[Discussion] Rayleigh vs Shiki

[Dr Strangelove]

I know its hard to say since we haven't seen anything from either but Shiki did manage to almost take down MF (im not talking about film Shiki here)
Still however I would go with Rayleigh.

 

[the big boss]

one on one Rayleigh

crew vs crew, shiki had a massive fleet, and the roger pirates got "lucky"

 

[Lord Naruto San]

I hope we see Shiki as a Manga character and not one of those Filler/villian in movies thats just a troll. Luffy takin him out i guess Movie Luffy > Whitebeard and Garp

 

[the big boss]

I hope we see Shiki as a Manga character and not one of those Filler/villian in movies thats just a troll. Luffy takin him out i guess Movie Luffy > Whitebeard and Garp

shiki is in chapter zero if i remember correctly

 

[ziggyZ]

Both in their prime: Shiki takes it High DIFF.


Movie Shiki vs. current Rayleigh: Either a draw or Shiki wins XHigh DIFF.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Shiki would take it at the peaks of their power. Currently I am siding with Rayleigh though.

 

[Fujitora]

I feel like Rayleigh would take it, prime and now.