[Discussion] Plotholes with HxH *gasp*

[Yubel]

LOl Don't you think you need to understand the distinction between an argument or a statement of fact before you can cry fallacies?

If you made your point already so did I. Agree to disagree rather than trying to make up for lack of a convincing argument with rudeness.

I made my point with enough convincing evidence, the rest was an argument against the observations I made in the OP. You even call it an argument yourself in the bolded. If you don't have anything more to add to the thread I'd prefer you don't speak at all, you said you were leaving yet you're still here, you say agree to disagree but you clinged to the first sentence in my other post instead of adressing the argument or just walking away like a mature person. You need to make up your mind but I won't reply to you again because logic doesn't work apparently, bye.

 

[Freecss]

Lol at you not replying to my post. No Phantom Troupe member can fight within themselves. Chrollo was even there. They left everything up to him. The homie put some trust in Hisoka.

 

[Complex]

I don't get how this is a plothole :/

 

[Freecss]

I don't get how this is a plothole :/

It's not really.

 

[Twisted007]

So hear me out on this one. I was rewatching some HxH episodes when I reached the part where the Phantom Troupe were talking about their fortune written by Chrollo regarding losing half their limbs, anyone remember that part? Afterwards Hisoka gave his fortune to Pakunoda who showed it to everyone after changing it using Texture Surprise.

Plot Hole #1: It's obvious Hisoka used In to render his aura invisible after having used Texture Surprise. However, everyone in the Phantom Troupe know what Hisoka's ability is as they were discussing it when they were first introduced. Even if they don't know the full extent of Bungee Gum's abilities, we know atleast Machi(the pink-haired member) is aware of Texture Surprise. Even if we assume they didn't, the Phantom Troupe are professional killers and top tier Nen users. To not use Gyo in that situation is a plot hole considering they're not ones to trust each other. So Machi knew about Texture Surprise from the Heavens Arena arc but somehow it didn't even occur to her that he might be scheming something despite the long explanation he gave her about his abilities + seeing them in battle where she used Gyo to see through his In when no one else besides Wing did it. For Machi to not see through Hisoka or the Phantom Troupe member to see through the deception is a plot hole.

Plot Hole #2: Pakunoda has the ability to read minds, as soon as they became aware of Hisoka possibly having sold them out. She could've simply used her powers to scoop up his memory which would've given definite proof that he's lying about the whole thing. Once they know the truth they would've killed Hisoka then and there, for the Phantom Troupe to not question him further was plot hole all for the sake of the plot to keep Hisoka alive and let him fool the Phantom Troupe but he didn't outsmart them, Togashi decided to dumb them down to make Hisoka look good and save his ass.

So there you have it, if you've read this far congratulations. You now know that even a series like HxH has plot holes.

Plothole 2: Scaze said this already but you didn't respond to him. Reading Hisoka's memory wasn't an option because he had a sword of truth on his heart. Both Chrollo and Shalnark made this clear. That was a brilliant play by Hisoka who nullified Paku's nen with that line.

Plothole 1: Texture surprise can be used without bungeegum and Gyo doesn't help, that's why Killua was fooled as well in GI.The only way to tell if the surface is fake is to touch it. Gyo is not the issue but the fact that Machi didn't think of the use of texture surprise because as far as we know she is the only one who knew about this power. Can Hisoka outwit Machi? I would say yes and that that's the main reason things played out that way. How ever this was very convenient for the story.