in the manga

I think it still applies regardless. We can probably find the exact same thing in the manga chapter corresponding to the episode.

 

[-Yard-]

Thanks guys, found the error quickly ^^

 

[Hammy120290]

From Npedia " Sasuke Uchiha claims that the Sharingan can distinguish clones from the original." meaning sharingan can.

Key word there. Anyway could claim that after defeating all the clones to go...ha I knew it was you.

Another point to note is Kakashi vs Naruto 1st fight in Shippuden he couldn't tell the difference.

 

[Protozoid]

Key word there. Anyway could claim that after defeating all the clones to go...ha I knew it was you.

Another point to note is Kakashi vs Naruto 1st fight in Shippuden he couldn't tell the difference.

Yeah, because it makes sense that Sasuke would lie to Naruto when he acted according to his "claim". He demolished the clones with relative ease and was able to tell where the real Naruto lied.

Stop denying pure facts people.

 

[Hammy120290]

Yeah, because it makes sense that Sasuke would lie to Naruto when he acted according to his "claim". He demolished the clones with relative ease and was able to tell where the real Naruto lied.

Stop denying pure facts people.

Ok I could be wrong please go find the relative Manga page for this fight.

 

[ReXii]

Just a typical anime mistake i guess but good thread yard it clears it up a lot of people wonder about that hence the overabuse of a sharingan in the RP