[Spoilers] Madara's True Identity

[Anub]

I usually don't jump to other conclusions ... but there are fact that can lead us to obito ... so can you tell me 100% that tobi is madara ?

 

[master of the sharingan]

leafninja.com is written by some guy who thinks thats what happened. its not like kishi wrote that. And its never been proven that that happened so its just whta he thinks and is probably wrong.

he doesnt evan act like obito./....
obito never acts goofy the whole time hes either mad at kakashi or preaching about self displine......
he never acts goofy....

 

[The Merciless]

I didn't want to start a new thread for this only question about madara, so i'll post in this one. When Madara took his brother's eyes, just why didn't he gave his eyes to his brother in exchange? Both would have gained the EMS and everyone would have been happy. Am i missing a point or this makes no sense?

 

[twistedlink]

I didn't want to start a new thread for this only question about madara, so i'll post in this one. When Madara took his brother's eyes, just why didn't he gave his eyes to his brother in exchange? Both would have gained the EMS and everyone would have been happy. Am i missing a point or this makes no sense?

Ive always wondered this too....no idea really.

 

[Kazamori]

I didn't want to start a new thread for this only question about madara, so i'll post in this one. When Madara took his brother's eyes, just why didn't he gave his eyes to his brother in exchange? Both would have gained the EMS and everyone would have been happy. Am i missing a point or this makes no sense?

haha yeah really ... why not ?

 

[Achilles]

Im Confused About all dese discussions i thnk madara is not madara himself..i mean madara uses obito's body thts why he said "My Power Uchiha Madara True power" as he was using obito's body....

n other important point is tht madara is quiet old he needs a body "Uchiha's Body" to preserve himself so the body avaliable 2 him was obito's...Just like oro transfered himself into other body instead of waiting 4 sasuke as he hardly have no time left...

Madara also said tht he intentionally hid some truths from Itachi otherwise he would have been killed by now... n truth may b about his body

 

[master of the sharingan]

I didn't want to start a new thread for this only question about madara, so i'll post in this one. When Madara took his brother's eyes, just why didn't he gave his eyes to his brother in exchange? Both would have gained the EMS and everyone would have been happy. Am i missing a point or this makes no sense?

because you like fuse the yes...
you need both eyes.

 

[Zero]

I didn't want to start a new thread for this only question about madara, so i'll post in this one. When Madara took his brother's eyes, just why didn't he gave his eyes to his brother in exchange? Both would have gained the EMS and everyone would have been happy. Am i missing a point or this makes no sense?

well madara was already blind, so madara's brother would have recieved Blind eyes and it would'nt have worked like that, Madara got EMS bcuz he replaced his eyes with brand new good ones u kno?

 

[The Merciless]

well madara was already blind, so madara's brother would have recieved Blind eyes and it would'nt have worked like that, Madara got EMS bcuz he replaced his eyes with brand new good ones u kno?

yeah yeah i guess you're right, im not sharingan specialist so this explanation sounds just right to me.

 

[twistedlink]

So his brother never used his MS at all??

the manga stated they both killed there friends to obtain the Mangekyou, and madara (the older brother) became the leader, surely his brother used his mangekyou as well??

But youre right, if you look madara has his brothers mangekyou pattern and his own pattern as well...

 

[champs07]

hell no

eh,no......madara stole obitos eye.... go to leafninja.com they have awnsers to all your wired questions

madara did not steal obitos eyes i now this for a fact because madara took his little brothers eyes before they helped frickin build konoha it was in a manga on narutobase its self.
so there is no way he would need obitos eyes.


besides obito lost BOTH his eyes on that fateful night.
one to kakashi and the other to the damn rock

Ive always wondered this too....no idea really.

because madaras eyes had already lost their light so it would be useless.

I didn't want to start a new thread for this only question about madara, so i'll post in this one. When Madara took his brother's eyes, just why didn't he gave his eyes to his brother in exchange? Both would have gained the EMS and everyone would have been happy. Am i missing a point or this makes no sense?

madaras eyes had already lost their light so madaras little bro would be blind.

So his brother never used his MS at all??

the manga stated they both killed there friends to obtain the Mangekyou, and madara (the older brother) became the leader, surely his brother used his mangekyou as well??

But youre right, if you look madara has his brothers mangekyou pattern and his own pattern as well...

it states in the manga that madara lost his light first.

 

[Zero]

So his brother never used his MS at all??

the manga stated they both killed there friends to obtain the Mangekyou, and madara (the older brother) became the leader, surely his brother used his mangekyou as well??

But youre right, if you look madara has his brothers mangekyou pattern and his own pattern as well...

Everybody's MS is different look for example Kakashi's supposably it doe'snt make him go blind it just puts alot of strain and tension on his body so maybe Madara's lil bros' was similar to that (thoery)

yeah yeah i guess you're right, im not sharingan specialist so this explanation sounds just right to me.

I like to think I know wat I'm talking about lol jk