One Piece or Naruto?

Jupiter

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 13, 2011
Messages
3,148
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Are you guys serious? >.> How long have you bee watching OP? 'Till like ep 20? -.-'
You cant judge/compare 2 anime when you haven't watched both of them to the fullest...
I have watched all the episodes of both Naruto and OP several times and I can say proudly that
OP >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Naruto >> Bleach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Heister

Mugiwara

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Apr 25, 2008
Messages
11,625
Kin
24💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Are you guys serious? >.> How long have you bee watching OP? 'Till like ep 20? -.-'
You cant judge/compare 2 anime when you haven't watched both of them to the fullest...
I have watched all the episodes of both Naruto and OP several times and I can say proudly that
OP >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Naruto >> Bleach.
the thread creator wasn't asking which one of them was the better one, he was asking which one would you watch if you could only choose one. So people that haven't seen a single episode of One Piece have the right to choose to continue watching Naruto. They are not judging or comparing them. When they say they rather watch Naruto, since they haven't started watching One Piece, they aren't necessarily saying that Naruto is better than One Piece. They are just saying that at this moment, they would choose to continue watching Naruto instead One Piece (maybe because they haven't watched any episodes of One Piece before).

Oh btw, Bleach aint that close to Naruto..
Its: OP >>> Naruto >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Bleach
 

arv993

Active member
Elite
Joined
Apr 22, 2011
Messages
6,999
Kin
193💸
Kumi
2💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
the thread creator wasn't asking which one of them was the better one, he was asking which one would you watch if you could only choose one. So people that haven't seen a single episode of One Piece have the right to choose to continue watching Naruto. They are not judging or comparing them. When they say they rather watch Naruto, since they haven't started watching One Piece, they aren't necessarily saying that Naruto is better than One Piece. They are just saying that at this moment, they would choose to continue watching Naruto instead One Piece (maybe because they haven't watched any episodes of One Piece before).

Oh btw, Bleach aint that close to Naruto..
Its: OP >>> Naruto >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Bleach
come on bleach is not that bad it had some good arcs, like soul society arc and hueco mundo arc its just not that good now. but i guess that is personal opinion
 

Lili-Chwan

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jun 18, 2009
Messages
19,417
Kin
3,929💸
Kumi
2,318💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I'm starting to hate the "One Piece seems childish"argument, i would like for some Narutard to tell me why it seems so "Childish"

One Piece.
Features are way too round, bodies are disproportional and the expressions are overly exaggerated, all of those are especially noticeable early in the series. Also early in the series, the drawings have very poor quality. In addition to that, the concept of a crew of "kids" gathering together to chase a dream by becoming pirates is a fairly childish-like concept, much like the fact that, like kids playing pirates, they are not interested in matters of Love and Romance or even ***, even though they are all teenagers when they meet up, with the exception of some later acquisitions. Both Graphic and Concept wise, over the years there has been a very clear evolution, and One Piece began approaching more mature matters, while the general childish-like concept remained very evident, and Oda made sure to keep it that way.

But like many other series/movies/books it is up to the reader the interpretation of the story, and especially good stories allow the reader to scope through various layers of content, and find deeper and deeper meanings. While the childish concept maintains, it is not hard to dig deeper into the matters and find more mature and heart warming topics, which would otherwise seem childish, depending of the maturity of the person reading it. One Piece is a marvelous piece of work, that allows us to jump from dream to dream, boarding matters of great importance and emotional charge, while keeping an active juvenile and free spirit, and that is what makes it so great.

So yeah, I'm using rich words to say that it's not One Piece that is childish, it's you, Narutards.
 
Last edited:

Jupiter

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 13, 2011
Messages
3,148
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
the thread creator wasn't asking which one of them was the better one, he was asking which one would you watch if you could only choose one. So people that haven't seen a single episode of One Piece have the right to choose to continue watching Naruto. They are not judging or comparing them. When they say they rather watch Naruto, since they haven't started watching One Piece, they aren't necessarily saying that Naruto is better than One Piece. They are just saying that at this moment, they would choose to continue watching Naruto instead One Piece (maybe because they haven't watched any episodes of One Piece before).

