Rinnegan vs Sharingan: Fair Comparison

[KCMNaruto]

Rinnegan clearly take this:

1) Even Obito know better then try to fight dual Rinnegan original wielder

also

2) Limbo is faster then kamui proved by databook and Madara mentioning in manga as hint to get Obito

 

[Apêx1]

Rinnegan wins because;

1. Rinnegan users can switch with the Limbo as shown against the Shukaku seal/Senjutsu Chidori (assuming this is allowed, wouldn't make sense if it wasn't as you would be purposefully wanting the Rinnegan user to die.)

2. Rinnegan user has Limbos demolish the Sharingan user.

3. The fact you made them sit down on a chair instead of stationary standing with unrestricted arm movements is the only reason I can see the Sharingan user winning.

 

[21 Savage]

Rinnengan wins........

 

[VongolaX]

In the end it all boils down to chakra

Just by having the strongest/most chakra, you can beat the other doujustu regardless of which one it is.

The only thing I can give you is that the sharingan can be the most haxx.

Kamui and Amenome (kaguya's sharingan) are perfect examples.

 

[V h o]

DMS Kamui solos, however rinnegan is better than sharingan.

 

[BigGuns Reloaded]

Two users with everything equal.

We are testing the best of Sharingan vs the Best of Rinnegan. (No Rinne Sharingan here as that is a different dojutsu)


One has real Dual Rinnegan. The other has Obito's Dual MS Sharingan.


Both strapped down to a chair to make this a controlled experiment.

Both stare at each other and uses their eyes only. No body movement. Just eyes only.


Who wins? Man with Sharingan or Man with Rinnegan?


The winner determines once and for all the superior eye.

From the looks of this thread you clearly believe the rinnegan is better you didn't actually make it fair

Considering the 6 gods(not a drake reference) a nd kamui are sharingan jutsu they all should all be included

Anyways as of now the lopsided competition u have goes to the rinne because chibaku asura and king of hell

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

If its a staring contest, Kamui Snipe GG.

 

[Mr Hiru]

Then you are saying that inherently Rinnegan is weaker than Sharingan when comparing the best of both?


That contradicts Kishi's opinion that Rinnegan is the greatest of the great dojutsu.

Isn't that a contradiction?

Sage Naruto beated Pain's ass. And then Edo Itachi beated Edo Nagato's ass.

No, man. I'd respectfully suggest to stop comparing two doujutsus and stop using folklore as if they were facts. Rinnegan is not better than Sharingan, it is just different, it has other properties.

The doujutsu don't determine the effectivity of the techniques. It's the user, stop trying to prove this wrong.

 

[Bansho Tenin]

susanoo while sitting down, amaterasu.

 

[Mr Hiru]

Anyways, Obito's MS wins in the proposed scenario. Any Rinnegan technique gets nullified, MS user would free himself with the ability to pass over objects, teleport behind the Rinnegan user (outside the Rinnegan vision field) and then... Kamui to cut the Rinnegan user's head.

:v

 

[Bansho Tenin]

Anyways, Obito's MS wins in the proposed scenario. Any Rinnegan technique gets nullified, MS user would free himself with the ability to pass over objects, teleport behind the Rinnegan user (outside the Rinnegan vision field) and then... Kamui to cut the Rinnegan user's head.

:v

can you shinra tensei kamui?

 

[Mr Hiru]

can you shinra tensei kamui?

No c:

 

[Bansho Tenin]

i think it depends on who has the rinnengan. Madara can use susanoo with his.
Nagato would probably lose
Obito with both ms would have a tough time against Madara in this scenario.

susanoo/limbo

 

[Mr Hiru]

i think it depends on who has the rinnengan. Madara can use susanoo with his.
Nagato would probably lose
Obito with both ms would have a tough time against Madara in this scenario.

susanoo/limbo

How could Susano'o/Limbo touch someone using Kamui with both MS? XD

 

[Bansho Tenin]

How could Susano'o/Limbo touch someone using Kamui with both MS? XD

depends who got to use either first. which is faster? activating limbo or obito phasing out of the restraints? when madara b1tch slapped all the tailed beasts it was almost instant and they were pretty far away too.

 

[Bronze]

Rinnegan wins.

Limbo can only be seen by Rinnegan and only sensed by Rikudou Senjutsu. So the Sharingan user is automatically blitzed by Limbo. Amatersu and Enton are useless by the gravitational forces granted by Deva Path, as seen with Nagato countering Amatersu using the said Jutsu. Or it's absorbed by Preta Path. Susanoo is powerless against Chibaku Tensei and Tengai Shensei. Tsukuyomi and KA don't work on Rinnegan, since it gives immunity to Visual Genjutsu. Kamui is useless against Amenotejikara and Limbo, since both fall under space-time techniques. Kurama is suppressed by Gedo Mazou. Not to mention Rinnegan is an evolution of Sharingan, so it maintains the Sharingan's powers.

Like said before, it's dependent on the user, but Rinnegan is overall vastly superior.

 

[Bansho Tenin]

Rinnegan wins.

Limbo can only be seen by Rinnegan and only sensed by Rikudou Senjutsu. So the Sharingan user is automatically blitzed by Limbo. Amatersu and Enton are useless by the gravitational forces granted by Deva Path, as seen with Nagato countering Amatersu using the said Jutsu. Or it's absorbed by Preta Path. Susanoo is powerless against Chibaku Tensei and Tengai Shensei. Tsukuyomi and KA don't work on Rinnegan, since it gives immunity to Visual Genjutsu. Kamui is useless against Amenotejikara and Limbo, since both fall under space-time techniques. Kurama is suppressed by Gedo Mazou. Not to mention Rinnegan is an evolution of Sharingan, so it maintains the Sharingan's powers.

Like said before, it's dependent on the user, but Rinnegan is overall vastly superior.

i think in this scenario, its who gets the first 'hit'. thats who wins.

 

[Mr Hiru]

depends who got to use either first. which is faster? activating limbo or obito phasing out of the restraints? when madara b1tch slapped all the tailed beasts it was almost instant and they were pretty far away too.

This kind of argumentation forces the Rinnegan to be the winner doujutsu... but at which cost? Biased opinion, of course, because you're including the character's skill in your judgement.

It's useless to compare two different users, when in fact we are only comparing the doujutsus in this thread.

Try to use the case of Dual Obito's MS Madara against Dual Rinnegan Madara, both with the same experience, this situation will put the users ability out of equation... that's how we will be able to focus our energies in comparing the doujutsus.

Who wins? Rinnegan or Obito's MS?

 

[Bansho Tenin]

This kind of argumentation forces the Rinnegan to be the winner doujutsu... but at which cost? Biased opinion, of course, because you're including the character's skill in your judgement.

It's useless to compare two different users, when in fact we are only comparing the doujutsus in this thread.

Try to use the case of Dual Obito's MS Madara against Dual Rinnegan Madara, both with the same experience, this situation will put the users ability out of equation... that's how we will be able to focus our energies in comparing the doujutsus.

Who wins? Rinnegan or Obito's MS?

it could go either way. I'd love to see an anime of that, i wouldn't care who would win.
Madara would probably underestimate his power. and so would Obito.

fanfic at its best.