I haven't had a solid look through everything yet, but lets address this just for a moment.
You are leaning on Gutsy because of certain interactions as you call it. Can you specify these interactions exactly and give an analysis of your thought process here.
Lets take the last game into account. You hard pressed me and convinced many town as well as mafia to turn my way, I lived through sheer luck at the time and when I did eventually die it was confirmed I was a basic townie.
Going by your last game you seem to lock in to one person and press but not really give a whole lot of reasons for this. Of course I am only going by your last game since that is the only one I have played with you and it was for very little time.
This being said. I have seen quite a few of Gutsy's posts. He is starting to take what could be called as 'Town Lead' at least from my view. I have seen first hand how this can turn out from how Waluigi played this who took the lead and turned out to be a Wolf.
While I am not yet convinced of Gutsy's role I will be keeping a close eye on him so if you can give me a run down on your thought process on why you have a suspicious feeling towards him that would be very helpful