Oh btw, Bleach aint that close to Naruto..
Its: OP >>> Naruto >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Bleach
I wasn't referring to the thread creator I was referring to the ppl who do judge/compare naruto to OP and say OP s*cks while they haven't even watched the first 20-60 episodes (aka Narutards), of which there are many here in the OP subsection.

But ofcourse everyone has his/her own opinion.
 

SageRinnegan

Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2011
Messages
180
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
well, seeing as this is a NARUTO forum, youre going to get kind of a biased opinion. even then, i would still pick naruto, but go to a one piece forum (if there are any) and ask the same question to be sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GRANDcash

DESTRUCTO

Active member
Regular
Joined
Mar 10, 2011
Messages
721
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I tried reading One piece, I really did. It just didn't catch my interest. I didn't care for the character designs, and the writing was a little to basic and "direct" ( could be a translation problem). The rendering on some of the pages was really good, especially for the style of design, which would be tough to render for. I would have to go with Naruto. I love the charcters, always have, ever since the first chapter. I love the realm, and the way things work, ever since the first chapter. One Piece I read to about chapter 40 and it didn't catch me.

Now before you guys say "at chapter 100 it gets really good" why would I waste all that time reading something i don't care about just to "possibly" be impressed. My feeling is that if it doesn't catch me by two or three chapters I'm not going to keep reading it. So in my defense I gave it 20x more of a fighting chance then I normally give comics and i still didn't care for it. Each of us have a right to our opinion, if you guys like it then good for you, however I don't and good for me.
 

Mercy

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 4, 2011
Messages
6,143
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I tried reading One piece, I really did. It just didn't catch my interest. I didn't care for the character designs, and the writing was a little to basic and "direct" ( could be a translation problem). The rendering on some of the pages was really good, especially for the style of design, which would be tough to render for. I would have to go with Naruto. I love the charcters, always have, ever since the first chapter. I love the realm, and the way things work, ever since the first chapter. One Piece I read to about chapter 40 and it didn't catch me.

Now before you guys say "at chapter 100 it gets really good" why would I waste all that time reading something i don't care about just to "possibly" be impressed. My feeling is that if it doesn't catch me by two or three chapters I'm not going to keep reading it. So in my defense I gave it 20x more of a fighting chance then I normally give comics and i still didn't care for it. Each of us have a right to our opinion, if you guys like it then good for you, however I don't and good for me.
I like people like you, youdon't just bash OP. And you have a reason for it, so like you said; Good for you :}
 

Mugiwara

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Apr 25, 2008
Messages
11,625
Kin
24💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I tried reading One piece, I really did. It just didn't catch my interest. I didn't care for the character designs, and the writing was a little to basic and "direct" ( could be a translation problem). The rendering on some of the pages was really good, especially for the style of design, which would be tough to render for. I would have to go with Naruto. I love the charcters, always have, ever since the first chapter. I love the realm, and the way things work, ever since the first chapter. One Piece I read to about chapter 40 and it didn't catch me.

Now before you guys say "at chapter 100 it gets really good" why would I waste all that time reading something i don't care about just to "possibly" be impressed. My feeling is that if it doesn't catch me by two or three chapters I'm not going to keep reading it. So in my defense I gave it 20x more of a fighting chance then I normally give comics and i still didn't care for it. Each of us have a right to our opinion, if you guys like it then good for you, however I don't and good for me.
Atleast you gave it a shot. It's not for everyone :p
But when you have problems catching interest, I tend to watch AMV of some anime or manga I plan on start to read. I might see some awesome stuff in the AMV, and I just start looking forward to that moment in the series when I start reading it :p
 
Top