[Game] Our loved Mangakas and their masterpieces Mafia Game #19

[Michelle]

Last Vote Count Day 1

​

3 Sagebee Ansatsuken
Alice in Noodleland
Rej
2 Rej Mothbomb
SoulKiller
1 Ansatsuken TheLukundo
1 NaomiRose LanMisa
1 PoisonChan All_Red
5 Non voting
NaomiRose
PaperBoiKonan
Elmage G Ace
Sagebee
PoisonChan

Sagebee was lynched

they were

Spoiler: Sagebee's role

Spoiler: Sui Ishida ~ Tokyo Ghoul

You must be registered for see images

Welcome Sagebee, you are Unjester.
You win when you are night killed. The game will continue after your wincon will be achieved, until one other faction will met it's wincon.

 

[Michelle]

Night 1 countdown

You must be registered for see links

 

[Michelle]

Night 1 was cruel with one of the most hardworkers of the mangakas and in the morning of day 2 one of them is no more in the game..

Soulkiller is dead, they were

Spoiler: Kentaro Miura ~ Berserk

You must be registered for see images

Welcome SK, you are Vanilla townie.
You win when all the threats to town are eliminated.

 

[Just_Red]

Bruhhhhhhh

 

[Michelle]

Living Players:

1. @All_Red
2. @Rej
3. SoulKiller vanilla town
4. Sagebee unjester
5. @Ansatsuken
6. @Elmage G Ace
7. @Alice in Noodleland
8. @PaperBoiKonan
9. @mothbomb
10. @Poison chan
11. @TheLukundo
12. @LanMisa
13. Naomi_Rose @Conspirator

Substitution:
@Naomi_Rose was replaced by @Conspirator


Day 2 countdown

You must be registered for see links

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

They were really that threatened huh.

@PaperBoiKonan you need to step up and speak.

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

@Elmage G Ace can you give me some your reads. I need some help.

 

[BoiNez]

They were really that threatened huh.

@PaperBoiKonan you need to step up and speak.

Alright sorry. I'm here now.

 

[Just_Red]

Of course they'd kill him. But here's where I think they messed up:
those that killed him must have played with him enough to fear his skill at mafia. Its true that he may be well renowned in this base, but I will choose to believe that it has to be of a close circle of people that were friendly with him or played with him a lot.
That would narrow the search down to these people:
1. @All_Red - played with Sk, has done move like this in the past: killing off players they knew would be a threat to them
7. @Alice in Noodleland - played with SK, is close with SK
10. @Poison chan - played with SK, is close with SK

Honorable mentions:
5. @Ansatsuken - has played with SK. I dont they are close with him though
6. @Elmage G Ace - also has played with SK, they arent close either

You may think, wait this is dumb the people closest with SK would obviously be smart enough to not kill him first round. But the thing is, not many people think this far ahead or even think of this reasoning as a threat. It is only dp1 so a kill on SK shouldnt alarm too many bells. Also when looking at the list, I would argue the players arent the best mafia players, excluding Ansa, and I would think they would pull a stunt like this before.

Of all the people there though, my suspicion, based on dp1 would be on Poison.
Vote Lynch @Poison chan

 

[LanMisa]

Night 1 was cruel with one of the most hardworkers of the mangakas and in the morning of day 2 one of them is no more in the game..

Soulkiller is dead, they were

Spoiler: Kentaro Miura ~ Berserk

You must be registered for see images

Welcome SK, you are Vanilla townie.
You win when all the threats to town are eliminated.

..Wait, WHAT?

 

[BoiNez]

..Wait, WHAT?

@SoulKiller is dead and now he can win if all killers and other threats are eliminated.

 

[Elmage G Ace]

First of all... I thought DP1 was like 3 days (did 3 days pass without me realising :|)

Anyways, yeah, if I was mafia, I'd totally kill Soulkiller first, however, I think most players here already know how good Soulkiller is at mafia, so it could be anyone really.

Now, I have in my sights, @Poison chan @All_Red @Rej @TheLukundo at least one of you is mafia. Give me a moment to prepare my posts

 

[Elmage G Ace]

Also, Sagebee wasn't mafia, so no townie points for voters too

 

[Just_Red]

First of all... I thought DP1 was like 3 days (did 3 days pass without me realising :|)

Anyways, yeah, if I was mafia, I'd totally kill Soulkiller first, however, I think most players here already know how good Soulkiller is at mafia, so it could be anyone really.

Now, I have in my sights, @Poison chan @All_Red @Rej @TheLukundo at least one of you is mafia. Give me a moment to prepare my posts

No. I dont think anyone could've killed him. I believe a select few players could have.

 

[LanMisa]

Of course they'd kill him. But here's where I think they messed up:
those that killed him must have played with him enough to fear his skill at mafia. Its true that he may be well renowned in this base, but I will choose to believe that it has to be of a close circle of people that were friendly with him or played with him a lot.
That would narrow the search down to these people:
1. @All_Red - played with Sk, has done move like this in the past: killing off players they knew would be a threat to them
7. @Alice in Noodleland - played with SK, is close with SK
10. @Poison chan - played with SK, is close with SK

Honorable mentions:
5. @Ansatsuken - has played with SK. I dont they are close with him though
6. @Elmage G Ace - also has played with SK, they arent close either

You may think, wait this is dumb the people closest with SK would obviously be smart enough to not kill him first round. But the thing is, not many people think this far ahead or even think of this reasoning as a threat. It is only dp1 so a kill on SK shouldnt alarm too many bells. Also when looking at the list, I would argue the players arent the best mafia players, excluding Ansa, and I would think they would pull a stunt like this before.

Of all the people there though, my suspicion, based on dp1 would be on Poison.
Vote Lynch @Poison chan

I personally do not think it's Poison, unless I misunderstood something.

Also, you should add another person to that list. If it is about feeling threatened by SoulKiller you need to consider all people SK felt uneasy about. Which would include Rej and myself.

 

[Elmage G Ace]

No. I dont think anyone could've killed him. I believe a select few players could have.

I hope you're not going anywhere soon, I have questions for you

 

[LanMisa]

Also, Sagebee wasn't mafia, so no townie points for voters too

Exactly. We need to treat his flip as if we had mislynched a Vanilla Town yesterday regarding all purposes of the game. The scum team didn't know he was NOT town and thus they had all reason to be okay with his lynch as well.

 

[Alice in Noodleland]

Mafia is not threatened with my deduction skills .

 

[LanMisa]

First of all... I thought DP1 was like 3 days (did 3 days pass without me realising :|)

Anyways, yeah, if I was mafia, I'd totally kill Soulkiller first, however, I think most players here already know how good Soulkiller is at mafia, so it could be anyone really.

Now, I have in my sights, @Poison chan @All_Red @Rej @TheLukundo at least one of you is mafia. Give me a moment to prepare my posts

Interesting list. I'm looking forward to your reasoning.

Can you narrow down the number? "At least" is a bit imprecise.

 

[LanMisa]

Mafia is not threatened with my deduction skills .

From an outsiders perspective, if you are town you make for a fine mislynch at this point in time.