[Game] Peaky Blinders Mafia Game Thread #24

[Kyte_]

By the way, this is your first appearance since your greeting post, where you've found it necessary to make this post to lash out on STQ/defend PK?

i was just reviewing the thread, and there are some relevant posts that you made earlier, i've missed some pages and decided to get back to it later

 

[Sagebee]

I think PK could be town and he could be the wrong man here, gimme a smoke to think about that, I don't know his voters think there is wolfmentality behind his posts, looks like framing

how About your scum reads and more specifically why do you think hes town

 

[Sagebee]

Alice is like "keep playing kids, imma check your homeworks later"

tbh i like SKs post, except the wall form lenght which makes me scroll down a week to read it, so he looks better now for me.

PK plays minimalist and rather scummy indeed.

I also liked how TSQ in post #308 have the conclusion PK and SoulKiller know each other because is true and shows that TSQ thinks at the game.

I agree pk so far commentary very minimalistic I dont really get the vibe hes trying to find scum and commentary so far on imperfection is unnecessary I like to hear his detailed scum reads.

 

[Sagebee]

I'm not a fan of the progression of the game right now.

Alright, first off, i feel like Michelle starts off playing in a way that he sets as non-serious enough to claim that he's just joking or messing around to his convenience, but if you look at what he's posted at the beginning, it seems like he's trying to find a place for his vote to land without having to do too much work. I also feel like his "good feeling about xEph" was merely a clever manipulation tactic to win favor from a more inexperienced member by just coming out the gate randomly declaring that he has town with flimsy arbitrary reasoning like "Oh, he seems like a good guy" (or is he trying to take suspicion off of him and they both are on the same scum team...?!). Next thing we see is xRph piggybacking Michelle's moves and off it starts with soft-pushing TSQ whose post in question (about AI and whatnot), and which could be very easily written-off as a common jest at the start of the game, was a big pile of absolutely nothing, and the whole argument that followed was uncalled for. It looks like xEph just sort of preemptively decided that TSQ was suspicious once and needed to be propped up as a lynch candidate, on a whim.

If either Michelle and xEph were to flip scum and I still feel the need to look into TSQ's case based on his future actions, that would be mind-blowing honestly, because i don't think they are on the same team, in the time being. However, I won't get to TSQ now, but not to say that he's off the hook atm, to me personally.

Also, I'm not really on board with the faulty logic to throw every new player (aka imperfection) under some blanket of them being meek, timid, and uncomfortable and thus being incapable of being scum, I don't necessarily think he's faking the part where he's inexperienced, but it doesn't mean he's not scum and had any intentions at all to quit, even, especially after he had overdone it with "b-b-but i-i don't understand anything" and now he's gotten back on board faster than i thought with the "I was overthinking, i understand now" mentality.

Another big man is Rej, I was left scratching my head after Rej because he was shooting in the dark in the small-time I've seen him here. It's like he's kinda attempting to win people over, but not really because he's also throwing enough empty accusations elsewhere to shade it. Sure, his self-made list is a draft and wasn't even taken seriously by the majority, but I see that he's bulldozed Michelle and cleared off xEph, which doesn't make much sense since they had been hand in hand at the time (even though I think is feasible), and then he throws big shots like SK and myself at the top as town reads, when we had basically just said hi. I'm actually not the type to jump on people for using their "gut feeling" for reason, but when Michelle among others persistently questioned his list, he ignores him at first and then jumps into clearing his intentions and immediately butters him up about his posts have become more "town-like"

There are others that I'm quite frankly warier of, but my suspicions are ongoing and it only heads the right way if i observe sometimes, and anyone who knows me well knows that i could very possibly abandon these reads and end up casting a vote on someone else entirely. The day is long, and at the very least it has already set us off to a good start to tonight's actions if anything.

Kyte left a good strong impression with this

 

[Sagebee]

Okay after catching up I'm not getting any vibe that these players are genuinely trying to find scum some try to appear engaging but dont add substance. That's ansat, ephemeral, pk, mr lonely, thestatusquo

Since I have more experience with ansat his playing this game and interaction seem really different from what I've seen in other games.

Best interaction is the lowest so far need to hear more from him.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Okay after catching up I'm not getting any vibe that these players are genuinely trying to find scum some try to appear engaging but dont add substance. That's ansat, ephemeral, pk, mr lonely, thestatusquo

Since I have more experience with ansat his playing this game and interaction seem really different from what I've seen in other games.

Best interaction is the lowest so far need to hear more from him.

Why do you think I never tried to find a scum? I already have my PoE so I'm working inside the circle of my PoE.

My PoE right now

TSQ-Ephemeral-Mr.Lonely

One of them I believe is scum. Right Now I'm watching Mr.Lonely. Ephemeral also is not far behind. Both were not really doing any real scum hunting yet.

Its like you never read the thread at all Sagebee.

 

[Ansatsuken]

And my suspect scum players also are the players that happened to be inside your list @Sagebee

 

[Sagebee]

Why do you think I never tried to find a scum? I already have my PoE so I'm working inside the circle of my PoE.

My PoE right now

TSQ-Ephemeral-Mr.Lonely

One of them I believe is scum. Right Now I'm watching Mr.Lonely. Ephemeral also is not far behind. Both were not really doing any real scum hunting yet.

Its like you never read the thread at all Sagebee.

Lile pk your commentary is minimalistic I never said you didnt engage at all just that its minimal and specifically you your level and quality of commentary is drastically different compared to other games I've been with you.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Okay after catching up I'm not getting any vibe that these players are genuinely trying to find scum some try to appear engaging but dont add substance. That's ansat, ephemeral, pk, mr lonely, thestatusquo

Since I have more experience with ansat his playing this game and interaction seem really different from what I've seen in other games.

