[Discussion] Oda is a mediocre artist and writer

[Enigmatic]

Wow, I heard about the creator of one piece being sick so i thought id try and read one piece for the first time and boy is it shit, oda is a shitty artist with very basic talents and mediocre as a writer...i dont get why u guys like this?!! The art is terrible! And the writing isnt that much better either!

I swear the art and storyline in soutpark is 3x better than this.

 

[rollin]

what made you come up with that opinion?

 

[-Shiro-]

how far are you ?...cause its acually a good story....dont quit when your in chapt 5...and if u dont like it then just dont read it ...dont come here and trash it like a child

 

[Dark Matter Thief]

Uhhhh.....Well damn.

 

[Loki Helcast]

its all about the characters cant beat luffy for laughs

 

[Uchiha Dan]

Various people have different tastes.
If you don't like your cup of tea, you don't have to spit it all over to those who do.

Show some respect for the creator and the fans.

I ain't even an OP fan..

Peace.

 

[Pekoms]

Wow, I heard about the creator of one piece being sick so i thought id try and read one piece for the first time and boy is it shit, oda is a shitty artist with very basic talents and mediocre as a writer...i dont get why u guys like this?!! The art is terrible! And the writing isnt that much better either!

I swear the art and storyline in soutpark is 3x better than this.

Had you taken more than a cursory look at it, you'd realize that the illustrating improves and the storyline is intricate.
It starts off slow, but in the end... there is a reason why the Japanese love it so much. Don't bash Oda or his work.​

 

[Enigmatic]

I don't mean to insult anyone personally..just sharing my viewpoint and wondering what everyone else thinks and why they stick with it.

 

[Simple Math]

Wow, I heard about the creator of one piece being sick so i thought id try and read one piece for the first time and boy is it shit, oda is a shitty artist with very basic talents and mediocre as a writer...i dont get why u guys like this?!! The art is terrible! And the writing isnt that much better either!

I swear the art and storyline in soutpark is 3x better than this.

exactly how much did you read? cause to me, it sounds like you just looked at the cover and quitted the manga straight after.

either way, whether you like OP or not, the dude has been hospitalized. show some respect atleast :sy:

 

[-Punk-]

I don't mean to insult anyone personally..just sharing my viewpoint and wondering what everyone else thinks and why they stick with it.

You'r voice should be heard too man , Make it Rain ! Make it Rain OP!

You must be registered for see images

 

[Avani]

He knows the art of story telling well and drawing style is something you get used to. There is humour, character quirks, fan service, and action along with a little stories to be solved in individual arcs besides the main ongoing plot which attracts targeted audience.

Not everyone liked action/adventure or the same kind of humour etc so you may not like the genre but then you are limited by your personal likes and dislikes.

 

[Pekoms]

Wow, I heard about the creator of one piece being sick so i thought id try and read one piece for the first time and boy is it shit, oda is a shitty artist with very basic talents and mediocre as a writer...i dont get why u guys like this?!! The art is terrible! And the writing isnt that much better either!

If you weren't trying to insult anyone then you shouldn't have written the bolded segment.
It starts off rough because Oda was still figuring out what he wanted and the first several dozen chapters are buildup.​

 

[GenKiDama]

Oda has created a great manga which I Find more enjoyable than naruto, especially since last chapter was just so god awful, Don't try cause a shitstorm because you want attention for 5 minutes.

 

[ianeustaquio]

Try watching/reading the whole series/manga.
IT WILL BLOW YOUR MIND.

You can't judge the mangaka/manga just by reading a PORTION of his work.


OP>>>>NARUTO :scorps:

 

[rollin]

you dont know what youre going to be missing out on

 

[ssanimo]

i read it every week and i don't really care for it that much......marine-ford war was badass and any parts having to do with ace or shanks i have liked......but the "individual arcs" tend to make it feel like a manga with fillers....and i don't like fillers.......the art is......um unique, not exactly my cup of tea either

i would give it a 5/10 overall

i will say it has some die-hard fans that love to bash kishi and naruto.....lol

 

[Enigmatic]

That kinda explains it. He had no real ending for his story and just makes it up as he goes along, thats where.."the more well-planned" artist/writers like kishi surpasses him. I didn't mean to insult anyone, maybe I should've used better wordchoice

 

[Simple Math]

That kinda explains it. He had no real ending for his story and just makes it up as he goes along, thats where.."the more well-planned" artist/writers like kishi surpasses him. I didn't mean to insult anyone, maybe I should've used better wordchoice

that's just arrogant.

how exactly do you know this ?

 

[Pekoms]

That kinda explains it. He had no real ending for his story and just makes it up as he goes along, thats where.."the more well-planned" artist/writers like kishi surpasses him. I didn't mean to insult anyone, maybe I should've used better wordchoice

No, Oda has had an ending planned since the beginning. However, Oda wasn't sure of his approach.
Oda's story is far more "well-planned" than Kishi's story. Every little thing has a purpose later on in the story.​

 

[Avani]

That kinda explains it. He had no real ending for his story and just makes it up as he goes along, thats where.."the more well-planned" artist/writers like kishi surpasses him. I didn't mean to insult anyone, maybe I should've used better wordchoice

To each his own. It may not be your cup of tea but to really compare the two writers/artists you need to study it more from a neutral POV. Oda has his Plus points just as Kishi. Let's leave it at that.