Minato vs Itachi threads(debate with manga portrayal)

[BloodSeed]

Your forgetting that none of those characters saw the full potential of Itachi's power and intellegence. If they saw what Itachi went through and how he planned ahead for everything they would probably have a change of heart. Minato saved Konoha, Itachi saved the Shinobi world.

itachi fails to saved the shinobi world when he failed to kill tobi and edo madara. the manga is not over but in the end you will realize that it was minato who saved the shinobi world by giving naruto the 9 tails to stop the jubii tobi and madara

 

[Boston Rob]

When itachi activates susanoo all minato weapons arsenal is useless

 

[Bogard]

all I can see here is that you can't accept the fact that itachi > minato anyday And all these manga that you show about minato was in part 1 well most of it in part 2 a lot of people surpass minato and itachi is one of them I used to like minato but because of fanboys I hate him soo to make it short and sweet itachi>minato

It's the contrary for me. I used to like Itachi a lot until i came in NB where i saw how overrated Itachi was

 

[lsgteam]

The manga never compared Minato and Itachi yet. None of ur posts implied what the manga states/what Kishi thinks. According to u this noone except Naruto can surpass Minato. So according to u Minato>all which is nonsense.

 

[BloodSeed]

When itachi activates susanoo all minato weapons arsenal is useless

fail to realize that using susano make your chakra burn out. minato would just stand still. who do you think would get tired?

 

[~Sovereign~]

When itachi activates susanoo all minato weapons arsenal is useless

susano cant touch minato

itachi will just be wasting his chakra which he already doesnt have alot of

 

[Sea Of Thy Soul]

Itachi >>> Minato.

No words can ever describe the severe painful punishment Itachi's Tsukuyomi would put Minato through.

The fight would end in a oneshot, with Itachi being the victor. IMO.

 

[The Hidden Shinobi]

Itachi brings out Sword of Totsuka, Minato will have to use RDS. Spirit fight. Draw

Was just about to make a battle between them on my youtube page, going to make it epic

 

[zeuspater]

i agree: minato>itachi.

 

[celarian]

The Student always surpasses the master like Minato surpassed his, this proves that Minato is stronger because in Naruto when itachi and kisame went for naruto, he mentioned Jiraiya would defeat them and if there were more the outcome would be the same. So Minato is stronger

But jaraya didnt surpass hiruzen, sakura hasnt surpassed kakashi, niether have ino, shika or choji for asuma, kakashi is minato's student but he hasnt surpased him, omio hasnt surpassed Killer be. There us no truth in that statement. Itachi was just lying to kasime so they could leave, kasime himself says that they could have. as they are fleeing he say "we could have...." but itachi's glance stops him, meaning that they could have either beaten jaraya or taken naruto. I personally think that itachi purposefully didnt take naruto because he still cares for the village, which i think is the main reason he didnt kill anyone from the village after the massacre. Remember itachi could have simply Amaterasu in jaraya's face and it would have been over.

 

[Brooks]

Genjutsu>any type of speed people including FTG

 

[KingHashirama]

Of course according to the manga: all 5 hokages > Itachi. Yes even Tsunade...... this is common sense by now..

But if we analyze it ourselves then .. its a different story.

^_^

 

[Shisui Namikaze]

Great thread. Minato is so underrated here. It's a shame.

 

[SoulKiller]

Great thread. Minato is so underrated here. It's a shame.

Underrated? He is one of the most overrated character and is hyped as hell by his fanboys

 

[Geeserock]

itachi fails to saved the shinobi world when he failed to kill tobi and edo madara. the manga is not over but in the end you will realize that it was minato who saved the shinobi world by giving naruto the 9 tails to stop the jubii tobi and madara

Minato and Itachi they both gave their life to protect the shinobi world. Dieing doesn't make their sacrifice unworthy. They both predicted the future quite accurately. So, from my point of view they are equal.

 

[celarian]

As far as in who would win in a fight, i think itachi.
Itachi would not be foolish enough to be caught in a reaper death seal. As far a taijutsu I think his is better than minato's going of what is shown of his past like, when oro first saw him.
Since minato's main tactical advantage is his teleportation tags, he wouldnt be able to tag itachi, remember itachi is a anbu level ninja who knows everything about minato, he would have had all information about the hokage at his disposal.
Itachi even though in an incomplete manga fights oro without sharringan, and wins.
So in my opinion Itachi > Minato

 

[celarian]

Minato and Itachi they both gave their life to protect the shinobi world. Dieing doesn't make their sacrifice unworthy. They both predicted the future quite accurately. So, from my point of view they are equal.

itachi gave his life to give sasuke ms, and hiruzen was ready to seal nine tails as soon as he arrived

 

[Brusky]

Your forgetting that none of those characters saw the full potential of Itachi's power and intellegence. If they saw what Itachi went through and how he planned ahead for everything they would probably have a change of heart. Minato saved Konoha, Itachi saved the Shinobi world.

itachi saved the shinobi world? evidence pls? look at wats going on now and who is tryin to save it for real. if anything he made it worst. his eyes went to ungreatful brother who is bent up on meaninless revengee and if he DOES destroy the leaf with no one to stop him he prolly not be satisfied till the world is down under also. itachi saught to make the future better but made it worst thus whhy he said he failed. and also minato>itachi.

 

[Omnipotent]

This thread coming from the person who believes Minato > the five Kage together and Minato > Hashirama

 

[Brooks]

Of course according to the manga: all 5 hokages > Itachi. Yes even Tsunade...... this is common sense by now..

But if we analyze it ourselves then .. its a different story.

^_^

You must be registered for see images

Itachi>Tsunade...Itachi>Hiruzen...Itachi>Tobirama...Itachi=Minato


Only Hashirama is stronger than Itachi..fact