I don't see how you think that without Gaara or Rubber Dude that Naruto is completely useless, yea Gaara gave him a footing with the sand...WOW that is sooooo much help. How do you know he wouldv'e fell if not for that? He could have stretched out a kyuubi chakra hand to the ground and pushed him self up more, but he had Gaara do it since it seems easier that way doesn't it?
And the Raikage took out everyone, no one in that platoon could beat him, and Naruto comes in and basically rapes him with a rasenshuriken, which you seem to forget that he did ALL BY HIMSELF. Yeah sure he wasn't able to be sealed with just that, but don't you think that that is because of the Edo Tensei? Do you really think that a real Raikage would have survived that attack? It looked like he was pretty beat up after the rasen, if not for the edo he wouldve won there. And yes Rubber Dude helped him escape, but you don't know if he NEEDED dodai to help him, dodai just did. And yes he asked hachibi what happened, BIG DEAL. You do realize Naruto was in Sage Mode when he went against him the second time? And yet he was still able to dodge the raikage's speed and hit him? The raikage, who is known as being the fastest ninjas?
As for the tobi fight, I don't see how Bee catching him when he is falling back means anything. That means he's weak? I'm sure Naruto would have been perfectly fine if Bee didn't use his tentacle to catch him, he was in KM remember? He doesn't get hurt as easily in KM. Plus that was the real Naruto, don't know what it has to do with clones.
Also you seem to be forgetting something, he doesn't just use normal clones. It is a kage bunshin, a high level tech? It splits his chakra into a clone? A clone is basically him himself? It's basically a split of himself, with all his thoughts and actions and moves and chakra and everything. It would be like fighting Naruto himself. Yeah the clones usually suck when he makes a lot and just disappear, but I'm pretty sure that's because he is just using them as a diversionary tactic, and not really trying to go all out with a clone. Yes he splits his chakra evenely between each clone, but HE HAS AN IMMENSE amount of chakra, one clone of his probably has more chakra than most other people since his chakra is so immense.