Anime Forum

Sasori

Caliburn

Caliburn

Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,771
Kin
2,805💸
Kumi
525💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Remove that he can use rain. Only custom characters and canon characters which have used rain in the manga can use it.


Bahamut said:
Its stated in the manga that the only part of his body left is the left chest area which contains his heart/chakra. Why could we be sure that his brain is in there too? It certainly isn't large enough to contain his whole brain, and if it just had bits and pieces, I think we all know that there wouldn't be any possibility of cognitive thought let alone sensory capability.

You're trying to compare this to the real world, but the problem is Naruto isn't the real world. In Naruto the only thing necessary for life is Chakra. Chakra doesn't exist in RL so you can't compare the two.

As RoH said (by quoting me :p) genjutsu works by manipulating the chakra flow to the prosencephalon. This was stated in the manga. If there is no prosencephalon, then there is no genjutsu. If their is no sensory system to affect, then how can the senses be tricked?

It was never stated in the manga because none of his opponents used a genjutsu. But given the facts that he a.) Has no brain and b.) Genjutsu affects the brain, it is only logical that Sasori is immune to genjutsu.

Also consider Sasori could fall under genjutsu. If its a genjutsu thats rank is too high to break free from using Kai, he would automatically lose. His body feels no pain (as he said to Sakura) so it would be literally impossible for him to break out of the genjutsu.


Sorry for getting involved, but since RoH used my argument about it I thought I should comment also.
Click to expand...
You do realize that what you are saying aren't arguments? I'm not basing this on RL facts, that's something you made up, in fact you have just proven my point: the user needs a brain for genjutsu to work. Why is that? Genjutsu works on the 5 senses and what controls the 5 senses? The brain. If he doesn't have a brain, genjutsu can't work but then the user can't move, talk, hear, smell or taste either. We know that Sasori can still do some of those things, thus he has still parts of his brain left.

This is real in Naruto. Tell me how does he move without a brain? This is true both in Naruto as in RL. Also where did the manga say that his "heart" is his physical heart from his body? Tell me why would he still need a heart? A heart is used to pump blood through a persons body, but his body is a puppet. The only place that still contains blood is his "heart". Are you going to tell me that he's pumping blood through the organ that pumps blood? No that "heart" of his is more of a metaphor to refer to the parts of his original body that are still intact that make the puppet move. In that "heart" of his is everything that he needs to make the puppet hear, walk, talk and where were all those functions in his original body? His brain :| This are not just things from RL, they are real in Naruto or are you going to say that everything is different in the Narutoverse than in the real world?

Your argumentation is based on saying that he doesn't have a brain and only heart, but you failed to prove both. In fact we don't have to prove it's not possible but you that it's possible and you failed completely at that.
 
Last edited:
Lord of Kaos.

Lord of Kaos.

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Sep 11, 2009
Messages
10,090
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Caliburn said:
Remove that he can use rain. Only custom characters and canon characters which have used rain in the manga can use it.




You do realize that what you are saying aren't arguments? I'm not basing this on RL facts, that's something you made up, in fact you have just proven my point: the user needs a brain for genjutsu to work. Why is that? Genjutsu works on the 5 senses and what controls the 5 senses? The brain. If he doesn't have a brain, genjutsu can't work but then the user can't move, talk, hear, smell or taste either. We know that Sasori can still do some of those things, thus he has still parts of his brain left.

This is real in Naruto. Tell me how does he move without a brain? This is true both in Naruto as in RL. Also where did the manga say that his "heart" is his physical heart from his body? Tell why would he still need a heart? A heart is used to pump blood through a persons body, but his body is a puppet. The only place that still contains blood is his "heart". Are youg going to tell me that he's pumping blood through the organ that pumps blood? No that "heart" of his is more of a metaphor to refer to the parts of his original body that are still intact that make the puppet move. In that "heart" of his is everything that he needs to make the puppet hear, walk and talk and where were all those functions in his original body? His brain :| This are not just things from RL, they are real in Naruto or are you going to say that everything is different in the Narutoverse than in the real world?

Your argumentation is based on saying that he doesn't have a brain and only heart, but you failed to prove both. In fact we don't have to prove it's not possible but you that it's possible and you failed completely at that.
Click to expand...
sorry, removed the rain part, also u dont need to continue argueing I already removed the immunity to gen part
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top