MS Sasuke vs. Rock Lee and Kiba

Bogard

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Reaction score
2,378
Bold is still wrong. Every shinobi's movement speed is faster than their striking speed. 6G Gai managed to blitz Kisame without him even processing a thought [ ] (top panel) but yet he was able to process a few thoughts (albeit just barely) when Gai struck [ ]. His movement speed is faster than his striking speed. Evidence is right there. Gai had to use his movement speed to get behind Madara. The 2nd Step's punch is faster but Gai still had to go completely around Madara to land that 2nd Step [ ][ ]. That's a blitz.
I didn't explain myself well here sorry. I meant to compare his running speed to his attack speed. Gai pushes air. The act of pushing the air is Gai's striking speed, but the speed in which the air travels to hit the target is actually his attack speed. It's that attack speed i'm referring to while saying it's faster than his running/movement speed

@bold, yes, there was an opening from behind him, so Gai had to go completely around him and then use 2nd Step.
He was already going while releasing the punch [ ] So Madara covering himself was part of his plan to attack him from behind

The sensing is all passive. He's sensing even when he's using his eyes. Juubito's using both eyes there yet he still senses the build-up of chakra in Sasuke's left eye [ ]. So that shows sensing by being the Juubi's host is passive but what's more is that SM sensing is also passive [ ]. Doesn't matter whether he needs to sense or not, it's always there.
Minato was also capable to sense Obito behind him, so Madara reacting to Tobirama behind him isn't a proof the SM sensing is passive [ ]. Actually it tend to prove even the contrary since he failed to notice Tobirama's approach until the last second. As for the Jubi Jin, it's possible though. Although i'm not totally convinced considering how inconsistent the sensing ability can be in this manga

He didn't need to go at full speed because he knew Madara was completely trapped by the 4th Step. He knew that Madara was forced to wrap himself up in an Onmyoudon sphere because he could no longer move. Gai had done his job of not allowing Madara a single opening to attack [ ].
No, the job would be done when he actually finished the evening elephant movement. The plan was to hit him continuously with the 5steps without leaving openings. He was only at the 4th step at that moment, so the combo wasn't complete and he was still in the process to finish the combo

Wow. Gai's not retarded enough to attack anyone straight forward and so I'd certainly hope he wouldn't against the Juubi's host. You're grasping at straws here.
We've seen 8gated Gai going full speed from the beginning of the chapter to the end. Did Madara just at one point even showed difficulties to follow his speed? I don't think

1- Madara following and calmly analyzing Gai's air kicking speed [ ]

2- Madara still following his speed(bottom left panel) [ ]

3- Madara blocking the first punch [ ] while continuing to track Gai who was behind him. Notice as well that on the bottom left panel, the onmyoudon black sphere was still feeling the pressure of the first punch. On the following page, Gai took advantage of this by using another range air cannon attack with Madara this time unable to block

4- Madara could still follow Gai, but because he was immobilised due to previous air cannon attacks, he covers himself while attacking Gai with the black spheres [ ]

At no point, did Madara show trouble following and countering 8gated Gai's speed. The trouble was more concerning the speed of the air cannon attacks [ ]


Lol, they both say the exact same thing, plus, I'm gonna trust MS since they spend more time on their scans and translations than MP.
No, MS only has better screenshot. Their translations are always exaggerated to the point it sometimes changes completely the sense of the japanese script. MP's translation however while lacking the cleaning department, their translation are simple, straight to the point and most of the time accurate

I see you asked for the viz already anyway. And according to the viz, Minato said

"Just Keep forging on, Guy, no matter what!!"

So Minato basically told him to keep his speedy approach on Madara, which clears up the point about Gai's running speed at that moment

...

That isn't air currents. You do know that's dust kicked up from the ground?
Lol maybe. But that would also mean they are so fast it creates circles of dust :p
 

