Separation of Chapter Discussion and Predictions

[Mugiwara]

I want to see if people want me from now on to separate Discussion and predictions threads so that you have it like this:
Option one:

Thread 1: Naruto Chapter 550 Discussion

Thread 2: Naruto Chapter 551 Predictions

Thread 3: Naruto Chapter 551 Predictions discussion

Option two:

Thread 1: Naruto Chapter 550 Discussion

Thread 2: Naruto Chapter 551 Predictions

Option three:

Leave it as it is right now, Discussion of the chapter, and prediction of the next chapter occur in the same thread.

In option one, there will be a separate thread to discuss the predictions that are posted in the Prediction thread, while in option two
the predictions and the discussion of the predictions will happen in the same thread. Option three is to leave everything as it is right now.

If a lot of people vote for option one, I might create a hall of fame for predictions, so that if a large part of the prediction actually occurred in the next chapter, it will be added in the Hall of Fame and the one who created the prediction will be rewarded somehow, but later on that.

Another thing: Separating Spoilers and Spoiler Discussion.
Have spoilers in one thread, and discussion of spoilers in another.

Feel free to discuss this, but keep it free for spam.
Also I am open for other suggestions.

 

[Scarface]

I like option one. I think that the predictions and the prediction discussions should be separate because its more neat and clean. More organized to. These threads usually get cluttered with spam, that would definitely cut down on it.

 

[maldoror]

If "Predictions discussion" is a separate thread, people will hardly post in there. It's troublesome since you will need to copy, paste, and quote the prediction from the other(Predictions) thread just to tell which prediction you are discussing about. Option 2 is the way to go.

 

[Mugiwara]

I like option one. I think that the predictions and the prediction discussions should be separate because its more neat and clean. More organized to. These threads usually get cluttered with spam, that would definitely cut down on it.

Yes, in my opinion, Option One is the best because if someone wants to read predictions, and go to prediction thread, they see one prediction, then 2-3 pages of discussion for that prediction, and then another prediction.

Also, does anyone want to separate Spoilers and Spoiler discussion? Since usually it has the same problem, new spoilers get mixed in with the discussion of older spoilers.

If "Predictions discussion" is a separate thread, people will hardly post in there. It's troublesome since you will need to copy, paste, and quote the prediction from the other(Predictions) thread just to tell which prediction you are discussing about. Option 2 is the way to go.

I guess you are right, since people rarely discuss predictions anyway.

 

[maldoror]

About spoilers, there usually are multiple different spoilers about a chapter, half of them just trolls or a confused spoiler which in fact is a prediction.

I've noticed there are some spoiler zealots who usually stalk & detect the correct spoiler most of the weeks. Perhaps administrators could give some sort of a rank to these people so that they can post something like "confirmed spoiler" or "almost confirmed" spoiler. So other people won't get confused (like how it happened this week, tobi being so6p's son and all). I've noticed that dude with "angel castiel" avatar is very good at this for example.

 

[Mugiwara]

About spoilers, there usually are multiple different spoilers about a chapter, half of them just trolls or a confused spoiler which in fact is a prediction.

I've noticed there are some spoiler zealots who usually stalk & detect the correct spoiler most of the weeks. Perhaps administrators could give some sort of a rank to these people so that they can post something like "confirmed spoiler" or "almost confirmed" spoiler. So other people won't get confused (like how it happened this week, tobi being so6p's son and all). I've noticed that dude with "angel castiel" avatar is very good at this for example.

There is no need for that, if we separate the spoiler and spoiler discussion, I can just delete a spoiler it turns out that the spoiler is fake.

 

[Hot.Tendo]

I voted option two... we need to clean and change the manga section plus I dont see any consistency in option three nor one

 

[Kushan]

I vote for option 2 as well, option 1 might be a tad confusion for certain souls here, I mean we're talking about people who can't seem to comprehend relevance of sections and the relationship it should maintain with the threads posted in that section.

With regards to the idea of separating spoilers and spoiler discussions, I have to say yes, but again as previously mentioned, I'm concerned as to how people would follow the rules, it could end up back firing...

 

[Mugiwara]

I vote for option 2 as well, option 1 might be a tad confusion for certain souls here, I mean we're talking about people who can't seem to comprehend relevance of sections and the relationship it should maintain with the threads posted in that section.

