[Suggestion] Request to make the forum to be liberal discussions

[The Sach]

That transition has already started.

Yeah I am just hoping that NB will undergo awesome revamp.^^

 

[Joseph Gomes]

No we don't.

You must be registered for see images

and

You must be registered for see images

Can Sakura beat this pokemon?

^ your idea of cross over..

First image is your threads 3 months ago and second your threads recently. You said something about trolls spamming the section? Almost all your posts end up on Sakura bashing and nothing else despite multiple warnings and infractions.

If MAC section is less active it's because less people are interested in discussing those mangas. It doesn't mean they should not be able to have neat discussions threads and must go through Sakura and itachi threads for their own topic.

I tried to make some thread about One Piece and Bleach but all of them were deleted/locked. If crossover battles were allowed I wouldn't bother with the likes of Sakura.

 

[Joseph Gomes]

I agree here and time has come for Narutobase to become Mangabase.

I agree. If that happens this website will become 100x better. Most Naruto discussion topics are repetitive. It would be best to promote new mangas are Naruto is already over

 

[I'm stupid real stupid]

I tried to make some thread about One Piece and Bleach but all of them were deleted/locked. If crossover battles were allowed I wouldn't bother with the likes of Sakura.

Crossover battles usually end in people bashing the series the said character is in.

 

[Six Paths]

I can clearly see what everyone means when they talk about the multimanga base. But lets be honest, NB is kind of a multi-manga base. It has separate sections for each manga and now time after time, these sections are growing, now we have a section for the old manga, like Dragon ball, or Case Closed (Detective Conan), but eve the newer very good ones like Akame ga Kiru and Tokyo ghoul. This will slowly expand in on itself and become very huge, hence why I believe Narutobase will never die out.

But lets be frank here, the reason why Naruto discussions is so much bigger than all of the M.A.C sections, is because this is what this page started as. It was a Naruto Manga page, and people might have joined for the full reason of talking about Naruto. And to think that Naruto remained the #1 manga in Mangapanda, the page where most of us read the latest manga, it made everyone check it out at least once, and then get sucked in the amazing story which Naruto is. So yes, This page is becoming a multimanga site, and yes, the Naruto sections is a lot bigger than all the others. But this is simply understandable.

 

[Joseph Gomes]

Crossover battles usually end in people bashing the series the said character is in.

This is where the mods can step up, of course. Animevice is practically all crossover threads. I barely see any blatant trolling/bashing over there. The mods over here can do the same

As long as Naruto discussion is limited to Naruto only, Itachi/Sakura/Hinata etc troll threads will continue. What else is there to do? The manga is already over. The mods will keep on banning the trolls and wasting their time.

I can clearly see what everyone means when they talk about the multimanga base. But lets be honest, NB is kind of a multi-manga base. It has separate sections for each manga and now time after time, these sections are growing, now we have a section for the old manga, like Dragon ball, or Case Closed (Detective Conan), but eve the newer very good ones like Akame ga Kiru and Tokyo ghoul. This will slowly expand in on itself and become very huge, hence why I believe Narutobase will never die out.

But lets be frank here, the reason why Naruto discussions is so much bigger than all of the M.A.C sections, is because this is what this page started as. It was a Naruto Manga page, and people might have joined for the full reason of talking about Naruto. And to think that Naruto remained the #1 manga in Mangapanda, the page where most of us read the latest manga, it made everyone check it out at least once, and then get sucked in the amazing story which Naruto is. So yes, This page is becoming a multimanga site, and yes, the Naruto sections is a lot bigger than all the others. But this is simply understandable.

I am sorry but I disagree. MAC section is practically empty. Gintama has new threads once after every 2/3 months. Kimi no todoke has only 1 thread so far. That's not much activity.

I wouldn't have created this thread if Naruto wasn't over. But as the manga is finished, it's logical to allow other manga because there's nothing new to discuss about Naruto. There's no room for prediction or theories.

However, if crossover threads are allowed more people will read Naruto again, as well as other manga...

 

[Avani 👑]

I tried to make some thread about One Piece and Bleach but all of them were deleted/locked. If crossover battles were allowed I wouldn't bother with the likes of Sakura.

You totally missed the point didn't you?

