Minato's plan Vs Itachi's plan

[~Uzumaki~]

They set things in motion to take place even after their death. Who's plan was better?

 

[Yanto]

both was good

 

[BusinessManTeno]

Its obvious Itachi planned failed

 

[Kakashi Kid]

Well minato's plan was kind of spur of the moment and he didn't have time to think about it much but it turned out perfectly. Itachi had more time to think about it and it failed, Sasuke found out about the truth of why itachi killed the clan and is now working with tobi to destroy the leaf.
Minato's plan

 

[Necron]

Its obvious Itachi planned failed

nope... Nothing is lost yet... We don't know the last part of Itachi's plan, so you can't say that for sure... U_U

 

[Killahkels]

Minato Itachi plan was to make Sasuke a hero through hatred wtf fail

 

[Yanto]

Its obvious Itachi planned failed

agreed

 

[Hexuze]

both?

 

[Yanto]

both?

not both failed only itachi failed

 

[PUU]

Minato's plan was better, Naruto has practically become the strongest ninja

 

[jtolliver87]

Its not Itachi's fault his plan failed

 

[~Uzumaki~]

I saY Minato but i have to credit Itachi for even coming up with a plan at age 13. Minato at that age was dreaming to be hokage and rescuing red heads

 

[Pradhan Tuna]

well Itachi had to kill many Uchihas,but himself remained alive to set his plan rolling.. while minato saved all and sacrificed his life to set his plan rolling... Now you be the judge whose plan was better.

 

[Shisui Namikaze]

Well minato's plan was kind of spur of the moment and he didn't have time to think about it much but it turned out perfectly. Itachi had more time to think about it and it failed, Sasuke found out about the truth of why itachi killed the clan and is now working with tobi to destroy the leaf.
Minato's plan

This

 

[jtolliver87]

based purely on the circumstances im gonna go with minato simply because his plan actually worked..while as far as itachi goes any plan that involves genocide is usually bad

 

[partha420]

Well minato's plan was kind of spur of the moment and he didn't have time to think about it much but it turned out perfectly. Itachi had more time to think about it and it failed, Sasuke found out about the truth of why itachi killed the clan and is now working with tobi to destroy the leaf.
Minato's plan

though itachis plan was eventually failed, but we cant deny his contribution......He sacrifised more....

 

[stinkey]

j man's plan is the best it included all the main events

 

[Yanto]

Its not Itachi's fault his plan failed

i think it realy did not fail since he turned good in the end

 

[kotoamatsukami]

itachi had to plan much harder than minato he had to take down 1 of the main villains he kne nonthing bout...his plan was to put kototsukami as a bac up an would have worked but he put his trust in naruto....an minato plan had to work we talking bout the main person of the show..

 

[Eternal Nine Tailed Fox]

I think minato...even though Itachi was selfish....minato wasn't he saved the village saved his son.. And he did that as the parent not as fourth homages duty to save naruto