Best interaction is the lowest so far need to hear more from him.

Tbh you, kyte and me have our focus on some same targets; TSQ and Ephemeral(Three of us), Mr.Lonely(You and me)

So let's decide which one of these three is truly a Mafia.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Lile pk your commentary is minimalistic I never said you didnt engage at all just that its minimal and specifically you your level and quality of commentary is drastically different compared to other games I've been with you.

I currently suffering from connectivity problem bcuz of Lockdown. I have noticed Poison about this problem in the sign up thread. So don't expect me to be super engaging. But I still try my best to contribute.

 

[Sagebee]

Tbh you, kyte and me have our focus on some same targets; TSQ and Ephemeral(Three of us), Mr.Lonely(You and me)

So let's decide which one of these three is truly a Mafia.

I want to wait until the end since this phase will last 3 data tomorrow being last I think so I'll see if anything changes and likely vote the statis wuo

 

[Thestatusquo]

I have a very complicated way of thinking, so if it doesn't make sense, I'm sorry. I speculate details that I may find useful at hinting whether someone is town or not. You don't throw certain words around merely for the fun of it and that was what I was trying to point out. I also thought that he was looking into things about SK that were insignificant as a way of framing him. I was hoping he'd say something in reply to me, but he just brushed it off saying that I'm repeating something that everyone already knows.

I said you’re speculating on misinterpretations

 

[Thestatusquo]

@Ansatsuken I don’t get why from your PoV one of Me - Eph - Mr Lonely HAS to be mafia?

 

[Ansatsuken]

@Ansatsuken I don’t get why from your PoV one of Me - Eph - Mr Lonely HAS to be mafia?

Because I believe one of you is Mafia.

I still 50/50 about your position TSQ

The other two players are devoid of scum hunting effort. Just Chit-chating all the time. That's the best to describe them.

 

[SoulKiller]

Guess I'll put it in different words, just for you

How's the view from the fence, Tommy?

You must be registered for see images

The view looks exactly how I explained it. If you want a refresher ya can go back to my post and read it again. Unless, you have something specific you want to know, which in that case you should be capable of asking it directly, right?

Tbh imperfectionist looked like obvscum to me but i just feel like he got thread spewed

Hmm, do you think he would be a good vig candidate?

This post has me like

You must be registered for see images

This post cracked me up real hard xD

 

[SoulKiller]

@SoulKiller

I am paying kitty mate. Where you at?
You wanna join in on the action?

I bring the action and you know it. But I see you became more active my friend, pressure getting to you yet? the day is near to it's end. Who do you think should be lynched this DP?

Okay after catching up I'm not getting any vibe that these players are genuinely trying to find scum some try to appear engaging but dont add substance. That's ansat, ephemeral, pk, mr lonely, thestatusquo

Since I have more experience with ansat his playing this game and interaction seem really different from what I've seen in other games.

Best interaction is the lowest so far need to hear more from him.

I really like this post of sagebee, I could def see scum inside that list.

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

There's something odd about Sk's approached. I don't know what is it. It gives me chills. The hair on my arms are rising. I feel cold.

Maybe I just need a cup. Of coffee

 

[Michelle]

why am I only knowing this now when I've known you for quite a while? or so I thought...?

idk for real, it's not hidden info

Spoiler: for Kyte

My bad though, I should introduce myself, I am Michelle, my own name is translated in english to form the username because it can't be read in english and is closer of the italian Michaela. I am a lady so I am usually talking nice
I love to read mangas and Naruto made me come here 12 years ago. NB now AB is my homeforum so when a friend invited me to play this game here I said why not, and so i catched the mafia virus.

I've always been the type to lay down my take-aways on finished matters for display. As for ongoing disputes, I tend to speculate as my opinion could fluctuate, but at any rate, I think it’s fair to say that my activity on the first DPs has generally always been questionable. Ultimately I’ll pursue my lynch targets and defend myself once it comes down to it.

I suppose there nothing wrong with considering the unlikely possibilities of you being scum mates with xEph or TSQ? Early disputes could be misleading in a sense, especially if felt forced in particular. I'm not basing off my reads over these mere speculations so I don't see why you're complaining.

Now what I'm concerned about more than his experience level is his style of play in that game you speak off, I'm not one to base off my reads on meta's but I think he's comfortable enough that he had adopted that passive attitude on more than few occasions.

the bolded is really complicated as sentence, avoids a scum read imo but it does express a doubt. If I understand it wrong please correct me.
It's always ok questioning and I hope you find the correct answers. I am not really complaining tbh

His style in the other game was slightly different but because between MU and AB are big differences at activity level I can't say the difference is AI by itself.
If you want to check it, it's the Attorney 9er, and you can find it in manual games (i can't post a link to respect AB general rules).

Though he is kind of holding back...

 

[SoulKiller]

There's something odd about Sk's approached. I don't know what is it. It gives me chills. The hair on my arms are rising. I feel cold.

Maybe I just need a cup. Of coffee

You must be registered for see images

Mind pointing out those "odd" approaches for me? i am quite curious ^^ and yes you def need a cup of coffee : )

 

[SoulKiller]

@Ansatsuken ansa my boi, I am quite frankly, not really sold out on you yet. Something is off about you, I know you said internet connection etc. But it's much more than that I feel, can't place my finger on it yet. Who you planning to cast your vote to this DP? I know you have few selected individuals but who is more likely to get your vote?