So lets say Sasuke pierces it without Neji getting hit , the hand sized hole would cause the rest of the Chakra to simply cease to be and stop spinning when a small portion was taken out?
The amount of time it takes for Sasuke's hand to pierce Rotation and pierce Neji is not going to be significant enough for Sasuke to be repelled when he went through Gaara's dome without resistance, and Gaara's dome is around the same size as Neji's Rotation with very minor differences.
Gaara's sand wasn't composed of spinning Chakra which is where my spinning sand dome analogy stemmed from. The unpierced area would not stop spinning after losing a hand sized portion so Sasuke's wrist would be inches away from the unbreached area which would still be in super fast motion. His unprotected wrist then arm would need to cross a greater distance in relation to the spinning unbreached portion of Chakra simply following its path since both are in movemnt simultaneously.
Simply piercing a spinning object does not stop it from spinning unless the thing that pierce it have enough force to do so. Take in example, throwing knife on a spinning wheel does not stop it from spinning. However, if someone with a great physical strength stabbed the knife into the spinning wheel then he would stop it from spinning. I think it is the same case with Rotation and Chidori. Chidori is just like a knife or a spear. The metal sharp part had the penetrative capability to pierce through the wooden spinning wheel just like the lighting Chakra on the hand has the penetrative capability to pierce the spinning the Chakra. However, if the arm that has Chidori doesn't have enough strength then the Chakra would keep spinning. So if Sasuke thrusts Chidori from a melee range, it would be easily redirected as Sasuke haven't shown any strength feat that suggest his arm can stop the spinning. But if he charged with a great momentum that is strong enough then yes, he would stop the Rotation.
Two different scenarios. The latter was a blunt approach, the former is a penetrative one. Chidori would pierce through rotation, and in doing so would most probably cause the jutsu to cease through destroying a small margin of the rotation, distorting the jutsu's cohesion. We've seen multiple techniques fall apart once they've been distorted.
Gaara's Sand is nothing but an example to show that Rotation's level of defensive power and something that is shown to be the same
This isn't about putting up resistance against it. This is about the unbreached area.
Why would destorying the small hand sized margin cause the whole thing to just cease to be instantly ? even in those cases it didn't happen instantly.
1. Naruto's Chakra was getting sucked out simultaneously which messed up his control , not to mention his Rasengan still rotated before vanishing . Neji's Chakra control isn't getting messed if a hand sized hole pierces Rotation. He simply expels the Chakra then spins which allows the Chakra to spin fast w/him.
Lol , faceplam for not remembering wat that was. Ok we use that point and say a Chidori pipe pierces Kaiten without hitting Neji would the rest of the Chakra cease to be or stop spinning since a hole was sent through it?
No, resistance is exactly what you are talking about. You are arguing that the unbreached area will continue spinning and knock Sasuke's arm off course yet Rotation doesn't have the power to do that to something as strong as Chidori. So Chidori will rip through Rotation and hit Neji.
It most likely stops the moment Chidori pierces it.
I'll ask you to clarify again then. What exactly are you arguing will happen when and after Chidori hits Rotation?
Chidori pierces a small hole through the Rotation. Unbreached area of the rotation still in motion would stop spinning before piercing Neji or still continue. Thats basically wat i was analysing.
Then I think it's safe to say we've both come to the conclusion that it stops, right?
In all the cases I linked it happened nigh instantly/soon after.