Touken

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Apr 3, 2013
Messages
4,499
Reaction score
245
I didn't explain myself well here sorry. I meant to compare his running speed to his attack speed. Gai pushes air. The act of pushing the air is Gai's striking speed, but the speed in which the air travels to hit the target is actually his attack speed. It's that attack speed i'm referring to while saying it's faster than his running/movement speed
Now you're confusing me. The speed of which Sekizo is almost instant; as soon as Gai strikes, the air pressure that takes form of an elephant's foot is almost instantly created [ ][ ]. If anything, that 2nd scan shows it's slower than Gai's striking and movement speed, considering there's a very tiny delay between when he punches and when the Step is formed.
He was already going while releasing the punch [ ] So Madara covering himself was part of his plan to attack him from behind
Just because he planned it doesn't discredit it. If Madara easily reacted to Gai then he would have used 2 of his other orbs to cover his blindside. Lemme add that it wasn't part of his plan to have Madara block an attack, why would Gai want that if it means he does less overall damage to him?
Minato was also capable to sense Obito behind him, so Madara reacting to Tobirama behind him isn't a proof the SM sensing is passive [ ]. Actually it tend to prove even the contrary since he failed to notice Tobirama's approach until the last second. As for the Jubi Jin, it's possible though. Although i'm not totally convinced considering how inconsistent the sensing ability can be in this manga
It took a few seconds to register Obito was there, whereas Madara instantly sensed and reacted and he had no reason to sense there. Sensing ability isn't inconsistent, especially not with Juubi hosts.
No, the job would be done when he actually finished the evening elephant movement. The plan was to hit him continuously with the 5steps without leaving openings. He was only at the 4th step at that moment, so the combo wasn't complete and he was still in the process to finish the combo
He had no reason to go at full movement speed after his 4th Step.
We've seen 8gated Gai going full speed from the beginning of the chapter to the end. Did Madara just at one point even showed difficulties to follow his speed? I don't think

1- Madara following and calmly analyzing Gai's air kicking speed [ ]
He was going full speed until the 5th Step. Gai wasn't advancing towards Madara when he started kicking up the air, he was just moving up.
2- Madara still following his speed(bottom left panel) [ ]

3- Madara blocking the first punch [ ] while continuing to track Gai who was behind him. Notice as well that on the bottom left panel, the onmyoudon black sphere was still feeling the pressure of the first punch. On the following page, Gai took advantage of this by using another range air cannon attack with Madara this time unable to block
He was able to block his 1st Step but was unable to with Gai's 2nd. You can see that it only takes 2 orbs to form a shield [ ] (top left panel) and if he comfortably reacted to Gai's 2nd Step, another 2 orbs would have formed and blocked that attack. The Onmyoudon shield absorbed the full impact of the 1st Step which is why Madara took no damage from it, so no, it didn't hinder Madara from using 2 other orbs to block the 2nd Step. Lemme add that Madara just barely blocked his 1st Step, in the top left panel you can see he wasn't even facing Gai, he was at an angle. It's also the reason why Madara commented on Gai being fast. (Viz translation: "He is fast.")
4- Madara could still follow Gai, but because he was immobilised due to previous air cannon attacks, he covers himself while attacking Gai with the black spheres [ ]
Again, he wasn't going at full speed against his 5th Step. He wasn't able to follow Gai when he used all his other Steps (hence why he didn't cover himself earlier) but when Gai used his final Step he was suddenly able to follow and thus cover himself in his shield. Why? Because he wasn't going at full speed. Unless you're implying 6G Lee has faster reactions than 8G Gai and was able to throw Minato's kunai fast enough to land it in front of him before Gai himself covered the distance between him and the orbs in his full movement speed. Everything points to Gai not being in full speed with his 5th Step. Another possible reason as to why he didn't go full speed with his 5th Step is because Gai decided to hit Madara directly with his punch. I wouldn't be going at full speed if I had to get up close to someone and that someone is extremely fast.
At no point, did Madara show trouble following and countering 8gated Gai's speed. The trouble was more concerning the speed of the air cannon attacks [ ]
Yet he could only notice Gai when he was about to use his air cannon attack [ ][ ]; he couldn't notice him while he was using his movement speed.
No, MS only has better screenshot. Their translations are always exaggerated to the point it sometimes changes completely the sense of the japanese script. MP's translation however while lacking the cleaning department, their translation are simple, straight to the point and most of the time accurate
Some translations are better in MS than in MP when compared to Viz. For example, MS were spot on with explaining (through Lee) what Sekizo is meant to do (MS) [ ] (MP) [ ] -
Viz said:
Lee: "He stopped partway?!"
(The Sekizo is supposed to be a continuous attack that can be shifted up in speed from one to five times...)
MS does exaggerate sometimes like with Kakashi talking about the vision in his eye but MP is not always superior to MS in translations.
I see you asked for the viz already anyway. And according to the viz, Minato said

"Just Keep forging on, Guy, no matter what!!"

So Minato basically told him to keep his speedy approach on Madara, which clears up the point about Gai's running speed at that moment
That statement has no references to Gai's movement speed whatsoever. He told him to carry on going with no matter to what Madara does.
Lol maybe. But that would also mean they are so fast it creates circles of dust :p
Tiny circles of dust. These are much, much inferior speeds to Gai's speed when you compare little circles of dust and massive air currents.
 
Last edited:

~Sky~

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 19, 2012
Messages
6,871
Reaction score
600
With intel they'd be blocking LOS from the start with smoke bombs.
 
Top