Nagato Uzumaki vs Itachi Uchiha

[khaydz5]

I seriously think it would be Itachi...heres my logic: Naruto was able to defeat the paths of Pain, all by himself. Pain would have to be kinda weak in a way for that, because Naruto isn't as strong as Sasuke, and Sasuke was up against Itachi and Itachi died competing against him

your logic..is kinda like...below average lol

 

[blackbird31468]

itachi would beat nagato despite haveing the rinnegan itachi was extremly powerful and talanted when he was sick he would be 2 or 3 times stronger if he wasn't.

 

[Kinkaku]

Nagato blows Itachi, he's too much for him.

 

[Mugetsu]

Itachi > Nagato. He was the student of Madara! He is comparable to the most powerful characters in all Naruto....Orochimaru, Sarutobi, Kakashi...etc

 

[Hyperion]

I reckon NAGATO.
He actually had the Rinnegan not like Pain(s)

 

[Heister]

nagato isnt an uzumaki and itachi would win

Nagato was an uzamaki...

But if we're talking about strictly Nagato here, I'll take Itachi.

If we're talking about all 6 paths + nagato, that's a different story.

 

[blackbird31468]

heres what the 3rd databook says about susanoo:



and that is why i voted itachi

same here

 

[fxwarrior]

I think everyoen is mistakeing nagato for the paths of pain =P

 

[Jazzy..]

I seriously think it would be Itachi...heres my logic: Naruto was able to defeat the paths of Pain, all by himself. Pain would have to be kinda weak in a way for that, because Naruto isn't as strong as Sasuke, and Sasuke was up against Itachi and Itachi died competing against him

Yeah I totally agree with you!!! I like the bold words haha
But anyway Itachi would win
My vote goes for Itachi teehee

 

[DESTRUCTO]

Its too hard to say, except for the six paths of pain, we don't know exactly what techniques are from the Rinnegan and which ones were from the bodies he controlled. So can Nagato absorb chakra and chakra based attacks himself? Can he summon whatever he wants? I think the robot guy is a given that his abilities are not rinnegan based. You get what I'm saying? Itachi is sick, don't get me wrong, but we don't know exactly the full extent of of Nagato.

 

[khaydz5]

Itachi > Nagato. He was the student of Madara! He is comparable to the most powerful characters in all Naruto....Orochimaru, Sarutobi, Kakashi...etc

most powerful eh? orochimaru vs nagato? i think nagato would rape him.

sarutobi vs nagato? still think nagato has the upper hand.

kakashi? lol. he cant even handle one akatsuki member.

so i agree with you, itachi is just in the same level as the characters you mention.

but nagato is above their level. lol

 

[Rambo200]

<div class="bbWrapper">Itach of course</div>

 

[Anub]

i'd definitely beat itachi my rinnegan is just to much for him to handle and when he uses the ms it uses up a lot of his chakra.

dude you're not nagato...



And why this thread again? Hoping to gain something new? There an ongoing one...was it necessary?

 

[Lankeysob]

most powerful eh? orochimaru vs nagato? i think nagato would rape him.

sarutobi vs nagato? still think nagato has the upper hand.

kakashi? lol. he cant even handle one akatsuki member.

so i agree with you, itachi is just in the same level as the characters you mention.

but nagato is above their level. lol

Kakashi almost beat the Deva path before the other path sacrificed itself for him. As for the question at hand, assuming Nagato had all the abilities of the six paths, I'd vote for him.

 

[khaydz5]

Kakashi almost beat the Deva path before the other path sacrificed itself for him. As for the question at hand, assuming Nagato had all the abilities of the six paths, I'd vote for him.

its nowhere near "almost" dude. he didnt even scratch deva. and he died in top of that. lol.