tejasomina
Member
130 posts
25 reactions
- Joined
- Jun 27, 2012
- Messages
- 130
- Reaction score
- 25
- Status
- Offline
- Activity Streak
In the last chapter, Tobirama says this
He basically says that the Sharingan is awakened and is developed due to Chakra affecting "Optic Nerve"
As a matter of fact, Optic Nerve is the connector between the retina of the eye (analogous to the film of a reel camera) and the Brain.
And due to the mutation in Uchihas, the Sharingan which is a reflection of that mutation is observed on the Iris of the eye
In short, Sharingan is a result of mutation of chakra from Brain, and not directly from the Iris
Given this fact, it would be impossible to transplant Sharingan, because transplant is replacing the Iris, and it doesn't alter the way in which the recipient's brain transmits chakra into the Optic Nerve. You don't replace the Brain or Optic Nerve in this transplant
OK, let's assume once the Sharingan gets awakened, the Iris somehow retains the chakra signature of whatever the hell it needs to be assumed (which is bs as per Tobirama's statement, and let's assume for argument's sake). In that case, once the sharingan is transplated, the receiver cannot develop it further as his brain doesn't alter chakra transmission to optic nerve as he's a non-Uchiha. But we know Kakashi has improved his Sharingan into MS
So, we have a plot hole no jutsu here. Damn you, Kishi!!
You must be registered for see images
He basically says that the Sharingan is awakened and is developed due to Chakra affecting "Optic Nerve"
As a matter of fact, Optic Nerve is the connector between the retina of the eye (analogous to the film of a reel camera) and the Brain.
And due to the mutation in Uchihas, the Sharingan which is a reflection of that mutation is observed on the Iris of the eye
In short, Sharingan is a result of mutation of chakra from Brain, and not directly from the Iris
Given this fact, it would be impossible to transplant Sharingan, because transplant is replacing the Iris, and it doesn't alter the way in which the recipient's brain transmits chakra into the Optic Nerve. You don't replace the Brain or Optic Nerve in this transplant
OK, let's assume once the Sharingan gets awakened, the Iris somehow retains the chakra signature of whatever the hell it needs to be assumed (which is bs as per Tobirama's statement, and let's assume for argument's sake). In that case, once the sharingan is transplated, the receiver cannot develop it further as his brain doesn't alter chakra transmission to optic nerve as he's a non-Uchiha. But we know Kakashi has improved his Sharingan into MS
So, we have a plot hole no jutsu here. Damn you, Kishi!!
Last edited:
