If you're putting it that way then...
- Sasuke would be **** without a sharingan...He would never have been given the curse seal by orochimaru in the first place. And Kakashi would never teach him chidori, because it requires the sharingan to be used effectively. Plus Oro wouldn't even want him, so no training, so a much weaker sasuke, while Naruto will still have had jiraiya.
- Naruto can still go sage mode wihtout the massive amount of chakra. It would be even better if he doesn't have the kyuubi as then he will be able to do Sage Art: Amphibian Technique, and if u really do read the manga u would know how that benefits him. And Naruto can now do multiple shadow clone jutsu (in big numbers) without relying on the kyuubi now.
- Nowhere is it said who is physically stronger, only speed. And naruto wins with sage mode.
You're clearly a fanboy, you're username says it, your avatar says it, your picture says it, and even your view and points just scream it.
You're making scenario's which would never happen and which u think will guarantee sasuke to win. Sasuke panicked, lost and failed and against Kirabi. And whatever scenario you make up won't change that.
Rofl, Kirabi even had the time to write lyrics in the middle of the fight. And again like someone has already said, the 8-tails confirmed that kirabi had the upperhand.