There are plenty of other things to do than pitting characters from different versus and make an imaginary argument over and imaginary character. But people should be reading those manga first and want to discuss it

Letting you spam ND with other mangas doesn't resolve anything. I am not going to look for the thread you claim to be deleted in your Sakura thread maze but it wouldn't have been deleted if it was a genuine discussion and wasn't breaking rules. If it's an OP thread post it in OP section.

Activity increases if people take initiative and become active themselves. At first you may get fewer responses but if the discussion is good that's enough. Better than pointless spam of repetitive topic with " 10/10". "will read again", " nice thread" "lel" by many just to keep bumping a fellow fanboy or hater kind of activity. You could as well be discussing with your cat.

You must be registered for see images

You shouldn't measure the activity level by comparison with other sections either. Naruto section gets more posts because it was not only one of the more popular mangas, it's one of the longest ones. 700 chapter in a duration of some 15 years along with theme of clashing views.

Short series or less popular ones naturally get less people talking about them and of course discussion can be over the available material only. But, there are many other sections which are decently active and people who are really interested carry on their discussions.

 

[Joseph Gomes]

You totally missed the point didn't you?

There are plenty of other things to do than pitting characters from different versus and make an imaginary argument over and imaginary character. But people should be reading those manga first and want to discuss it

Letting you spam ND with other mangas doesn't resolve anything. I am not going to look for the thread you claim to be deleted in your Sakura thread maze but it wouldn't have been deleted if it was a genuine discussion. If it's an OP thread post it in OP section.

Activity increases if people take initiative and become active themselves. At first you may get fewer responses but if the discussion is good that's enough. Better than pointless spam of repetitive topic with " 10/10". "will read again", " nice thread" "lel" by many just to keep bumping a fellow fanboy or hater kind of activity. You could as well be discussing with your cat.

You must be registered for see images

You shouldn't measure the activity level by comparison.

Short series or less popular ones naturally get less people talking about them and of course discussion can be over the available material only. But, there are many other sections which are decently active and people who are really interested carry on their discussions.

There are plenty of other things to do? Like what? Naruto is already over. The movie has come out. Boruto mini series will be about Boruto, not Naruto. Just like Rock Lee SD is about Rock Lee

My thread was about Admirals and Hashirama. Why should a crossover thread be in One Piece section if it also included Naruto? Obviously I'm going to post it in a forum which is more active.

As it stand now, Naruto discussion is a playground for trolls. I don't care about other forums personally, and there's nothing else for me to do in other forums. I'm talking about Naruto discussion here. My proposal is, as long Naruto is in it, it should be allowed. If there's any bashing the mods will take care of that.

There are plenty of long and short series which have good discussions. Just go to Animevice and you'll find out. I have no clue why the admins/mods are reluctant about changes. Crossover discussion >>> pointless pairing/wank threads anyday

 

[Avani 👑]

This is where the mods can step up, of course. Animevice is practically all crossover threads. I barely see any blatant trolling/bashing over there. The mods over here can do the same

As long as Naruto discussion is limited to Naruto only, Itachi/Sakura/Hinata etc troll threads will continue. What else is there to do? The manga is already over. The mods will keep on banning the trolls and wasting their time.

If someone is posting they still haven't gotten it out of their system. No one is asking you to participate if you are over it.

I am sorry but I disagree. MAC section is practically empty. Gintama has new threads once after every 2/3 months. Kimi no todoke has only 1 thread so far. That's not much activity.

Yea because people like you are who claim to be interested in other manga discussions are hardly ever posting there but spamming Naruto media.

I wouldn't have created this thread if Naruto wasn't over. But as the manga is finished, it's logical to allow other manga because there's nothing new to discuss about Naruto. There's no room for prediction or theories.

DBZ is over and we made a section for it because people still want to discus it and demanded it. So I don't really see your point.

However, if crossover threads are allowed more people will read Naruto again, as well as other manga...

Yea .. right.. Your suggestion is similar to this:

You must be registered for see images

It won't work.


We are not changing rules for your personal convenience and whim. How many times it has to be emphasized? Every site has it's own way of running and setting. You should chose one which suits your need.

 

[Souji]

How hard is it to click the MAC forum? It's on the same page as all the other subforums (NDS included).

