[Discussion] Shanks vs Mihawk at marineford

[akimofnevis]

If Mihawk had killed Luffy we all know that Shanks would have killed a few people. Who do you think would of win if Mihawk and Shanks fought at marineford. I am going with Shanks, what's your opinion .

 

[Fluffyman]

Shanks, easily.

 

[Madarauchiwa]

mihawk.they were matched when shanks had both arms now he just has one and the being in rampage mode after luffas death would put him at a mental disadvantage to the calm and collected mihawk

 

[Fireplay]

When a greater adversary raises his sword it's only natural that the weaker one turns his back....Jk lol. It would've been a long fight but Shanks would've won. Extreme-diff.

Shanks vs Mihawk threads should be banned. They attract the biggest fanboys.

 

[The7thHokage]

Lol

Shanks roflstomps the shit out of Mihawk.

Shanks is arguably the strongest OP characters right now, with BB and Dragon on the same line for debate.

 

[Hexuze]

Shanks, high-diff. Just cause Mihawk and Shanks has daily duels back in the day is irrelevant to scale them together right now. IMO, Pure Haki > Swordsmanship and I'm pretty sure Shanks is superior than Mihawk in haki.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Shanks, extreme diff.

 

[YellowFang]

The battle would be an epic one with Shanks coming out as a victor...

It might prolong but it won't be extreme difficulty for the victor...

 

[Hexuze]

The battle would be an epic one with Shanks coming out as a victor...

It might prolong but it won't be extreme difficulty for the victor...

Too bad we won't get to see it happen...

Man there's so many fights that I want to see happen which I know will never happen. Like Madara vs. WhiteBeard xD

 

[SSS12]

It would be a tie IMO.

 

[akimofnevis]

Shanks, high-diff. Just cause Mihawk and Shanks has daily duels back in the day is irrelevant to scale them together right now. IMO, Pure Haki > Swordsmanship and I'm pretty sure Shanks is superior than Mihawk in haki.

I don't think we have seen mihawk at full power yet

 

[MugiwaraBoy]

Shanks mid diff, although Mihawk is very strong.

 

[VongolaX]

Shanks, extreme diff.

^^This, there battle will last for like 20 days at least.

People will die from watching and islands will be destroyed from sheer will power (Haki).

 

[Pirate King]

Shanks got this, would be a good fight

 

[ultraChalk]

I don't understand how people are being so easily decisive about the winner when we haven't seen either of them at full burst, or even fight seriously.

I can't vote for anybody because I haven't seen them yet, moku.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

^^This, there battle will last for like 20 days at least.

People will die from watching and islands will be destroyed from sheer will power (Haki).

It would be battle of two people from the strongest tier in One Piece, I would expect nothing less U_U

 

[Naruto D Luffy]

Shank of course.

 

[crono0929]

shank arrived, everyone stopped.....including mihawk....just saying.

 

[shon93]

Shanks wins this high diff Shanks swordplay might not be on the same level as Mihawk but speed and elite form of all haki makes up for everything and adds a decent gap between the two

 

[LitzSabr]

Going with Mihawk. Not using any assumptions for this tho, just the manga fact that Mihawk is now the World's Strongest swordsman. A swordsmans remains a swordsman in the end even if he incorporates strong haki with his swordsmanship (like Shanks, or zoro, vista, or Rayleigh). That thing alone is a confirmation of Mihawk being superior to Shanks in terms of strength.