well Itachi worked with Madara for years and didnt kill him is that a fail?
Like I said; people tend to look at what Itachi failed at and forget about everything he did right. Itachi might have not killed "Tobi" but Minato had a very good chance and if he had killed him at that moment, Naruto would not have to go through what he has, Uchiha might not have thought of the uprising and Itachi would not have been known as a mass murderer, Sasuke would still be in Leaf and there would never be this war.
We don't know what exactly went down after Itachi joined Akatsuki. We don't even know when Tobi came out of the shadows of Akatsuki; we know that he was considered a newbie in the Akatsuki by the time Shippuden started.
Fact is; neither Itachi nor Minato spilled the info about Madara. Itachi had his mission or some sort of deal made with Tobi and Minato wanted to stop the 9-tails right then because it was more important than Tobi.
Your post is not only in favour of Minato but also against Itachi. This is why I reminded you that Itachi is not the only one who experienced failure. This thread is comparing both of them, not putting one's failures against the other's.
matter fact tobi/madara escaped as the same thing i think with the shodaime but at the he will die with the yondaime's technique left to naruto (yondaile's legacy)
No. Madara was KILLED vs. Shodaime. It was written in history. The history is not always accurate but do we even know if Tobi is Madara? We can only take his word for it.
He will die by Naruto. His is not entirely Yodaime's legacy. There are countless ninjas who played a role in helping Naruto achieve this peace. Itachi and Minato are two of the many. This is exactly what Itachi was mentioning in the recent manga.
I think that makes them exactly the same...Minato could have killed people all the time and yet he didn't. He let Bee and A live when he could have killed them fairly easily.
Bee had a knife against Minato too, he didn't necessarily let them live.
You must be registered for see images