 

[Memento Mori]

Hmm...Users come to Q/S Section.

>>>Posts a thread asking they need a Nanatsu no Taijai,Kuroko no Basuke,Detective Conan and asks sections for all the anime they think at that moment.
>>>Versuvio Comes to online
>>>Visit's the thread
>>>Be happy and creates a Section for it
>>>Section for whatever anime they have asked for is created under M.A.C section.
>>>All the old threads related to the respective section are transferred.
>>>People who have asked for the Section(s) rarely posts or not post anything at all either.
>>>And then section remains inactive.
>>>Whereabouts of the people who have asked the section they want are unknown.

 

[Anduril]

Hmm...Users come to Q/S Section.

>>>Posts a thread asking they need a Nanatsu no Taijai,Kuroko no Basuke,Detective Conan and asks sections for all the anime they think at that moment.
>>>Versuvio Comes to online
>>>Visit's the thread
>>>Be happy and creates a Section for it
>>>Section for whatever anime they have asked for is created under M.A.C section.
>>>All the old threads related to the respective section are transferred.
>>>People who have asked for the Section(s) rarely posts or not post anything at all either.
>>>And then section remains inactive.
>>>Whereabouts of the people who have asked the section they want are unknown.

Sections are not made because a user/member wants them to be made. They are made because the staff think its appropriate to provide a section. So even if a person/member has suggested a section it does not mean he has to take up the responsibility to keep that particular section alive.
Like all the other suggestion, the staff has all the right to not accept that suggested section or forum. So don't blame other members.

 

[Memento Mori]

Sections are not made because a user/member wants them to be made.

Oh really ?

They are made because the staff think its appropriate to provide a section.

Does on what criteria they think it is appropriate to provide a section ?They randomly do ?

So even if a person/member has suggested a section it does not mean he has to take up the responsibility to keep that particular section alive.

Did I say specifically said that he/she should take a responsibility ?

Like all the other suggestion, the staff has all the right to not accept that suggested section or forum.

Who said not ?

So don't blame other members.

Where did I ?All I did was just posting what users did so far in the Q/S Section.It is not an Iron rule that everyone must comment in the section they have asked to,is it ?

 

[Scorps]

Narutobase is one of the few sites that doesn't allow multiverse discussion in their main forum. Narutoforum is much more open minded in this regard. Even Comicvine freely allows manga and anime related threads

As the manga is over, the site's can remain active if multiverse topics are allowed in the forum. Naruto can be made mandatory topic to be included in every multiverse discussion. Otherwise the forums are full of same kind of threads (trolling, spamming, pairing, flaming etc.). Multiverse topics would make the members interested in Naruto more than ever, which would be required to participate in any debate. Members would also gain knowledge on other anime/manga.

Do consider this propsal

Picking up 2 or more different universes, with different "laws", physics, powers, etc and comparing them is simply ridiculous. To compare something, that something needs to be comparable.

Example:

Gaara VS Magneto.

Ridiculous. For one, Gaara has Chakra, ninjutsu, lives in Narutoverse where life is linked to chakra, where death makes you pass on to another plane of existance, your soul can be called back and reincarnated into a corpse, you can seal something inside a scroll, etc etc. Magneto on the other hand, is a mutant. Aside from having the ability to manipulate magnetic fields, he is bound by the same physics and laws as there would be in our Real Word, something that Gaara is not bound by because his World has its own rules which, in some key aspects, diverts from ours; the world of mutants is otherwise paralel to ours in terms of universal laws. Power levels can't be compared because the scales are not only different as the gravity that moves them is not even the same. Comparing both is like comparing a Banana with.... the color White. A Banana is a fruit and White isn't even a color. It simply makes no sense.

Besides, you claim that because Naruto ended, we need to allow other mangas do be discussed. But we do. M.A.C Section. Actually, if you check the annoucements forum, you'll see that Versuvio, the owner, has described his plans for Narutobase to eventually make its way over to Mangabase. The fact that Naruto ended has already been acknowledged and the site itself is already migrating to a more broad discussion forum for other Mangas. However, none of that has anything to do with allowing multiverse discussions. Those have been tolerated before and the result is always a pointless discussion and a useless set of arguments that ends up leading to a flame war.