With regards to the idea of separating spoilers and spoiler discussions, I have to say yes, but again as previously mentioned, I'm concerned as to how people would follow the rules, it could end up back firing...

No spoiler discussion in spoiler thread, simple as that.
Anyone who discuss spoilers in the actual spoiler thread and not in the spoiler discussion thread will be warned/infracted and their posts will be deleted.

 

[Kushan]

No spoiler discussion in spoiler thread, simple as that.
Anyone who discuss spoilers in the actual spoiler thread and not in the spoiler discussion thread will be warned/infracted and their posts will be deleted.

Obviously but the thing is, it has to be policed and the commitment from the members in reporting breach is the key to success, which you have already pointed out!!!

 

[Sade]

Also, does anyone want to separate Spoilers and Spoiler discussion? Since usually it has the same problem, new spoilers get mixed in with the discussion of older spoilers.

I voted for the third..I like the things how they are but with little changes that were at other Options...But the best is that you just described Mugi...

550 Discussion(Discuss out weeks Manga)
551 Predictions(ONLY POST PREDICTIONS)
551 Predictions Discussion(ONLY DISCUSS THE PREDICTIONS FROM THE "Predictions" THREAD)
551 Spoilers(ONLY POST CONFIRMED SPOILERS)
551 Spoilers Discussion(DISCUSS ABOUT THE SPOILERS FROM "Spoilers" THREAD)

Its the same problem as the Predictions with the Spoilers,this is the best....

Personally I think with this threads is going to be as clean as possible,BUT,only if all of us,see someone that is not following te rule,to click on the report button...

 

[Mugiwara]

I voted for the third..I like the things how they are but with little changes that were at other Options...But the best is that you just described Mugi...

550 Discussion(Discuss out weeks Manga)
551 Predictions(ONLY POST PREDICTIONS)
551 Predictions Discussion(ONLY DISCUSS THE PREDICTIONS FROM THE "Predictions" THREAD)
551 Spoilers(ONLY POST CONFIRMED SPOILERS)
551 Spoilers Discussion(DISCUSS ABOUT THE SPOILERS FROM "Spoilers" THREAD)

Its the same problem as the Predictions with the Spoilers,this is the best....

Personally I think with this threads is going to be as clean as possible,BUT,only if all of us,see someone that is not following te rule,to click on the report button...

Looks like its gonna be option two.
Thread 1: 550 Discussion(Discuss out weeks Manga)
Thread 2: 551 Predictions(PREDICTIONS AND THE DISCUSSION OF THE PREDICTION)
Thread 3: 551 Spoilers(ONLY POST CONFIRMED SPOILERS)
Thread 4: 551 Spoilers Discussion(DISCUSS ABOUT THE SPOILERS FROM "Spoilers" THREAD)

5 threads is a bit too much, and there isn't going to be much discussion on the predictions, so we might as well just put both predictions and the discussion of prediction in the same thread.

 

[Sade]

Looks like its gonna be option two.
Thread 1: 550 Discussion(Discuss out weeks Manga)
Thread 2: 551 Predictions(PREDICTIONS AND THE DISCUSSION OF THE PREDICTION)
Thread 3: 551 Spoilers(ONLY POST CONFIRMED SPOILERS)
Thread 4: 551 Spoilers Discussion(DISCUSS ABOUT THE SPOILERS FROM "Spoilers" THREAD)

5 threads is a bit too much, and there isn't going to be much discussion on the predictions, so we might as well just put both predictions and the discussion of prediction in the same thread.

Personally I dont have problem,but however,I think that a confusio will be created by putting it like this...

5 threads is really much...I can understand that...Buit this is in order to keep the sections more organised and clean,am I right(?),so thats why I explained it like this...

Yeah...Option two will probably "win"

 

[kisamexRocks]

Option 2 is better. it gives people a better chance to read the predictions and then discuss them at the same time, instead of having to switch from one thread, then to the next thread, or have multiple windows or tabs open just to view and comment on the predictions.

 

[Sakon]

Yes option 2 plz and about the spoilers I think there should be 2 different threads with one with the spoilers and another thread for discussing the spoilers.

 

[UzumakiClash]

I vote for Option 2. In Option 1, there is no point of having a section for Prediction Discussion. I think discussing the prediction in its thread is good enough. And Option 3... NO.

 

[apple pie of doom]

Just leave it as it is.
Option 3 is obviously the best.