Winner's can be determined. it's just like Kakashi vs pein, both are skilled ninja in different ways but it depends on who's the better fighter. in the end Deva path wouldn've lost because kakashi, less powerful, outsmarted him.
thanks, i made a mistake, it was bee in 8tails mode who got burn, but i found that KM Naruto can be burnt by lava:
You must be registered for see links
and it's clear Amaterasu is hotter thank lava.
Bold:All in full health and chakra.
50 meters
vast field.
Minato has kunai spread out at the beginning of the fight. Itachi Activates his MS and Nagato summons his "weird animals". Naruto goes in to KM mode first.
I Say Itachi and Nagato pwns. Bijuu bomb can be absorbed by nagato, and dont say "Bijuu bomb happenes instantly he won't have time to absorb it!" then how did Madara absorb Onooki's dust tech?
People are saying minato just has to avoid Itachi's eyes and he'll be out of genjutsu range. thats incorrect, as far as i remember itachi can cast his genjutsu from his finger, meaning that he could do so at the beginning of the fight U_U
itachi's full susanoo cannot be damaged because of the shield. he can easily seal the oversized BM naruto.
If the alkali from Tailbeast Version 2 can burn Naruto, then Amaterasu would definitely do the job.
Itachi and nagato wins.
How can that be so? Each character you have listed in the first post has already made their preparations.
Each one character is incline to make their first move. Which character makes their first move is undetermined. Even if they make the first move, during the battle, it can't be predicted for the last duration of the battle. Those, it would be base off our speculation and/or assumption during that time-frame on who would have they overwhelming advantage until the end.
We would also be biased to one side and not looking at the battle as a whole. Also, even if someone were to post a logical and unbiased side to the battle, many would still disagree.
Underline: (Example)
What proof do you have the Bijuu-dama could be absorb by Nagato while he is in full health? Nagato might can't absorb such a massive size and attack such as Bijuu-dama that is created by Jinchuuriki. What makes you say that it is entirely made of chakra and not something else. Say, blood with a mixture of chakra.
Itachi has Genjutsu that places you under control without you being aware. Minato, who is Hokage, has probably heard of the Uchiha's Sharingan casting Genjutsu and has skills and abillties to counter. Besides, Minato, with FTG prep, can counter at any giving moment during the first phase of battle without having to fall under Itachi's Genjutsu.
Nagato's summons is an issue, but they can be counter by Naruto's summonings and/or Naruto himself, when he enter Bijuu Mode.
What makes you think Amaterasu could burn such as the alkali from Tailbeast Version 2? Is their proof that you can back it up?
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Their is no way of determining a winner based on assumption because everyone has their on opinion. Even if Kishi was to say [Blah, Blah wins], and not write, draw, or sketch out, many would still disagree.