Rinnegan vs Sharingan: Fair Comparison

[Senju Bean]

Two users with everything equal.

We are testing the best of Sharingan vs the Best of Rinnegan. (No Rinne Sharingan here as that is a different dojutsu)


One has real Dual Rinnegan. The other has Obito's Dual MS Sharingan.


Both strapped down to a chair to make this a controlled experiment.

Both stare at each other and uses their eyes only. No body movement. Just eyes only.


Who wins? Man with Sharingan or Man with Rinnegan?


The winner determines once and for all the superior eye.

 

[Gerkak]

rinnegan wins. limbo GG

 

[Punk Hazard]

How skilled is the Sharingan user with Kamui?

 

[Limbo]

Depends on the users entirely, example, Nagato gets negged by DMS Obito or EMS Madara but Dual Rinnegan Madara negs Obito/EMS Madara.

 

[RinneBlitz]

The Sharingan, because of the Genjutsu. But if they use their bodies... GG Sharry, it was nice to know you lol.

 

[Senju Bean]

How skilled is the Sharingan user with Kamui?

Equally skilled as the Rinnegan user is with Rinnegan.

 

[IndraGripen]

Rinnegan evolves from sharingan

 

[Punk Hazard]

Equally skilled as the Rinnegan user is with Rinnegan.

That's not what I asked you. How well is their usage of Kamui? We talking early Shippuden Kakashi, mid-Shippuden Kakashi, or end of Shippuden Kakashi-Obito?

 

[Senju Bean]

That's not what I asked you. How well is their usage of Kamui? We talking early Shippuden Kakashi, mid-Shippuden Kakashi, or end of Shippuden Kakashi-Obito?

How about Hagoromo with his Prime Useage of Rinnegan vs his long lost identical twin brother who's only difference is that he has dual Obito MS.


So presumably, it's power would be beyond end of shippuden Kakashi.

 

[Punk Hazard]

How about Hagoromo with his Prime Useage of Rinnegan vs his long lost identical twin brother who's only difference is that he has dual Obito MS.


So presumably, it's power would be beyond end of shippuden Kakashi.

Kamui wins then.

 

[Senju Bean]

Kamui wins then.

Then you are saying that inherently Rinnegan is weaker than Sharingan when comparing the best of both?


That contradicts Kishi's opinion that Rinnegan is the greatest of the great dojutsu.

Isn't that a contradiction?

 

[Tarinth]

Well this just depends on how far away they are from each other. And how strong each of them
are in their bodies. If this is like JJ Madara using limbo, then the limbo would GG the kamui user.
If this is someone less capable and like 100 meters away using limbo, Kamui ggs them before
limbo comes. So basically the victory depends on how strong they are, with the stronger both
of them are making rinnegan more favorable and vice versa for weaker characters.
Distance also plays a role.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Then you are saying that inherently Rinnegan is weaker than Sharingan when comparing the best of both?


That contradicts Kishi's opinion that Rinnegan is the greatest of the great dojutsu.

Isn't that a contradiction?

1. Kishi is synonymous with contradiction, how new are you really?

2. No, there's one aspect of Sharingan that is stronger than the Rinnegan but overall, Rinnegan is stronger. Unfortunately for you, the stronger power isn't always the power that triumphs.

 

[Senju Bean]

1. Kishi is synonymous with contradiction, how new are you really?

2. No, there's one aspect of Sharingan that is stronger than the Rinnegan but overall, Rinnegan is stronger. Unfortunately for you, the stronger power isn't always the power that triumphs.

Yes it is. I made this comparison as fair as possible by setting everything the same except the eyes.

By making it 1 v 1.

Also, Kishi wouldn't contradict it.


If Kishi really thinks that Rinnegan>Sharingan.


Then Rinnegan must have someway of stopping the Kamui Snipe. Even if it wasn't shown. And the best bet lies in Preta Path.




Rinnegan may be more useful at reviving people or at taking on multiple opponents, but that doesn;t make it the strongest.


What makes it the strongest was how well it can fare against any one particular opponent.

Afterall, the main threats in NV aren't armies( they are individuals, Pein, Madara, Kaguya, Juubi etc)

 

[Trúth]

Yes it is. I made this comparison as fair as possible by setting everything the same except the eyes.

By making it 1 v 1.

Also, Kishi wouldn't contradict it.


If Kishi really thinks that Rinnegan>Sharingan.


Then Rinnegan must have someway of stopping the Kamui Snipe. Even if it wasn't shown. And the best bet lies in Preta Path.

Nothing but fanfiction.​

 

[-immortal-]

They both snipe eachother



Limbo gg
Kamui gg

Equal

 

[Senju Bean]

Nothing but fanfiction.​

Kamui Snipe never hit a Rinnegan user.

So I guess by lack of evidence, that would be fan fic as well

 

[Trúth]

Kamui Snipe never hit a Rinnegan user.

So I guess by lack of evidence, that would be fan fic as well

Konohamaru has never been hit by Kirin so by lack of evidence he must have some way to block or dodge it.

​

 

[AlphaMaleLion]

Limbo soloes

 

[3MESSIAH]

kamui would be faster than limbo in this instance so i think DMS wins in this scenario...it`s different if they are granted movement though