6- What kind of a silly argument is this? Why doesn't Boil Release melt Mei and her mouth when she's using it? Why doesn't Amaterasu affect Sasuke when he uses it on his own hand? Why doesn't his hand burn when he uses an Enton sword and literally grasps it within his own hand? Is this even an argument? Why doesn't Amaterasu / Enton affect Sasuke's own Susano'o? Why doesn't the shock wave from Madara's sword obliterate his own PS? I can go on and on here to discredit your childish shot at argumentation.
Not clear on why you're even bringing this up, elucidate
7- Irrelevant points:
1 - Jiraiya sealed it.
2 - Nagato didn't use any chakra based attack to push it off his body. He simply pushed the flames away. He didn't extinguish them.
3 - Petra Path works on all Ninjutsu made up of chakra.
None of these lessen the value of Amaterasu nor do they factor in with the argument that Amaterasu > NE. In fact, these examples are literally worthless for the topic at hand because sealing and PP have nothing to do with NE. If you plan on building an analogy, then learn how to use it first. It's sad that majority of NB still scratches its head when it comes to analogy building or choosing factors that are corollary to the arguments at hand. But you people never learn, do you?
If you learned how to read what bold means, you'll see why the response it what it is. So go look in the dictionary, find out what bold means and go back and read why I responded as I did
8- Even these claims are irrelevant as hell:
- TSBs negate all Ninjutsu save for the ones that have no physical form; Kamui and FTG.
- Kamui has done jack to Amaterasu.
Read above
Let me ask you again, since the whole thing seems to be beyond your reasoning ability:
what do TSBs and Kamui have anything to do with Natural Energy being weak before Amaterasu? Oh wait, absolutely nothing. It's a worthless, let me repeat it again, a worthless and cheap argument with no link to the thread or to the argument.
Read above
Kamui will, for example, work on Kaguya's TSB as well. Now going by your pointless opinions, Kamui >> Kaguya's dimension destroying Kekkei Mora TSB. Does this really work that way? No. Do me a favour and revisit the point above on how to build analogies as you are failing in this department at every turn.
What do TSB and Kaguya's dimension have anything to do with each other let alone Amateratsu. Kamui can warp Amateratsu to the Kamui dimension extinguishing the fire from that plane of existence
9-
Do me a favour again and don't bring science into this. Why? Because you have zero real life examples to explain the concept of Natural Energy and create an argument. I am not even slightly interested or impressed by this intangible argument of yours as the
Buddha Statue is built entirely upon Natural Energy as well and Madara was able to hurt it with PS Sword. This is a fictitious manga and none of the chakra based elements work on science. These elements are not Natural phenomenon but run completely on chakra down to the last chakra drop; they are an imitation of nature. Whatever the author has shown, goes. Don't even go there, or I will embarrass you just like I embarrassed Kidgamer.
When clearly the WOOD has been cut by PS swords. Again, what point are you trying to make. It was your boy that compared Air to NE, not me
Physical energy and mental energy are intangible as well. Your argument is laughable. I asked for a scan, you haven't given me any. Sapped or not sapped, NE dispersed regardless.
You shot yourself in the foot the moment you began this argument. According to you, NE is intangible and cannot be touched by anything, but it's affected by heat regardless?
@Bold, ok so again what's your point?
A scan of whyat? a claim I never made, don't get desperate because you're always getting shat on. Obviously the NE dispersed because like I said in my other post, when a technique is destroyed or been overpowered, the source of whatever powered that technique ceases to exist. You have no proof NE was sapped
You admit yourself that an intangible energy has been affected indefinitely by heat from something physical, but the other side of the argument is so so wrong, because it doesn't sit well with your kiddy arguments?
Do you have any argument and counterargument left after this admission? No, because your entire last paragraphs are worthless because of the argument you yourself established that NE, despite being intangible was dispersed by something physical; in other words, something physical killed the cave that was brought to life with something intangible. If you think you are impressing anyone with this, then you are not, man, because this argument of yours fell flat on its face with your own post.
Ok, quote me where I said the bold
10- Your last two examples don't factor in as well,
as when KB is destroyed the chakra is destroyed, which is why it doesn't return to the user. It's a body made out of Chakra. Only if it is cancelled that the chakra goes back to the user.
Your ET argument is pointless as well, as this technique and Kabuto's IT are not even remotely related. Even then, when Ninjutsu Cancellation element of TSBs is used, the chakra on the portion of ET body it touches is utterly destroyed and even ET cannot heal it.
Tobirama stated that Mintao "would die if he was hit fatally with that technique." It means, that TSB has the capablity to destroy the life-force; something intangible within the body. Similarly, Madara was about to kill Gai by hitting him with a TSB; in other words, he would going to kill him by destroying his life force.
Already addressed the bold in my other claim and it's not relevant to what I was saying anyway. The chakara is not sapped from the user. Rest of the post is irrelevant. Kunais can kill ninja, so do Kunai kill lifeforce as well?
So, what was your argument again? Oh yeah, you don't think NE was sapped, because ... because you say so? I don't think it's a matter of concern then.
