[Discussion] Rank Roger, Whitebeard, Rayleigh, Garp and Sengoku

[Olorin]

they were major players of their era and it is said that Newgates power rivaled that of Roger, also that Garp and Roger almost killed eachother on many occasions. Weve only really seen WB really go nuts so I know really ranking them is impossible, but theres no reason not to tell your opinion. So how would you rank them?

also could Garp (or Sengoku for that matter) really match WB at marineford, whats your take on that?

Edit: all of them in their prime

 

[Yonkou Pandaman]

1. Roger
2. Shiro
3. Garp
4. Rayleigh
5. Sengoku

 

[Loome]

Roger will surely go first.
And the rest, I cant tell. I havent watched One Piece enough. I am up-to-date with the manga, but I watched it in a hurry.

 

[ballerjordan]

1. Roger
2. Garp
3. Whitebeard
4. Rayleigh
5. Sengoku

I think Garp and Roger are equal

 

[Fujitora]

Roger, WB - strongest of all time
Rayleigh, Garp - a step below Roger/WB
Sengoku - a step below Rayleigh, Garp

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Rodger>=whitebeard>reigliee>sengoku>=garp

 

[Souji]

Roger
WB
Garp/Sengoku
Rayleigh

 

[CommanderInChief]

Seems to me that they were basically equals. You have to remember, Whitebeard had no desire for "conquering" the ocean.

 

[KGB Kakuzu]

Based on what people have said (in the manga) as well as what we saw,

1. Roger/Garp

2. Whitebeard

3. Sengoku

4. Rayleigh


Kind of hard to put Garp over Whitebeard, but what we see from Garp hasn't been much of anything, and he still managed to speed blitz Marco. Based on the fact that Roger and Garp constantly fought, and they never beat/killed the other....I'm guessing they were about equal!

 

[Fujitora]

Iirc WB is the only one to have equaled against Roger, never losing against him.

 

[ziggyZ]

1. Roger
2. Garp & WB
3. WB
4. Rayleigh
5. Sengoku

 

[ziggyZ]

Iirc WB is the only one to have equaled against Roger, never losing against him.

As was Garp also the man to rival and at times "take Roger to the limit".

Rodger>=whitebeard>reigliee>sengoku>=garp

Roger
WB
Garp/Sengoku
Rayleigh

Nope.

 

[Naruto D Luffy]

1. Roger Gold
2. Rayliegh Dark
3. Sengoku
4.Garp

 

[ziggyZ]

1. Roger Gold
2. Rayliegh Dark
3. Sengoku
4.Garp

No chance.

 

[WhistleBlower]

1.Roger
2.Garp
3.Whitebeard
4.Sengoku
5.Rayleigh

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

1.roger
2.whitebeard
3.garp
4.rayleigh
5.garp

 

[ziggyZ]

1.roger
2.whitebeard
3.garp
4.rayleigh
5.garp

It's been stated by Roger himself that Garp took him to a limit no one has. Hence why he is second.